3 ms·
That isn't really a solution, because most employees are ignorant or don't care about noncompetes. If you don't sign the noncompete, the company very well migh
by stale2002 10y ago
That isn't really a solution, because most employees are ignorant or don't care about noncompetes.
If you don't sign the noncompete, the company very well might recind your job offer.
The REAL solution is when you leave a company, you just completely ignore the non-compete, and do whatever the hell you want.
It is enormously risky for a company to go after former employees, especially engineers.
It costs time, money, and for all they know, the former employee saved a bunch of passwords and is crazy, and will cause a million dollars in damages.
If you break a non-compete, the chances of someone actually going after you is exceedingly slim, due to how dangerous you COULD be if you wanted.
- tdicola 10y agoAny reasonably sized company is going to have the dollars and IT smarts to not worry about former employees causing damage (passwords, keycard access, etc. are all immediately cut off on the day of leaving.. and any actual damage someone does is grounds for a likely felony-level criminal case with years behind bars). As others have mentioned they don't even need to take people to court to enforce a non-compete--just the fact that a former employee is under a non-compete is enough to scare away and stop potential new employers (read the comments on this page to see examples of this). By making the non-compete something the company has to pay for it pushes it more into the realm of only applying to people that absolutely need it (high level executives, critical engineers, etc.) and who will be compensated while under it.
- stale2002 10y agoHow about IP being leaked? EX: saving all your code on a flashdrive on the 1 day that you work from home. Sometimes crazy people do stupid things. Obviously you should never actually do something like that, but from the companies perspective, an X% chance of millions in damages is a stupid risk to take, for little benefit.
- lsc 10y ago>Any reasonably sized company is going to have the dollars and IT smarts to not worry about former employees causing damage (passwords, keycard access, etc. are all immediately cut off on the day of leaving.. At least on the sysadmin side? The only way to be sure that someone who once had root on your server no longer has root on that server is to wipe and re-install using scripts that person didn't develop/sources that person didn't control. Of course, you kill the logins, but there are a million ways to leave a hard to detect backdoor... and many of those are impossible to distinguish from a simple mistake. This is definitely something you need to worry about; and at the very minimum, you go out of your way to make sure you don't piss off ex employees more than you have to. Yes, yes, if you have your whole process in source control, that's great, and will really help when trying to track down who put in the back door (However, can you prove it was a backdoor and not just, you know, a dumb mistake that left a security hole open? Innocent mistakes of this type are pretty common.) - even then, what of the sysadmins who have root on your revision control server? (this is actually an area where smaller shops, which tend to just use git, have an advantage; it's way harder for the repo owner to insert something without anyone noticing on a git system, say, than a more centralized setup like perforce, which tends to get used by the much larger companies.) For that mater, even the ground-pounding so-called "rebooter monkeys" have a lot more power than you think. Anyone who has root on your workstation, even for a short period of time, can cause all sorts of mayhem, and worse, make it look like you did it, for some time to come. >and any actual damage someone does is grounds for a likely felony-level criminal case with years behind bars). I mean, I'm not saying you couldn't make things pretty miserable for the perpetrator, you could. but that doesn't really help the business that was harmed. It does provide a pretty good deterrent. but that's why the comment you are responding to was talking about "crazy" - there are people who do things that are not in their long term best interest, and if those people have root on your systems, or access to your codebase, they can do more damage to you than you can possibly hope to recover from them. It's a pretty rare sysadmin who couldn't do millions of dollars in damage to his or her employer; and a pretty rare sysadmin who has the assets/insurance to cover a judgment that large.
- __jal 10y agoSure, go ahead, if that works for you. But: - It is risky for the employee. Just how risky depends on a ton of factors like the company they're leaving, the company they're joining, what skills they have/who they are, perceived scarcity of talent, and probably how litigious managers feel that week/the phase of the moon. Most employees have far fewer lawyers and less money than, e.g., Amazon. If they come at you, odds are pretty good that even if you win, you lose. - It is risky for your new employer. Just how risky depends on ... (see above). If you (employee coming in under an NDA) don't tell them about , you are being unethical and probably breaking your employment contract, and that sort of thing at the very least looks really bad. If you do, well, at the very least, you are making the hiring decision harder. There are companies that won't mind a lawsuit for a high-value hire; perhaps you even are one. But certainly, the risk of a lawsuit over a newhire is going to make the company think about it. Oh, and if you're thinking about causing "a million dollars in damages" with passwords you shouldn't have retained because you're pissed about a noncompete, um. If you're interested in working anywhere with responsibilities more interesting that "take out that trash and dump it in the dumpster", I hope you think twice. My bottom line on this way of thinking: it probably would have been more appealing when I was in my early 20s when I had a lot less to lose and knew a lot less about the legal system.
- stale2002 10y agoObviously you should never actually do something like vindictively break the law and cause millions in damages. That would be illegal and hugely immoral. But sometimes crazy and/or angry people do stupid things. The company doesn't 'really' know if you are secretly crazy or willing to risk jail for spite. Use that to your advantage. An X% chance of losing millions is a stupid risk to take for little benefit. The company has a significant incentive to not needlessly piss off former employees purely from an expected value perspective.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]