4 ms·
For those who read this piece of news and don't understand why there is no mention of machine learning, neural networks and deep learning, that's because the sy
by YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago
For those who read this piece of news and don't understand why there is no mention of machine learning, neural networks and deep learning, that's because the system described is a typical fuzzy logic Expert System, a mainstay of Good, Old-Fashioned AI.
In short, it's a hand-crafted database of rules in a format similar to "IF Condition THEN Action" coupled to an inference procedure (or a few different ones).
That sort of thing is called an "expert system" because it's meant to encode the knowledge of experts. Some machine learning algorithms, particularly Decision Tree learners, were proposed as a way to automate this process of elicitation of expert knowledge and the construction of rules from it.
As to the "fuzzy logic" bit, that's a kind of logic where a fact is true or false by degrees. When a threshold is crossed, a fact becomes true (or false) or a rule "fires" and the system changes state, ish.
It all may sound a bit hairy but it's actually a pretty natural way of constructing knowledge-based systems that must implement complex rules. In fact, any programmer who has ever had to code complex business logic into a program has created a de facto expert system, even if they didn't call it that.
For those with a bit of time in their hand, this is a nice intro:
http://www.inf.fu-berlin.de/lehre/SS09/KI/folien/merritt.pdf http://www.inf.fu-berlin.de/lehre/SS09/KI/folien/merritt.pdf
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoAlso, I should say: I'm really sorry this news had to be about an automated weapon. That sucks.
- Retra 10y agoIt wouldn't be news if it weren't about a weapon. Or rather, it wouldn't have grabbed your attention.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoIt grabbed my attention because it's an expert system with fuzzy logic rules and I have an interest in those. I'm not interested in their military applications.
- Retra 10y agoThen why did you bring it up?
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoI analysed the bit I'm interested in and stated I abhor the bit I abhor. What are you failing to understand?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- saulrh 10y agoNot actually hand-crafted. If you read the actual paper, they're training their fuzzy system with some kind of genetic algorithm. The theory behind it isn't in this paper, and it seems to be home-grown DIY type stuff - pretty standard for heavily military work like this - but it is still doing some optimization and learning. No idea what it's doing, whether it's just tuning weights or whether it's actually altering the tree itself, but I'd guess that they've basically reinvented decision trees.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> If you read the actual paper You're right that I didn't. Thanks for correcting me and apologies for the slight fudging. I think my description is still mostly accurate though. >> I'd guess that they've basically reinvented decision trees. That would make sense in the sense that it's kind of an obvious algorithm to re-invent if you're trying to learn propositional rules. I'm not so sure about the "evolutionary" part though.