4 ms·
The so-called "cyber war" will be a very important component of any future war between nation states. Taking over the enemies SCADA systems, power grid, net inf
by adrianN 10y ago
The so-called "cyber war" will be a very important component of any future war between nation states. Taking over the enemies SCADA systems, power grid, net infrastructure etc. can do massive economic damage with few casualties.
I don't think we'll ever see a civilized form of war where no real harm is done, because abiding by the rules of such a war is not a game-theoretic equilibrium. If a party builds a real army in addition to the simulated army and uses it, it will win the war.
- sevenless 10y agoWe have a Geneva Convention, and international norms against nuclear weapons, which are also pretty good deterrents themselves (we hope). Just like nuclear powers sometimes wage limited conventional wars, it's possible to imagine a set of international laws and norms where disputes would be resolved by virtual conflicts without escalation to armed force. Advances in robotic war machines could make them so fearsome they deterred real-world armed conflict in favor of virtual conflict. (Of course, that's what they said about the machine gun before WW1)
- talmand 10y agoThe Geneva Convention only works if both sides abide by it. Such deterrents only work because we allow them to work. Once one side decides the consequences of going against the norm is acceptable, or can be avoided altogether, then the rules no longer apply.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoWhat makes you think that disabling infrastructural targets will result in fewer casualties? Power for heating, cooling and hospitals. Transit systems for food distribution. Computers for synchronising all of the above. How many casualties do you think would result from shutting down infrastructure in NYC in mid winter? Even evacuation causes casualties. I was reading an assessment of the Fukushima evacuation that suggested fewer casualties would have resulted from just staying there.
- adrianN 10y agoBlowing up all transformers in the power grid by inducing a huge power surge surely causes fewer casualties than blowing up all transformers using bombs.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoPerhaps? I suspect the random variation between the two would account for far more difference than the casualties directly attributable to method of destruction, though. Unless you mean destroying the transformers with blockbuster-size HE, or dirty nuclear devices? I guess my point is that the number of people who would die from sustained, widespread infrastructure disruption would be huge, and not greatly changed by casualties around the blast site if you decided to blow stuff up literally instead of just metaphorically.