3 ms·
> People think that it's just big business rigging the system to make sure they get most of the money and the expense of the average person and politicians are
by smsm42 10y ago
> People think that it's just big business rigging the system to make sure they get most of the money and the expense of the average person and politicians are along for the ride.
They funny thing is it's more of the reverse. The politicians are rigging the system to make sure they get most of the power, and big businesses are along for the ride because they can monetize the power. It's a symbiotic relationship - if a politician passes an expensive regulation, she gains power as champion of the people sticking it to a big business. But if the regulation does not kill the big business but kills (or forces to sell) their smaller competitor who has huge compliance costs and no lobbying connections - who exactly won here? And, more importantly, who exactly lost here?
Lobbying is an insanely profitable investment, second to none. And it's not possible to do anything with it going from the business side - big businesses have much more concentrated and agile power than the society, and thus would always be able to influence a specific politician more efficiently. The only way to make a dent there is to reduce the amount of damage any particular politician can do. If only thing they control is a generic nation-wide tax rate, it's not really much space for lobbying there. If they have 2000-page tax code that is full with exclusions, deductions, special cases and targeted exceptions - oh, it's a lobbying bonanza! And so on.
> Theoretically politicians with "big government" is supposed to be the people's answer to corporate power.
That's like saying a diet of donuts and cola is supposed to be the answer for obesity. Or heroin is supposed to be the answer for marijuana.
> now businesses are running away unchecked
That's exactly the opposite of what happens. Never in history there was so many regulations as there is now. Literally never - there are 3500 to 3800 regulations created every year. Think about how many of these there are when this system runs for decades. Big businesses have army of people to deal with this cursed forest. Small businesses do not. Guess why people think the system is rigged?
- jandrese 10y agoBut as you just pointed out, regulations are more likely to help big corporations by stifling competition, allowing them to snowball as is the natural consequence of competition free capitalism.
- smsm42 10y agoRight. My point is that Big Goverment is a primary driver here. Absent Big Government, big corp will be kept in check by competition and often taken down by the market forces when it gets too big due to its internal inefficiencies and lack of agility and flexibility, that happened multiple times. Even if it's not, even biggest corporation comprises only tiny bit of the enormous US economy, and thus economic power is distributed. With the Big Government, however, the power is concentrated and it's much easier to capture it. What's easier - to play eternal whack-a-mole with a thousand of competitors or buy a couple of senators and pass a regulation to ensure all these competitors never have a chance?
- nikdaheratik 10y agoI think that's kind of ignoring a large chunk of history where small, local governments were steamrolled by corporations and it takes action at a nationwide level to counteract this. The primary driver of this is the fact that there is just so much money out there and businesses are faced with a never ending battle to defend it. The arena can be with "big government" but it can also be "city by city" or even with hired security pushing around the new players. I don't think it's a good idea to try and rollback every change that's been made unless you think about why the regulatory body or whatever exists in the first place.
- smsm42 10y ago> where small, local governments were steamrolled by corporations Steamrolled in which way? Usually these corporations enjoy some support from much bigger government - like monopoly, patent, etc. - and usually the way they "steamroll" is capturing the power local government wields and using it against the competition or the opponents. > The primary driver of this is the fact that there is just so much money out there Do you mean the supply of money (or, to be more precise, of value expressed by money, since supply of actual fiat money is arbitrary anyway and can be made as big or small as the government wishes) is fixed? If so, this is decidedly not true. > or even with hired security pushing around the new players. If by pushing around you mean violence, the only entity that can legally employ violence not in self-defense in the government. So if somebody is pushing around somebody else, either government is participating or at least abdicating their duty. > unless you think about why the regulatory body or whatever exists in the first place. The problem is that nobody ever provided the "why" when these bodies are created. Most of them were created "because we can" or "to improve quality" or some other similarly fake and unprovable reason. If you require tangible proof to remove regulation, should not you at least require equally tangible proof to keep or institute one? Or, even more proof?
- nikdaheratik 10y agoI think you have a good point, especially about regulations being a way for businesses to build a moat around their money making enterprises. However, it's not like eliminating "big government" is the cure either. All it does is change the focus of activity from national regulations to courts, and local governments, and even other forms of quasi-legal action. Business activities in the 19th century "lassez faire" era are what caused these regulatory bodies to be put in place in the first place. At least with modern legislature, we can find out who is doing what through the public record, can push back if they try to go too far, and don't have to worry about businesses hiring "private security" to settle their differences instead.