5 ms·
If mathematics has a bikeshed, this is it. I enjoy the ridiculousness of it all, but people who consider this anything other than a well-executed joke really s
by skrebbel 10y ago
If mathematics has a bikeshed, this is it.
I enjoy the ridiculousness of it all, but people who consider this anything other than a well-executed joke really should get a hold of themselves.
- Bromskloss 10y agoI find it worthwhile to think about questions like this, whose answers, on some level, do not matter, but, on another level, can be felt to be more or less in line with insights about the underlying structure. Examples of other questions in the same category: - Whether the natural numbers should be defined so as to include zero or not (and, relatedly, whether counting should start on zero or on one). - How to structure a database or a piece of computer code (including the details of how to formulate individual lines of code).
- ska 10y agoMathematics has no shortage of bikesheds.
- jeffwass 10y agoLet's assume the bikesheds are spherical, with radius r. They'll have surface area 4pi*r^2 and, oh never mind...
- jessriedel 10y agoYou're right about the bikeshedness, but that doesn't mean there isn't a clearly better bike shed design. I also find that these sorts of inefficiencies/inelegances compound. One or two are trivial, but when you have 30 of them, suddenly the mental tax becomes noticeable. Furthermore, the cost falls mostly on the students, while the experts have already paid it and don't see the need to worry about it anymore.
- lamontcg 10y agoYeah, but this bikeshed got decided hundreds of years ago. Its only appealing to internet hipsters who want to brag about their organically grown free range tau. Making the next generation of math students use "2 pi" in their formulas is going to be vastly easier than literally rewriting all the books.
- Asooka 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html Essentially there are two rules here: don't post or upvote crap links, and don't be rude or dumb in comment threads. The most important principle on HN, though, is to make thoughtful comments. Thoughtful in both senses: civil and substantial. So the principle here is: don't say anything you wouldn't say face to face.
- jessriedel 10y agoAs a practicing physicist, I found it illuminating and non-trivially useful to know this when it was first introduced to me years ago. This is true even though I will never use in a paper, and even if I only rarely write it in my notes. In my head, 2\pi is a single character, to the point that I often write \frac{1}{2} 2\pi.
- m000z0rz 10y agoReally? This seems very similar to problems with variable naming and magic numbers, which are far from bike shedding.
- stonogo 10y agoNo, they aren't.
- JadeNB 10y ago> If mathematics has a bikeshed, this is it. In my experience, few professional mathematicians care about this. The question that Bromskloss (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11993750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11993750) mentions, of whether or not 0 is a natural number, is likely to incur a far more passionate response. (At the risk of downvotes: it is.)
- Bromskloss 10y agoIn therms of practical consequences such as making mathematical expressions look different, it seems to me that 0 vs. 1 makes a smaller difference than does τ vs. π, because many statements about the set ℕ of natural numbers make no mention of what its first element is anyway. Often you can drag along any of the two definitions of ℕ through the argument, without changing it's conclusions. For example, if f:ℕ→ℝ (and ε∈ℝ, N∈ℕ, n∈ℕ), the limit L∈ℝ is given by (∀ε>0)(∃N)(∀n≥N)(|f(n)-L|<ε), regardless of whether one takes ℕ={0,1,2,…} or ℕ={1,2,3,…}.
- JadeNB 10y agoWell, certainly there is a difference if one wishes to compute, say, `\sum_{n \in \mathbb N} 1/n!`. In that case, it's easy just to say what you mean; but, then again, so is it easy to say what you mean in any occurrence of `\pi` or `\tau`. I spoke only of the passion that the issue evokes, not its practical consequences.
- Bromskloss 10y ago> Well, certainly there is a difference if one wishes to compute, say, `\sum_{n \in \mathbb N} 1/n!`. Certainly. To be clear, I don't mean to argue against anything you said. I just find it to be an interesting observation that statements quite often are true for both versions of ℕ. Specifically, I suppose, the two versions work the same when one is concerned with only the most fundamental essence of the natural numbers, as captured by the Peano axioms. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peano_axioms#Formulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peano_axioms#Formulation
- tempodox 10y agoI find your interpretation rather benign. Saying, “pi is wrong, tau is right” is the equivalent of mathematical bigotry to me.
- mithaler 10y agoI have to disagree. I'm a programmer, but I'm not good at math. I know this. And yet, the Tau Day Manifesto explained the geometry of the circle to me more clearly and understandably than any of the math classes I've ever taken. And it's not just because it's a well-written work; the concept is genuinely simpler to understand. Pi really is a pedagogical disaster, and tau really does help.