3 ms·
He asked why we should accept that and you explained why he should entertain it. So you didn't really answer his question. There's a big difference between acce
by snowwrestler 10y ago
He asked why we should accept that and you explained why he should entertain it. So you didn't really answer his question. There's a big difference between accepting and entertaining.
> If you've got good reasons to attach particular values to the helium in 100 years, or the helium now, or the value of anything else investable in 100 years, then by all means do share, and tell us why everyone else in the market has it wrong
Of course the market today is wrong about the value of things 100 years from now. If it were possible to predict the value of things 100 years from now, we would not need a market to allocate resources.
Markets beat central planning not because they are superior at predicting the future, but because they are superior at adapting to the surprising future as it arrives.
Markets are quite bad at predicting the future. Market prices capture today's collective thinking about the future, but that's not the same thing as actually predicting the future--and sometimes it is the opposite, as in a bubble.
Markets walk randomly to price things, but there might be no-return boundaries lurking in our future. If we run out of helium, it doesn't matter if the market corrects to a proper scarcity valuation. Raising the price of something does not physically create more of it.