3 ms·
I think there is fundamental difference of opinion here, exposed by Adam's and A16Z's posts. A fairly typical early stage employee will forgo hundreds of thous
by ska 10y ago
I think there is fundamental difference of opinion here, exposed by Adam's and A16Z's posts.
A fairly typical early stage employee will forgo hundreds of thousands of dollars in salary over a vesting period, in exchange for options.
The philosophical difference is here: At the end of that period, do you think of the shares as the employees, earned in exchange for both the work done in those years, and the hundreds of thousands the company saved on salary? Or do you think of the options as an ongoing incentive to keep the employee with you (perhaps still below market rates), in exchange for the chance of a big payout later?
Technical employees often feel the former, and will point to the fact that they've "given" the company much more in salary reduction than many early round investors paid per share they own outright. Corporations often state the latter point, or some variation, particularly pointing out that later employees don't have the same leverage on the option pool. Option agreements often encode the latter.
- mahyarm 10y agoI'm starting to have the feeling that those very early employees are about equivalent to an angel investor, and they should be getting some sort of angel investor equivalent terms. Otherwise once people really start realizing the negatives of being an early employee vs. founding your own startup it would be hard to hire otherwise.
- ska 10y agoOne way to do this with very early employees is to avoid the whole mess by just giving stock.
- sulam 10y agoYou'd still have to pay taxes on it as per your (audit-able) 409a valuation.
- ska 10y agoSure, depending on the country it works different ways. But if there is tax to pay, it is on a low valuation (very early, remember).
- argonaut 10y agoTo be fair, there is another catch-22, which is that a low valuation means the startup is early-stage, which means your options are worth less. So sure, you can early exercise, but there is a greater chance your early exercising will lose you money (if the options end up worthless).
- ska 10y agoNote I said "give stock", not "give options". Granted, this doesn't solve everything - it was an aside comment about early stage vesting (where liquidation events can be a long way off)
- argonaut 10y agoMy comment is equally valid if you replace "early exercise" with "paying taxes on" (assuming you do an 83b election).