5 ms·
While choice between tau and pi is arbitrary from mathematical point, things like pedagogy, notational simplicity and aesthetics matter. The reason why I thin
by nabla9 10y ago
While choice between tau and pi is arbitrary from mathematical point, things like pedagogy, notational simplicity and aesthetics matter.
The reason why I think π is probably better choice is because small multiples of constant are cognitively easier to process than fractions. 2π is easier to write and see as single object than τ/2. All we need to do is to make slight cognitive adjustment and think and teach 2π as a number instead of 2×π.
- jobigoud 10y ago> 2π is easier to write and see as single object than τ/2 The point is that you shouldn't have to write 2π in the first place. So notational simplicity would mandate the use of τ, not π. Noting that you will have to write τ/2 for a half turn is moot, in your case you'll also have to write π/2 for a quarter turn anyway.
- jeffwass 10y agoIt gets worse! When using solid angles over a sphere, you're still going to need to use 2Tau steradians to cover a sphere. This factor of 2 will continue to cause confusion for the Tau fans. Therefore we must also define a new constant Sigma = 4pi so we can cleanly and easily deal with steradians. Anybody up for writing the Sigma Manifesto? </sarcasm>
- agumonkey 10y agoMaybe we could subscript tau with dimension n.
- jerf 10y agoDoes it help the pedagogy and understanding? Does it help form equations that match the form of other equations in some mathematically-meaningful way? Then, yes, I'd support it just fine. So the sarcasm fails. One of the other things I don't see mentioned very often in this discussion is that mathematics evolves. We almost never get it right the first time. The original Maxwell's Equations were 20 equations, rather hairy ones at that, now expressed in 4 with superior notation. Derivative and integral notation did not spring fully-formed from Newton or Leibniz, it has evolved. Matrix notation evolved. Number notation has evolved. The idea that pi itself may have to evolve because it wasn't quite right is perfectly natural and normal. What's bizarre is the idea that it must be held to be perfect, that criticism is all-but-morally wrong, and that anybody even talking about it is crazy. I blame our terrible math system, for teaching people that math consists entirely of edicts handed down from, I presume, aliens, or possibly some form of diety, since apparently it can't be humans as we're not allowed to touch the Holy Notation. But that's not how it works in reality, and there's nothing bizarre about the idea that we might want to change pi; what's bizarre is the idea that such a thing is blasphemy.
- jeffwass 10y ago>Does it help the pedagogy and understanding? Does it help form equations that match the form of other equations in some mathematically-meaningful way? Absolutely! In 3D systems. Particularly using spherical coordinates. It's ironic you chose Maxwell's Equations as your example because Sigma would get rid of those pesky factors of 4pi appearing in them when written in Gaussian units! Besides, Maxwell's Equations are really best represented as just one equation when expressed in covariant form.
- contravariant 10y agoTreating 2π as a single entity is probably the best option for now. Not sure if formulas like 1/2 (2π) r^2 will ever catch on, but in more complicated formulas it's probably better to not simplify things like (2π)^4 / 6 to 2^3 π^4 / 3.
- sevenless 10y agoThe idea of 2π as symbolic entity in its own right, should be easier to accept than τ. Introduce a single symbol that joins 2 and π, a bit like the Jupiter symbol (http://unicode-table.com/en/2643/ http://unicode-table.com/en/2643/), and pronounced 'two-pi'. Like τ it also starts with a T, for turn. That would be totally backward compatible in reading, writing and speech.
- eddieh 10y agoA ligature is what you're suggesting. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Typographic_ligature https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Typographic_ligature
- ejlo 10y agoMathematically, tau is clearly superior, since it represents a full circle. The question is whether the gain is big enough compared to the trouble of introducing a new constant. It's not like pi is going to disappear any time soon.
- BenFrantzDale 10y agoMy favorite example of why τ is the true circle constant is actually the equation A = 1/2 τ r^2. It fits the usual quadratic form and shows how circumference and area relate: c = dA/dr = τ r and so A = ∫ c dr = ∫ τ r dr = 1/2 τ r^2. At first glance those 1/2s seem superfluous and like it would be nicer to just have a 2 in the other terms, but the 1/2 shows that differentiation and integration with respect to r are happening, where the "1/2" and the "^2" anhialate each other on differentiation and then re-form on integration.
- agumonkey 10y agoReminds me of Taylor series. The factorial terms eluded me for so long until I realized it was a cancelling factor for accumulated derivation of polynomials. Now there's this link in my mind between powers / derivation / factorials.
- Steuard 10y agoWhat polynomials are being derived, and from what premises? Are you thinking of how to derive series solutions to differential equations or something? I'm unclear on what you're getting at here. (Or, oh: did you mean "differentiation" when you said "derivation"? That would fit what you've said. Sorry for the pedantic post; I'll just leave this here in case anyone else is confused.)
- agumonkey 10y agoSorry for the fuzzy vocabulary. TBH I wasn't even convinced I understood taylor series correctly. A quick search on wikipedia hint at that derivation is used sometimes; derivative; differentiation etc etc. About the point: d(n)(x^n.dx) = n d(n-1)(x^(n-1).dx) = (n * (n-1 * (...))) = n! * x hence the 1/n! term.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]