4 ms·
In most of the US, you have a choice of one or two wired broadband ISPs anyway. I imagine most renters don't care about competition, since they know they wouldn
by mikeash 10y ago
In most of the US, you have a choice of one or two wired broadband ISPs anyway. I imagine most renters don't care about competition, since they know they wouldn't have much of a choice no matter where they go, and if they're in an area with two choices, they're likely to be equally crappy.
ISP competition is important, but I see this as a symptom, not a cause. Fix the root problem, and people might start caring about ISP choice. Once renters care about ISP choice, big landlords will fall into line.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoTypically there are four consumer level providers in US markets. One coax, one copper/fiber, one (or more) satellite, and most likely a regional operator that may be either copper/fiber or coax. Also some regions do have consumer-level WISPs, although those are more rare in urban areas. Webpass being a high profile exception. The problem is you can't get the standard Comcast or U-verse product in those buildings. The landlord signed a 10-year deal stating "10mb/s" per unit. Meanwhile your neighbor in a non-exclusive building gets 75mb/s easily for the same price or even less than you're paying under the exclusive agreement. Worse, a lot of these buildings sign deals with no-name local fiber providers (or resellers) who pull the same crap, so its not a "big business won't let us compete" issue as much as it is lack of choice for residents due to existing contracts by the property owner.
- mikeash 10y agoSatellite is terrible and doesn't really count. I've never heard of someone using satellite unless they literally have no wired ISPs available. IMO it belongs in the same category as cellular internet. According to this report, in 2013 only 28% of US households had three or more providers capable of giving 10Mbps service, and 24% only had one: http://esa.doc.gov/sites/default/files/competition-among-us-broadband-service-providers.pdf http://esa.doc.gov/sites/default/files/competition-among-us-... If you raise the bar to 25Mbps, then only 9% had three or more, and nearly half only had one choice. That's 2.5 years old, but I don't think it has changed all that much. Maybe they offer even worse services in these buildings, but I bet that in areas where they have a monopoly simply because of no competition, I bet it's pretty bad too. It certainly was for me when I lived in such an area.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoThose surveys include all of the US's massive rural areas. In urban areas there's more choice and much higher speeds. 80% of the population lives in urban areas. I think its important to keep that in mind when reading surveys like these. Just because some guy who chooses to live in the middle of nowhere gets only 1.5mbps DSL doesnt mean I can't get 100+mbs in urban areas. I'm currently on a 100mbps in Chicago with AT&T and Comcast soon releasing their consumer-level gigabit fiber product. Other cities have the same or better, like Kansas City's Google fiber. Its dishonest to say that high-rise renters in urban areas should think 10mbps is competitive. Its not remotely so. This also cuts both ways. I know a building serviced just by RCN and every tenant gets 100mbps and a bunch of channels for a good price. Its a mixed bag, but usually leans on less competitive products.
- mikeash 10y agoIf 80% of the US population lives in urban areas, and 50% of the US population only has one choice for 25Mbps service, then that means at least 37% of the urban population only has one choice. If 72% of the entire US population had at most two choices for 10Mbps, then that means at least 65% of urban dwellers do.
- zeveb 10y ago> The landlord signed a 10-year deal stating "10mb/s" per unit. Meanwhile your neighbor in a non-exclusive building gets 75mb/s easily for the same price or even less than you're paying under the exclusive agreement. Units with no better than 10Mb/s service should let for significantly less than otherwise-equivalent units with 75Mb/s, significantly less given modern Internet usage. There may be folks who are willing to give up some about of bandwidth in order to save on rent; it would be unfortunate if that choice were taken away from them.
- mikeash 10y agoThey're not going to be saving anything. If these agreements cut the rent the landlords could charge, they'd never sign them. All this does is trap people who failed to investigate beforehand.
- zeveb 10y ago> If these agreements cut the rent the landlords could charge, they'd never sign them. If landlords believed these agreements cut the rent the landlords can charge by more than they are kicked-back, they'd never sign them. I'm certainly not defending this sort of thing. But, given a competitive rental market, it's not something to worry overmuch about.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoA competitive rental market is something that rarely exists. In most of the cases I've heard of, the demand is much greater than supply, so the landlords are free to charge whatever and if you don't accept, there are 100 other people in line for the same apartment.
- mrep 10y agoLike you said, depends on the market. Here in Seattle, whenever one of my intern friends would move in, we would first tell them to look for apartments with wave/condo internet. 60$ a month, no contract or installation fees for 100 Mbit per second internet. It hasn't gone down once in that past 4 months nor ever slowed from that speed (I can also spend an extra 20$ a month to get 1 gbit per second).
- chimeracoder 10y ago> ISP competition is important, but I see this as a symptom, not a cause. Fix the root problem, and people might start caring about ISP choice. Once renters care about ISP choice, big landlords will fall into line Depends on where you live. In NYC, Verizon promised to provide fiber to the entire city several years back (and there is currently a massive legal dispute with the city because they've fallen incredibly short of delivering on that)[0]. It's particularly apalling because Verizon didn't even have to build out most of the fiber - the city already had a dark fiber network covering large portions of the city. I'm one of the unlucky ones. Verizon has fiber running right in front of my building - other buildings on the block already have Fios. However, Verizon refuses to provide Internet to my building unless they can also provide TV service as well[1]. The landlord has given Time Warner Cable the exclusive rights to provide TV service in my building, so that means that I'm stuck with only one choice, even though it's technically a "competitive" market. So, this issue is both a symptom and an exacerbating cause pf ISP non-competition. At least in NYC, exclusivity agreements make it much easier for the local monopolies[2] to pretend that they aren't blocking competition, when in reality they've carefully drawn lines around their territories and have a "gentleman's agreement" not to encroach on each others'. If landlords didn't (or couldn't) receive kickbacks like these, it'd be much harder for them to maintain this illusion. [0] http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20150713/BLOGS04/150719982/de-blasio-administration-goes-after-verizon-for-failing-to-deliver-fios http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20150713/BLOGS04/150719... [1] This is not hypothetical; I've called up their offices more than once and confirmed that this is the blocking step before they schedule a date to hook up the building. [2] TWC, Comcast, and Optimum have exclusivity rights to buildings all across the city.
- rayiner 10y agoCities using TV franchises to block competition and extract tithes is a huge part of the problem. Verizon wanted to wire up Baltimore with FiOS. Baltimore refused to give them a TV license. The economics of FiOS don't really work out without TV service, so nobody got FiOS except a few luxury buildings that were easy to wire up.
- chimeracoder 10y ago