5 ms·
When does Campoes term out anyway? There certainly is a struggle between ownership rights and the right of cities to regulate business within their jurisdictio
by mc32 10y ago
When does Campoes term out anyway?
There certainly is a struggle between ownership rights and the right of cities to regulate business within their jurisdiction.
As a renter, I can sympathize with wanting to avail more rental properties to renters, but I am also very uneasy with politicians dictating what you can and cannot do with your property when that act in and of itself is not otherwise illegal. It's not confiscation, but it also kerbs your ability let your property as you wish --and I say this as a renter who arguably would benefit from this politician's policies.
PS move HQ to Brisbane and take the corp taxes with you.
- sjwright 10y agoSpeaking entirely out of ignorance, how might these policies benefit someone like yourself?
- jedberg 10y agoPeople who buy housing just to rent out on AirBnB would find it more economical to rent out to a long term renter (because the licensing is actually less onerous), thereby increasing the rental supply and lowering rents.
- jonpaine 10y agoAm I misunderstanding you? SF's legendary rent control creates a clear incentive for landlords to use a service like Airbnb to continually rent at market rate (though lower occupancy rate) while maintaining control to allocate the unit as they see fit. Renting a unit in sf both freezes rental revenue and removes the owners control to reallocate the unit. Did you mean something else?
- jedberg 10y agoEven with rent control it's still better to be a landlord of a long term tenant than follow the licensing restrictions. The license 1) Costs money and 2) limits the number of days you can rent. #2 is the big issue. Even with rent control, at least you can rent the place out for the whole year. With the license you can only rent the place out for 90 days a year. You must live in the unit the other 275 days of the year. So your rent controlled rate would have to be 25% of market rate for the legal short term rental to make sense, and you'd have to live there when it isn't rented.
- ap3 10y agoWhy don't more people rail against rent control like they do airbnb? How many people live in rent controlled units in SF?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Why don't more people rail against rent control like they do airbnb? I've seen more people -- on HN and in real life -- railing against rent control than against AirBnB.
- mc32 10y agoBy disallowing properties which would otherwise be put on the rental market strictly on ab&b thus arguably subtracting this unit out from the rental market.
- sp332 10y agoBut your neighbors might not want you to let out your place to an endless parade of strangers. This is a case where the government needs to listen to the people, and determine if the majority want more freedom or a nicer neighborhood.
- mc32 10y agoTrue enough. They might also only want single family homes to be owner or family occupied only. I think there can be compromises people come to.
- natrius 10y agoUsing laws to bias housing stock towards owner-occupancy is explicit economic segregation. Owning a home requires wealth that many families don't have, and they should have an equal right to all neighborhoods. Segregation is the default in American housing policy to the point that most people treat segregation laws as normal, justifiable things. Every time we make a decision about homes, we should consider the impact it has on different kinds of people.
- mc32 10y agoYes, that was my implicit point. We can go to extremes, but we don't have to. We can be reasonable about things. (I am, by the way, such a renter).
- cstejerean 10y agoThen your neighbors should put that in their HOA rules. The city is getting involved to protect hotels not "neighbors".
- mc32 10y agoThat's a good point. However, I _think_ they genuinely have good intentions for renters, except they are doing it in the most knee-jerk constituency visible way, for whatever reason.
- ProAm 10y ago> but I am also very uneasy with politicians dictating what you can and cannot do with your property when that act in and of itself is not otherwise illegal The list of things you cannot do is already extremely lengthy and much to the chagrin of homeowners. I assume you've only rented and never owned, but wait until you see what your property taxes go to, what you are allowed to build, not build, must maintain, must pay for on behalf of citizens that do not own (Denver is currently trying to raise property taxes to subsidize builders and ease purchase pain of new homeowners who currently cannot afford to buy for example). I think people are up in arms over this because Airbnb is a large player in the startup community, but the uproar of politicians creating policy for it's citizens is not absurd.
- mc32 10y agoYes, renter so, far. And I am vaguely aware of the control/ordinances, etc. government impose on property owners --many for the greater and one's own good. But at some point it becomes too much. My favorite is the old window tax they used to collect in France, among other places, centuries? ago. People boarded up their windows. I also am very wary of the Chavezist instinct to blame property owners and businesses for the faults and failings of bad government planning and policies.
- ProAm 10y ago> But at some point it becomes too much Yes you are correct, the point it usually becomes too much is when you, as an individual, have to begin paying it. Or in this case when a business feels it's paycheck is being affected.
- ap3 10y ago>Denver is currently trying to raise property taxes to subsidize builders and ease purchase pain of new homeowners who currently cannot afford to buy for example Sadly there is nothing new in politicians coming to take away more of your money & rights
- pbreit 10y agoYour rental agreement (or HOA regs) almost certainly forbids short term rentals.
- ubernostrum 10y agopoliticians dictating what you can and cannot do with your property OK, let's completely legalize Airbnb-style temporary rentals... but make the host bear the full cost of it. Not the small fraction of the cost the host thinks about, but the actual cost with all the externalities factored in. Because really the only way Airbnb works is if it offloads significant costs onto unconsenting and often unaware third parties. And all those goshdurned gubmint regulations? They bring the cost of running a hotel-like business into line with, well, the actual cost of running a hotel-like business. But we can replace them all with just a single charge if you like.
- mc32 10y agoDo we want to go down the externalities rabbit hole? Do we tax people who cannot knowingly fiscally responsibly afford to have kids more because their kids cause tax externalities that people who don't have kids have to bear (school, food, health subsidies, quality of life impact, etc.)?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lovich 10y agoAnd then do we we tax people who benefit from the economic output of these children after someone else raises them? Figuring out the extent of these externalities is not easy, but ignoring their existence is like putting your head in the sand
- ap3 10y agoHow do I benefit from the economic output of other people?
- ab5tract 10y agoWe absolutely should tax the shit out of the cretins spawning more 'arrows for god' or parents so broken in the head that they push out 5 kids because they are chasing a specific gender.