3 ms·
Good point. However, nothing about these agreements makes anything fundamentally cheaper, it's just shuffling money around. In the best case, the kickbacks redu
by mikeash 10y ago
Good point. However, nothing about these agreements makes anything fundamentally cheaper, it's just shuffling money around. In the best case, the kickbacks reduce rent, people's internet bills increase, and they pay the same. If the internet is cheaper because it's slow, then it could be cheaper and slower anywhere.
Since none of this fundamentally cuts costs, you end up with a zero-sum game. There are four basic possibilities: either the ISP miscalculates and loses more money on kickbacks than they gain from renters, the landlord miscalculates and loses more money in rent than they gain from kickbacks, the renters miscalculate and lose more money on their internet bill (or lose more value due to having crappy internet) than they gain in rent savings, or everything manages to balance out perfectly and this is just a bunch of wasted effort. Since the renters are by far the party with the least information and the least ability to analyze the situation, it's highly likely that they're the ones who end up being screwed.