6 ms·
While there are not criminal laws that could compel a liquidation directly, the equivalent could happen by making a restructuring unfeasible through fines, ther
by Zigurd 10y ago
While there are not criminal laws that could compel a liquidation directly, the equivalent could happen by making a restructuring unfeasible through fines, thereby forcing liquidation.
- tptacek 10y agoSure, but the reason that doesn't happen is that you can't fine arbitrarily; companies can dispute them legally, and those cases are murderously expensive to try. So I'm acknowledging that you could pass laws that make an effective death penalty (through fines or through literally forcing liquidation) a reality, but then asking: why would you want to do that? Aren't there better laws we could pass instead?
- Zigurd 10y ago"Better laws" that directly target the management responsible for malfeasance could do the job instead of dismantling the corporation out from under that management. But the same lawyers fighting to keep creditors from forcing liquidation are also fighting for the management that hired them, no matter the shades of ethics involved in that. It's a difficult problem. In the case of VW you have suppliers and engineers being told to produce results that are not possible without cheating. And then that eventually becomes part of corporate culture and the cleverness of the cheat gets institutionalized and probably even spreads through the industry as employees move around at various levels and as suppliers sell, on the down-low, the means to cheat.