3 ms·
We have a robot similar to this at work. It's broken right now - maybe the battery is dead, maybe there's a software issue - and nobody's particularly intereste
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
We have a robot similar to this at work. It's broken right now - maybe the battery is dead, maybe there's a software issue - and nobody's particularly interested in fixing it, because it never worked too well.
For one, on our model, there's zero peripheral vision. This makes it really hard to orient yourself in space - how far away is that wall? Did I scoot far enough past that doorway to swivel 90° to the right and go through it? Am I about to hit someone?
The same problem occurs when you're trying to talk to people. You can really only see two people who are standing in front of you. I'm not even sure if there's stereo sound - as there appears to be on the Snowbot, since he swivels towards people who are addressing him.
Other minor difficulties:
* it was difficult to park it into its charging station, which meant that sometimes it would just go comatose in a hallway.
* there's still a fair amount of lag, which makes it slightly annoying to have a conversation. Dialing someone over Skype/Hipchat/whatever-video is almost always the better option.
* sometimes you'd remote in, and be in an unfamiliar location because the robot wasn't returned to its parking spot. Since the whole point is to be able to access remote locations, we typically weren't familiar with the office layout, and would have to wander around aimlessly trying to get someone to help us get to where we needed to go.
- riprowan 10y agoThe camera on the bot should switch to wide-angle / fisheye view when it moves, then switch to a regular lens for faces when it's still / just rotating in position. The wide angle / fisheye view would provide a more typical FPS-like frame of reference, while the 20-35mm view makes faces appear realistic.
- basch 10y agothat was my first thought as well. the main problem seems like something a tiny piece of curved glass could solve. If it could get almost 180 degree FOV, you could pan in software on the client end.
- j2bax 10y agoAll of these issues sound like they should be fairly easy to resolve with the tech. The unit should have an internal map of the company and know where each employees desk is, you shouldn't have to manually drive it around an unknown office, thats just crazy! I'm sure the fact that it doesn't is a result of it still being in the novelty phase, but I would think the industry might get serious about this technology as teams become more and more distributed. Anything that simulates the effect of presence is going to be very valuable and detrimental to the communication of the future distributed workforce. I think VR/AR will ultimately take over this space, but these roving camera/screen's might be a good interim solution.
- blakeyrat 10y agoI've worked for 2 smallish tech companies that had robots like these sitting in corners collecting dust because they invariably turned out to be not very useful.
- monksy 10y ago> Skype/Hipchat/whatever-video Don't bother. Pied Piper video chat is so much better.
- mitchtbaum 10y agoIt seems like a setup that gives remote users access to building-integrated CCTV feeds, microphones, and speakers for an intercom-like interface with a nice UI for navigating and directly connecting to a local user's devices (based on "where" they are in the space) would work much better than a "centralized" mobile machine. I would guess those whose culture already respects a presence of disembodied and remotely connected souls (transdimensional spirits, perhaps) would have an easy route to adopting this.
- ef4 10y agoWe are on the cusp of solving the peripheral vision piece, because 360 degree camera rigs are getting cheap and popular. As soon as they can stream in realtime, you could have low-latency VR as if your head was really on top of the robot.
- comex 10y agoBut only rotational movement would be possible, no positional, like the DK1 / Gear VR... Not the end of the world but not pleasant either.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoGiven that most everyone operates telepresence robots from behind a desk, I think rotational-only would be a reasonable limitation.
- ef4 10y agoThere are already commercial VR camera rigs that can do translation within a sphere big enough for head motion. The camera makers want to be able to make content for use with things like Gear VR.
- comex 10y agoI haven't used one of these myself, but from my experience with regular video calls (and a mention in the article), a killer feature will be some way for the robot operator to maintain eye contact without having to fake it, i.e. looking at the camera instead of the screen. Googling brings up some rumors about devices with cameras hidden behind the screen, especially an Apple patent from 2009... but even if the tech doesn't pan out, I bet you could fake it pretty well in software if you have multiple cameras on different sides of the screen.
- CaptSpify 10y agoCan I ask what problem this solves that something like skype/hipchat/whatever doesn't solve? I guess to me it just feels like a step backwards. I'm not saying that these bots are bad, but I feel like there's a benefit that I'm not seeing.