4 ms·

> what it really needs is for that isometric graphics mod to become a full UI layer Ugh, no. Isometric views are a nightmare for usability. They look nice, b

by Freaky 10y ago

> what it really needs is for that isometric graphics mod to become a full UI layer Ugh, no. Isometric views are a nightmare for usability. They look nice, but they obscure things and make for particularly error-prone tile selection, which is just poison in a game where that's the main thing you're doing. I'd look to Prison Architect and RimWorld for UI inspiration, not Stonesense and Gnomoria.

tomc1985 10y ago
Alright fine, whatever, minor details. Isometric, fully 3d, 2d, who cares? Nearly anything is better than what it is right now.
- imdsm 10y ago
  I'm happy for people to augment DF with things like Armok vision and all the other tools, but I don't want DF to change in itself. That would totally ruin it. It's perfect how it is right now. RimWorld is fantastic, but it is a grain of sand compared to the beach that is DF. Which game would you prefer? The good lucking shallow one, or the feature-rich but slightly-less-sightly one?
  - tomc1985 10y ago
    Why is it always this binary comparison? It doesn't have to be good looking. It doesn't have to pretty. It doesn't need to be 3d, or need all these fancy bells and whistles. Nowhere has that been suggested (at least in anything I've written), yet people nonetheless frame their answers in this artificial contrast. Once again: just make the UI intuitive. Make things behave as normal. Grant a few hooks into the GUI code so the community can create their own without having to reverse engineer your game. That is all!
    - Freaky 10y ago
      > It doesn't need to be 3d, or need all these fancy bells and whistles. Nowhere has that been suggested (at least in anything I've written) You literally just suggested a pretty isometric visualiser become the new basis for the game UI. That's a bit like complaining that vim is obtuse and to fix it we should switch its rendering engine to use proportional fonts. > just make the UI intuitive Oh yes, "just" do that. If you actually have something new to suggest, feel free to contribute: http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?board=5.0 http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?board=5.0 Generally the attitude is perpetually "yes, it'd be nice, but then we also want all this other stuff". And at the end of the day, Toady does what Toady does, he doesn't owe us anything.

by Freaky 10y ago

tomc1985 10y ago

Alright fine, whatever, minor details. Isometric, fully 3d, 2d, who cares? Nearly anything is better than what it is right now.

imdsm 10y ago
I'm happy for people to augment DF with things like Armok vision and all the other tools, but I don't want DF to change in itself. That would totally ruin it. It's perfect how it is right now. RimWorld is fantastic, but it is a grain of sand compared to the beach that is DF. Which game would you prefer? The good lucking shallow one, or the feature-rich but slightly-less-sightly one?
- tomc1985 10y ago
  Why is it always this binary comparison? It doesn't have to be good looking. It doesn't have to pretty. It doesn't need to be 3d, or need all these fancy bells and whistles. Nowhere has that been suggested (at least in anything I've written), yet people nonetheless frame their answers in this artificial contrast. Once again: just make the UI intuitive. Make things behave as normal. Grant a few hooks into the GUI code so the community can create their own without having to reverse engineer your game. That is all!
  - Freaky 10y ago
    > It doesn't need to be 3d, or need all these fancy bells and whistles. Nowhere has that been suggested (at least in anything I've written) You literally just suggested a pretty isometric visualiser become the new basis for the game UI. That's a bit like complaining that vim is obtuse and to fix it we should switch its rendering engine to use proportional fonts. > just make the UI intuitive Oh yes, "just" do that. If you actually have something new to suggest, feel free to contribute: http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?board=5.0 http://www.bay12forums.com/smf/index.php?board=5.0 Generally the attitude is perpetually "yes, it'd be nice, but then we also want all this other stuff". And at the end of the day, Toady does what Toady does, he doesn't owe us anything.