7 ms·
There's a lot of clutching at straws going on at the moment. People coming out with political or legal theories, trying to interpret David Cameron's failure to
by Nursie 10y ago
There's a lot of clutching at straws going on at the moment. People coming out with political or legal theories, trying to interpret David Cameron's failure to immediately declare leaving under article 50 as kicking the whole issue into the long grass etc etc.
This is the latest, like others it's more of an exercise in denial than it is in reality. Many of these things could come to pass, it's true, but each one carries with it the implication that a direct democratic mandate, to leave the EU, is ignored.
If this occurs we can expect politics in the UK to become dangerously divided and unsettled, and the likes of UKIP to become a seriously large party in the next parliament, not to mention civil unrest in various forms.
The people that voted leave already feel left behind and ignored by the state. Explicitly ignoring them and finding a way to work around their democratically expressed opinion is likely to be a really BAD idea.
--edit-- I notice the points attached to this post going up and down. To those downvoting, can you tell me where/why you disagree?
- DanBC 10y ago> David Cameron's failure to immediately declare leaving under article 50 as kicking the whole issue into the long grass Maybe not the long grass, but it's a poison chalice for the next leader for the reasons you say - trigger article 50 and Scotland leaves UK and tries to join EU. Don't leave and the majority voters get angry. (And we really don't need them getting angrier since a small minority are angry enough to spray paint Polish community centres; to print and laminate "no more polish vermin" cards. (EDIT: Both these things have happened post-ref.)
- Nursie 10y agoOh there's political poison all over the place. It's one of the reasons I considered voting leave and am not too pissed off that the way I did vote didn't win - it's rather delightful seeing the turmoil at Westminster.
- jacquesm 10y ago> it's rather delightful seeing the turmoil at Westminster. Some men just love to watch the world burn. I will never understand this sentiment.
- antouank 10y agoAround 4 million EU nationals that live in the UK, were not eligible to vote, and they are directly affected by his decision, while they pay taxes and they contribute to the economy as much as the ones who could vote ( if not more... ). Also, a significant percentage of those who voted "Leave", around 10% at least, now would certainly change their vote since they saw that "scare tactics" was basically people telling them how economy works. So a false 2% margin is "democracy"? Not really. And this decision is way to big to rely on that typical and false margin. The circumstances do matter. Oh, by the way, "The referendum was non-binding, it's advisory".
- Nursie 10y ago1. They are not citizens, their lives may be affected but they have no vote. This has no bearing whatsoever on any of my argument above. 2. I voted 'remain'. If this result is ignored for a.second referendum I will vote 'leave' because I believe democratic respect is more important than EU membership. 3. Your 10% figure is pure conjecture. 4. It was a 4% margin. 5. Whether the referendum is legally binding or not has no bearing on its democratic legitimacy, nor on the potential fallout of ignoring the result.
- antouank 10y agoI guess you do not care whether the UK will be (or maybe is) way worse off economically and that xenophobia/racism is now an "every day" thing. Fine, vote "leave", probably suits better that mentality.
- Nursie 10y agoThis hate by some on the remain side is most unbecoming. You've got effectively called me a racist there. You realise this is precisely the sort of rhetoric that's lead us here?
- antouank 10y agoI just mentioned the facts after the result. Are they not? And I'm trying to say that they have such a big effect, that defending them is not, in the long-term, good thing for this society. I'm just sad that a minority is viewed falsely as a majority.
- onion2k 10y agoeach one carries with it the implication that a direct democratic mandate, to leave the EU, is ignored There is no such mandate, implied or otherwise. The referendum was advisory. Legally there is nothing compelling the government to act on the result.
- Nursie 10y agoThe mandate is the vote of the people, regardless of the technical nature of the vote. There is a lot compelling action, I mentioned some of the possible fallout scenarios in my post.
- sievebrain 10y agoLegally the UK is still ruled by the Queen. That situation would change in a heartbeat if the Queen actually tried to rule.
- robhu 10y agoIn an extreme circumstance that is the role of the Monarch. In 1975 in an extreme circumstance the Governor-General (the Queen's representative in Australia) dismissed the sitting Prime Minister and appointed a new one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1975_Australian_constitutional_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1975_Australian_constitutional...
- Nursie 10y agoIndeed, to complete outcry, and I believe the post has been stripped of its powers since (though could be wrong). It certainly wouldn't fly 4 decades later.
- cromulent 10y agoCompletely different to the UK situation though - the GG was acting according to the Australian constitution. UK law is obviously different. The Australian constitution only underwent a tiny change in 1977 that doesn't change the GG's role. I think it would indeed "fly".
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> each one carries with it the implication that a direct democratic mandate, to leave the EU, is ignored. And there's the problem. There IS a case to be made that a democratic majority with a margin of merely 4% is something that can, in fact, be ignored. In the United States, we have these lovely Senate filibusters, for instance, which everyone loves to complain about when their party isn't the one doing them. And vetos. And Supreme Court smackdowns. The UK has at least a couple of these it could theoretically apply (e.g. the fact that Parliament isn't bound by the results, and some long-shot ones like Scottish Parliament or the royal veto that they apparently never use) but when you put something on the ballot like that and make the entire nation vote, it kind of sends a message that this is something that's going to be respected. If there's a whole new Parliament in a few months that may be different? But substantial fallout will remain.
- cmdkeen 10y agoYep but you can't retrospectively apply a different standard because the result you didn't like happened. Getting such a standard applied in the beginning would also have been tricky given recent precedent (the AV and Scottish referenda) that viewed 50% + 1 as sufficient. Given the Scottish government want a second IndyRef they weren't going to sit by and allow a supermajority clause added to this referendum.
- andrewingram 10y agoI posted this on Facebook, so i'll paste it verbatim, but i'll acknowledge that whilst it is indeed grasping futilely, it's also the case that even before the referendum took place, I thought it was a stupidly binary and dangerous question to be asking people: ---- Some people voted leave for less immigration, others for more balanced (non EU-biased) immigration, it seems that these goals are fundamentally at odds. This isn't the only example of polarising goals that people have expressed. Until a referendum is put forward that actually allows people to express the end result they're hoping for (leaving the EU just seems to be the first step, not the goal for most people), I strongly believe it's undemocratic to proceed under the false argument that the people have spoken. For what it's worth, the point i'm making is the same as the argument in favour of alternative vote (or single transferable vote) vs first-past-the-post elections. The way in which people are polled is insufficient for ascertaining what they actually want. A binary choice doesn't work in a world with more than two possible opinions. ----
- 7952 10y agoDemocracy is all about individual power rather than the collective outcome. Of course remain supporters are free to pursue continued membershpip using any legal method open to them. And the Brexit gang are free to try and stop them. IMHO the Brexiteers would almost certainly win the argument so it is not worth pursuing. On immigration I worry that we will see a crack down on non-EU immigration to allow continued EU immigration. People will argue that they are closer to us culturally, and they would be right. It is hard to see how the government can avoid appeasing ant-immigrant sentiment at this point. I agree 100% that we need a better voting system. I can't stand UKIP, but I absoutely think they should have more representation in parliment. It would be good to use this as an oppurtunity to reform the house of lords into being fully elected. Give them the authority that the EU held in terms of long term regulation. We need an institution that can take a long term view which we will sorely miss post Brexit.
- shin_lao 10y agoSeveral political leaders admitted that they lied during the election, therefore people voted based on lies. Since the majority isn't that big (less than 52%) is would be acceptable to not immediately follow through. It's as big as a constitutional change and such change usually require more than 50% to be adopted.
- Nursie 10y agoLike David Cameron and his promise to invoke article 50 last Friday? Or George Osborne and his punishment budget? There were dreadful lies on both sides. Personally I treated the entire campaign period as a sideshow we'd have been better off without, the issues and opinions about EU membership are far deeper rooted than the last few weeks of noisy bickering. Further, the constitutional changes that got us in were not subject to supermajority conditions, in fact no political party that implemented them had an equivalent mandate behind them to either side of the referendum vote.
- gmac 10y agoThere were dreadful lies on both sides. I disagree. Leave's lies were on a completely different (larger) scale. Most fundamentally, Leave claimed that Brexit would not be an economic disaster, which they cannot possibly have known — especially since they very clearly have no plan at all for what's next.
- DanBC 10y agoI agree that both sides were pretty bad. Did Remain have a lie painted on the side of their bus? A lie printed on huge posters at press conferences? A lie that they rode back from on the morning of the results? http://imgur.com/indvx6a http://imgur.com/indvx6a
- robhu 10y agoI have not seen anyone admit that they lied - I have seen several point out that what they said when asked about a policy was more nuanced than what was a slogan, but that is not lieing. Can you please reference where you saw a politician actually "admit they lied"?
- vegabook 10y agothis is 100% correct. It is very difficult to envisage a scenario where this rubicon can be uncrossed. From a confidence point of view, for example, the damage is almost certainly already done, because even if Brexit does not happen, the political and stability implications for Britain are bad, deterring investment. It is no wonder that despite all of these scenarios being bandied about, sterling is declining another several points today and British banks are dropping another 10% after 15% already on Friday.
- PavlovsCat 10y ago> the implication that a direct democratic mandate, to leave the EU, is ignored At least insofar it's true that many people just voted to "send a signal" but didn't actually think they'd get a majority, that strikes me as going by the letter of the law rather than the spirit of it, so to speak. > If this occurs we can expect politics in the UK to become dangerously divided and unsettled, and the likes of UKIP to become a seriously large party in the next parliament, not to mention civil unrest in various forms. Hmm, sounds like a lose/lose situation: http://usuncut.com/world/hate-crimes-across-england-evoke-nightmares/ http://usuncut.com/world/hate-crimes-across-england-evoke-ni... Admittedly, both these points are kind of anecdotal, I don't have an overview or a glass ball either. But still, I don't really get the "it might be a mistake, but you have to go through with it" stuff.
- arethuza 10y ago"the likes of UKIP to become a seriously large party in the next parliament, not to mention civil unrest in various forms" I think UKIP will sit back and let the next Conservative government fail to deliver on some key Leave promises - I think they'll be targeting the 2020 election on a "the Conservatives didn't deliver on what Leave promised but UKIP will" platform. The next Conservative leader will probably offer Farage a peerage to try and neutralise him but I suspect he is far too clever to fall for such an obvious ploy.
- Gupie 10y ago"In a 52-48 referendum, this would be unfinished business by a long way." Nigel Farage, 17 May http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/nigel-farage-eu-referendum_uk_576e6585e4b08d2c56393f12 http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/nigel-farage-eu-refere...
- ProxCoques 10y agoThe trouble with that "democratically expressed opinon" was that a) it was a 2% majority b) 36% of eligible voters voted for leaving, and c) some proportion of those may well have either not undertood what they were voting for, or were misled. That, combined with the fact that things are currently going to hell in a hand basket (look at the FTSE250, comprised of business that make most their money within the UK, as opposed to the FTSE100 which doesn't), makes the out vote at best questonable right now. Be that as it may, I voted remain, but only beause now was not a good time to leave and nobody seemed to have a plan for exit. But I have faith in Britain - what I hope will happen is that we will accept freedom of movement, and that we will bloody well deal with it properly this time by shutting up the racists and investing in intrastructure, health and housing such that the cause of all the mess that led up to all this doesn't happen again. Fuck austerity this time - spend like there's no tomorrow, because frankly there might not be a tommorrow otherwise. Whethe that actually happens in my lifetime, I doubt, but hey oh.
- GordonS 10y ago> c) some proportion of those may well have either not undertood what they were voting for, or were misled. You could make the same argument about those that voted to remain. > That, combined with the fact that things are currently going to hell in a hand basket (look at the FTSE250, comprised of business that make most their money within the UK, as opposed to the FTSE100 which doesn't), makes the out vote at best questonable right now. Not really. It's only natural that there will be some short term downward moves in the markets due to uncertainty about the future. But we don't know what the medium and long term holds.
- DanBC 10y ago> You could make the same argument about those that voted to remain. Yes. Do you have any examples? Here's the one I'm going to keep using from the Leave campaign: http://imgur.com/indvx6a http://imgur.com/indvx6a
- ProxCoques 10y ago
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoBoris Johnson stated this morning that he didn't think immigration anxiety was why people voted for Brexit. This may well come as a surprise to many Brexit voters. It certainly sets out his stall for what he hopes to achieve, presumably he'll happily sign up for mass immigration as long as the finance industry gets opt-outs from EU fraud investigations or whatever his backers want to get out of this. Re-invigorating northern England's former industrial heartlands is nowhere on his list, and the anger of the people who live there can in no way harm the Conservative party in the UKs current parliamentary system.
- Chris2048 10y ago> may well come as a surprise to many Brexit voters Not to me - the opaque processes of unelected EU officials was the main reason.
- pjc50 10y agowe can expect politics in the UK to become dangerously divided and unsettled Other way round. UK politics was already divided and unsettled, it's just that an illusion of stability and consensus has been pasted on the front. The cardboard facade has collapsed when asked to bear weight - just look at the leadership chaos! This referendum and its result is really a result of dozens of problems which have been pushed under the rug. It's all the unexploded bombs of nasty controversies that were never properly defused, just piled up in a corner. The "immigration" question covers lots of nasty questions, for example. What is the EU doing about refugees? Why has Sangatte festered for so long? What should the right response to radical islamist violence be? What is the economic function of towns whose businesses collapsed in the 70s and have not improved? What's going on in the "crap towns" like Great Yarmouth and Boston, Lincs.? Why are voters struggling to get GP appointments and school places? What is the UK constitution? Don't say "unwritten", because that's not true; instead it's scattered bits and pieces from Factortame to the Good Friday Agreement. That's why we're having this discussion about Scotland blocking it - it's not clear how any of this works. Is it really a good idea that Parliament can make big constitutional changes by simple majority (e.g. Fixed Term Parliaments Act)? Why do we have so many different voting systems but use the crap one for the important election? Does the House of Lords count as "undemocratic" compared to, say, the EU commission? What is the proper relationship of the non-English parts of the UK to the Union? Scotland regards Westminster as the distant, unaccountable elite and finds the distant, unnacountable Brussels elite more cordial. Despite the fisheries problem. What should UK economic and employment policy be? Are we funding the current account deficit by selling houses to foreigners from kleptocratic states and China? Are we too dependent on financial services which are too centralised in London? Was Greece treated fairly? What about Portugal, Ireland, Italy and Spain? What about the Polish constitutional crisis? Is Hungary run by Nazis? What if the Austrian election had gone differently? Did you know the EU has a Trump-style border wall? It's in Bulgaria. This twitter gives the view from Northern Ireland, which was "dangerously divided and unsettled" for years with malign neglect from the UK government: https://twitter.com/shockproofbeats https://twitter.com/shockproofbeats I'm sure that you, personally, have answers to all these questions. My point is that there is no broad consensus on all of them, they've nagged at the UK for years, and now they've all been made relevant.
- 10y ago