10 ms·
Could the Scottish Parliament Stop the UK from Leaving the EU?
- pja 10y agoNo, but they can make thinks extremely awkward & almost certainly use it as leverage to exit the UK if they really want to. (Betteridge’s Law applies?)
- robhu 10y agoClause 28 of the 1998 Act notes at sub-clause 7, in dry terms, with regard to legislative competence that "this section does not affect the power of the Parliament of the United Kingdom to make laws for Scotland." In that single little line is the subordinate nature of devolution. Generally, Westminster will let the Scottish Parliament get on with devolved legislation. Carry on governing. But it is also made clear that Westminster's ultimate sovereignty over the UK, the entire UK, is unaffected. So in other words, no. The UK Parliament is sovereign over the Scottish one, although by convention they do not usually override it.
- romanovcode 10y agoGood, then they would again argue and whine that EU is putting them down like they did for the past 10 years. Enough is enough.
- jamescun 10y agoCorrect. My view is that Scotland CAN veto, but Westminster can override that veto. It creates a brilliant scenario for Scottish politicians, particularly those who seek independence; by vetoing they gain the support of their constituents while kicking the toxic can down the road to Westminster politicians, who should respect the results of the referendum, creating louder calls for a second Scottish referendum.
- simonh 10y agoThey can only veto it if the legislation comes before the Scottish parliament for review, and it won't. What they can do is pass resolutions in Scottish law incompatible with Brexit that Westminster will have to repeal or get struck down in the courts.
- gsnedders 10y ago> What they can do is pass resolutions in Scottish law incompatible with Brexit that Westminster will have to repeal or get struck down in the courts. Acts of Parliament cannot be struck down in the courts, in general. This is one of the cornerstones of Parliamentary Supremacy. I believe the only case where they can be is where they are found in contradiction to obligations of the EU treaties.
- simonh 10y agoYou're right, but I think they could make it very difficult for Westminster if they wanted to. It's not a fight they can legally win, but it could still be in their interests to fight it anyway. There's a joke going around here in London that we should devolve with them forming Scotlondon and set up immigration controls at M25 junctions. It's becoming pretty clear that a lot of exit voters never imagined it could actually happen and are suffering buyer's remorse.
- codecamper 10y agoSounds funny, but maybe closer to the reality of the modern age? So much of GDP now comes from cities & information workers, I'd imagine. Is it just London that wanted to remain? What about the other cities? I haven't followed the race closely, but I'm guessing it was the country bumpkins mostly in favor of leaving?
- mhw 10y ago> Is it just London that wanted to remain? What about the other cities? Despite much of the media describing this as the north voting to leave, Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds, Newcastle upon Tyne, Harrogate and York all voted to remain. Further south there's also Bristol, Cardiff, Cambridge, Oxford. There are cities and urban areas that voted to leave, but generally speaking it does seem to be that the areas with lower population density voted to leave. I'd be interested to see a visualisation which examined this correlation.
- gmac 10y agoAnd Brighton. Lots of university towns.
- simonh 10y agoAs always with these things it’s a mixed bag. How close some of these results were matters. Many of the other cities went remain by 50%-60%. London was a full 75% for remain though. Totally overwhelming. There was an interview with people at a market on the BBC yesterday and a stall holder was selling Spanish cherries. He voted brexit, but had a haunted look on his face and said he never believed it would happen. The journalist asked if he regretted it, he said something like "No..... but I wonder whether I made the right decision.". So that would be yes, then. Interactive results map: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-36616028 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-36616028
- Tepix 10y agoThe old rule applies: If the headline ends with a question mark, the answer is "no".
- klausjensen 10y agoIt is called "Betteridge's law of headlines" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- paradite 10y agoI think this is a rather bad headline because it is effectively a clickbait, i.e. you won't know the answer until you click on the title and read the article. Headline should summarize the main points in the news article as a statement, rather than posing a question to the reader.
- ubernostrum 10y agoIt's more "does Scotland offer a face-saving way out of triggering Article 50 and exiting the EU". The answer to that may be yes.
- zargay01 10y agoSo in finest journalistic tradition, if a headline contains a question then the answer to that question is no.
- davidgerard 10y agoThis is a lot of words to say "technically maybe, but they're not so stupid as to try without a lot of public backing."
- whiteandnerdy 10y agoI think the position is: technically no, practically almost certainly no, but politically it might be a sensible move for the SNP to strengthen support from Scottish voters.
- davidgerard 10y agoApparently it's now polling 59% https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/747320186433208321 https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/747320186433208321
- seanalltogether 10y agoThe UK has a mandate from the people to leave the EU. Attempting to block the brexit over technicalities in Unionist agreements is a weak position for any politician to take. If the SNP believes they can successfully build a new mandate from the Scottish people to leave the UK, that would be a position of strength and they should work with that.
- alkonaut 10y ago> The UK has a mandate from the people to leave the EU. The question no one seems to have thought to answer until now, is whether Boris or any other politician has a mandate to dissolve the UK in order to do so. Does anyone believe that if the vote had been "Should England leave the UK and the EU" it would have won majority?
- learnstats2 10y agoPolitics is a game of chess - the suggestion of blocking Brexit is a tactic that the SNP can use to help get a second referendum on their terms.
- tallanvor 10y agoThe referendum was non-binding. While a majority of those who voted said leave, the role of the government is to do what's best for their country and their people, and that's not always going to correspond to what a majority says should be done.
- coldtea 10y agoIt was also no joke.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ck425 10y agoThe First Minister also has a mandate to represent the Scottish people, who voted to stay in the EU, and most whose elected officials are pro-EU. Not to say I disagree with you, but Nicola Sturgeon (her own political goals aside) is only being competent by exploring these possibilities. Views aside it's nice to see there's at least one British political leader that actually has plans and is publicly engaging in a conversation on what should be next.
- throwaway987611 10y agoNo. Sturgeon is just playing up to her base. Scotland is effectively a one party system, which is quite dangerous, never mind that the common man/woman do not see this. The consequences for leaving the UK are well known. Companies aren't going to stay in because of Europe. They are going to move over the border. Also. The UK rescued the Scottish banks. Scotland will have to take on half this debt. Will the EU bail out Scotland? Will there be Greece style terms? So with the debt, companies leaving, not getting much tax receipts. How will Scotland pay for the FREE tuition, FREE healthcare, FREE this and FREE that, they like to promise? Is the EU going to be sending them FREE monies? Finally and this is where I tend to laugh the most. Once Scotland joins Europe and the Euro. How is Scotland an independent state in Europe? How have Scottish people not realised this? Go look at Greece! Scotland won't be able to control her economy. The EU bureaucrats will not do what's in her best interests. They'll do what's in THEIR best interests! So what happens when Scotland no longer has control of her finances, can't pay for the FREE stuff. Oh and then slips into recession and the UK is doing better off? Yeah, that's the joke. Oh and the UK won't let Scotland use the pound. I can tell you that now!
- ubernostrum 10y agoThe consequences for leaving the UK are well known. The consequences for leaving the EU were well-known and kicked in within hours of the votes being tallied last week, but didn't stop the English from voting to do it anyway. And if we're going to allow the English to be that reckless on the basis of a single simple-majority vote, I don't see why we oughtn't let the Scots do the same.
- cmdkeen 10y agoThe consequences for Scotland leaving the UK are an order of magnitude worse, and that is if they were guaranteed admission to the EU on a roughly similar basis to to the UK's current status. In reality they would probably have to adopt the Euro and thus have even less control over fiscal policy which would mean dealing with the 9% budget deficit, higher than Greece's which would be political suicide.
- rando444 10y ago
- mhandley 10y agoAbout the only thing that might stop the UK leaving now would be for the new conservative leader to call a snap general election, thinking that labour are in serious disarray. Then labour campaign on not leaving the EU, and together with the SNP, win. The new labour/SNP government would be able to claim a mandate from the electorate to not leave. I don't think it's going to happen though.
- abpavel 10y agoAny outcome other than UK leaving the EU would go against democratically elected decision, in essence suspending democracy.
- hmmdiggy 10y agoThis is also my opinion, but for those downvoting/greying this comment could you elaborate why you disagree?
- learnstats2 10y agoI believe democracy is about following the will of the people. As such, there are several levels I object to this comment, in particular that we have fair reason to believe the will of the people might have changed in recent days. Stubbornly following the result of a majority vote is majoritarianism, not democracy.
- samdoidge 10y agoStubbornly following the result of a majority vote is majoritarianism, not democracy. Nonsense. In the case of an A/B referendum, following the majority vote is democracy.
- vkou 10y agoThe public isn't ever asked to vote on wars, trade deals, etc. When it is asked to shoot itself in the foot with a non-binding referendum, overturning it would be no different. In a representative democracy, all you vote for is your representative. The rest is politics.
- hollander 10y agoHow to get out of this mess: quit with this government, call for new elections. Then you make it an election subject: will we follow the referendum or not?! The referendum is advisory, not legally binding. So they can ignore it. If the new elections are clear and people vote 55% to stay in - it's a clear cut case.
- hmmdiggy 10y ago> Then you make it an election subject It was one of the main election subjects back in May 2015 to whether to hold the referendum or not. Making whether to follow through another election subject would be wasteful considering leave has the majority.
- pluteoid 10y agoAs things stand, Cameron will be replaced by a new Conservative leader in October who will be under pressure to call a general election more or less immediately (without the present mess we were not due another one until 2020). The Liberal Democrats, our third largest party, have pledged to run an election campaign based on nullifying the Brexit vote. So it seems what you propose is going to happen, but unfortunately the "Illiberal Undemocrats" are an unpopular choice for a wide variety of reasons...
- alexbilbie 10y agoThe PM can't call for a general election anymore due to the Fixed Term Parliament Act 2011. Only a vote of no confidence in the Government by MPs or a unilateral decision by two thirds of MPs can break the five year parliament and result in a general election.
- pluteoid 10y agoAnd that's exactly what we'll probably see here – 2/3 majority call for a general election. Just read the current headlines.
- Magnets 10y agoThe way our election system works, nothing is clear cut, it's partly why so many don't vote in general elections and why so many did vote in the referendum. (66% vs 72% turnout). How would the conservatives pledge? Half of them want out and spent the last few months campaigning for it. Many Labour areas of the country voted to leave, calling an election would just provide more confusion. I also don't think it's a good idea to just vote in a government based on 1 aspect
- Nursie 10y agoThere's a lot of clutching at straws going on at the moment. People coming out with political or legal theories, trying to interpret David Cameron's failure to immediately declare leaving under article 50 as kicking the whole issue into the long grass etc etc. This is the latest, like others it's more of an exercise in denial than it is in reality. Many of these things could come to pass, it's true, but each one carries with it the implication that a direct democratic mandate, to leave the EU, is ignored. If this occurs we can expect politics in the UK to become dangerously divided and unsettled, and the likes of UKIP to become a seriously large party in the next parliament, not to mention civil unrest in various forms. The people that voted leave already feel left behind and ignored by the state. Explicitly ignoring them and finding a way to work around their democratically expressed opinion is likely to be a really BAD idea. --edit-- I notice the points attached to this post going up and down. To those downvoting, can you tell me where/why you disagree?
- DanBC 10y ago> David Cameron's failure to immediately declare leaving under article 50 as kicking the whole issue into the long grass Maybe not the long grass, but it's a poison chalice for the next leader for the reasons you say - trigger article 50 and Scotland leaves UK and tries to join EU. Don't leave and the majority voters get angry. (And we really don't need them getting angrier since a small minority are angry enough to spray paint Polish community centres; to print and laminate "no more polish vermin" cards. (EDIT: Both these things have happened post-ref.)
- Nursie 10y agoOh there's political poison all over the place. It's one of the reasons I considered voting leave and am not too pissed off that the way I did vote didn't win - it's rather delightful seeing the turmoil at Westminster.
- jacquesm 10y ago> it's rather delightful seeing the turmoil at Westminster. Some men just love to watch the world burn. I will never understand this sentiment.
- kriro 10y agoI feel it is usually assumed somewhat nonchalantly that the Scots could split off as an independent nation. One signal of the Brexit vote is that nationalists (or empireists) will be represented stronger in future elections. I can see a (neo-imperialistic) future where it is in the interest of England to not let anyone split off and fight for that with all means. I think the hardline will be Northern Ireland but strategically speaking it would make sense to not allow precedent and keep Scotland in.
- alkonaut 10y agoLegally, as far as I understand no. But politically? Almost certainly. If Scotland could remain in the EU (By remaining, not re-joining, which Madrid would oppose) then they almost certainly would. This means that "brexit" would imply the end of the "United" in the UK and I believe that would be enough of a change in circumstances that a) leave politicians could hold off invoking Article 50 without losing face or b) a referendum for the new conditions could be held. So the Scottish Parliament don't really need to veto Brexit to stop it, they just need to threaten to leave the UK and remain in the EU to d oso. The new conditions of Brexit (which really were known before but likely not phrased as such) are "Should England and Wales leave the UK and form the United Kingdom of England and Wales, and then leave the EU?". I doubt that's a very popular idea.
- Nursie 10y agoNI, despite voting remain, is very unlikely to want to leave the UK. Scotland 'remaining' in the EU is far from a done deal, we have yet to hear whether the EU would accept it - it has no record of running its own economy to speak of.
- broodbucket 10y agoIt does raise some new issues, as there is now an unpoliced border between EU and non-EU in Ireland. (and by now I mean soon)
- Nursie 10y agoIt does indeed, and there's going to have to be some careful figuring-stuff-out going on, depending on exactly what path the EU and UK take now. There is precedent for open borders between EU and non-EU countries, Norway and Sweden for instance. But that situation is not exactly analagous and I'm not going to pretend I think there's an easy solution.
- broodbucket 10y agoThis is all so interesting! So much uncharted territory, competing factions and general uncertainty. As a non-European this is terrific.
- lhnz 10y agoWill it matter to Scotland's goal of joining the EU after getting independence from the UK that they would have the worst deficit in the developing world [0] and have, in the past, only been a net contributor to the UK economy in three of the last fifteen years [1]? It seems to me that the EU might require Scotland to make huge cuts to public spending. Would Scotland's independence be worth more to them than say free university tuition? I guess the SNP would avoid making cuts to certain nationally loved items, but something would surely have to give; either they would get higher taxes, or public spending would have to fall. Of course, the EU might agree to let them remain and also allow them their deficit, but there looks to be an increasing strain on the EU's richest members, so who knows whether that would be allowed. [0] http://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2016/03/if-scotland-had-gone-independent-today-it-would-be-facing-sado-austerity/ http://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2016/03/if-scotland-had-gone-in... [1] http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/simple-summary.html http://chokkablog.blogspot.co.uk/2015/03/simple-summary.html
- ProfChronos 10y agoObviously they won't force the UK into staying in the EU but that's definitely not what's important here. They are just starting UK's internal discrepancies which could seriously damage the union and Westminster won't be able to do much about it. England is already a well developed country which can't accept to be under the EU's power, while Scotland and others know that they're path to economic prosperity leads to the EU and its package of regulations and standards. As they France, Germany and the EU Commission likely to be tough on the UK, they are doing everything they can to stop the future bleeding. All this in one brilliant graphics: http://i64.tinypic.com/1zdu79u.jpg http://i64.tinypic.com/1zdu79u.jpg
- pi-err 10y agoTo quote a Tory MP: "Nicola Sturgeon seems to be the only one who knows what's she's doing". Warning of a constitutional crisis is good tactics. It probably will not lead to canceling brexit, though it will probably break the 1998 devolution law and change how Scotland can "sell" independence and its claim to stay in the EU. So it looks like this is either to lay ground for a "fast track" EU access due to special circumstances - OR getting special new rights within the UK to compensate leaving the EU.
- ck425 10y agoDefinitely the former. That and possibly an attempt at a second indyref if the current momentum doesn't die. I live in Edinburgh, one of the areas with the highest No vote in the indyref, and pretty much everyone I talk to who voted No would strongly consider a Yes vote. Depending how the situation in westminster develops, this might calm down or it could get stronger.
- sievebrain 10y agoThey're mad now. But a second referendum would force the situation to be analysed a lot more carefully. And that situation would not be a strong argument for leaving, no matter how much the Scots might like the idea of the EU.
- ck425 10y agoYou presume the referendum will be based on sound analysis. If there's one thing the EUref has shown it's that you don't need sound analysis. It also depends heavily on how the UK does in the coming year. The UK needs to be economically and politically powerful enough that it's not worth giving up for self determination. It doesn't need to be a better deal, it has to be better enough to defeat romantic notions of independence.
- sievebrain 10y agoThere you go: assuming the analysis of leave voters was not sound. Many voters made a very straightforward analysis: "the EU means I compete against an essentially infinite supply of labour, I can't do that, therefore we should get out of the EU so we can restrict immigration again". You may not agree with this reasoning or you may feel the various other benefits of the EU outweigh them in your personal circumstances, but it's not an illogical analysis: they think leaving will make them economically better off and there are millions of such voters. It's actually quite difficult to mount a robust economic argument against this idea: you have to argue that the EU will erect such serious trade barriers that all the jobs disappear. But a lot of these people are working in local service industries anyway, they aren't selling to the EU, so you end up arguing a very indirect path to them personally suffering which basically rests on "the EU will be such bastards that the entire UK economy collapses", which then stirs up patriotic sentiments very strongly (reminds people of the war). And you rapidly end up in economic wonk territory because the details of the damage depend so much on details of the final deal, etc. The public, quite rightly, does not trust economists due to their track record of getting the big things wrong. The economic rationale for Scotland leaving the UK and joining the EU is much less clear. The big one is public spending. The Scots may not like it but their country is subsidised by the UK to a huge degree. The spending deficit alone is the same size as ALL Scottish NHS spending. The economic argument from "lose the subsidies from the English, public services are cut because oil is cheap" is very direct and much more easily understood. Scotland does not have a problem with massive immigration. People like the idea of the EU but what specific economic problem would it solve for them?
- pmontra 10y agoSeen from another EU country, saddened as I am by the UK leaving the Union, my take on this is: 1) Even if the referendum is advisory, given the importance of the issue it would be difficult to dismiss it and do as if it didn't happen. I'd be embarrassed to make decisions with leaders that are willing to ignore such address from their people. 2) It's better for the UK to leave as quickly as possible because uncertainty is bad. It's bad for business and for anybody. See the hours we are wasting writing about it ;-) Furthermore uncertainty could prompt unrest, especially in the UK (you voted, you won, you're ignored, you get angrier and angrier). 3) There is no reason not to keep being friends, even if a little disillusioned, and keep doing business together. There will be some extra barriers and cross border exchanges will decrease, but IMHO the UK should become as one of those other European countries that don't belong to the EU. No need to be punitive. 4) If Scotland wants to stay in the EU they should either get independent or make some clear deal with the UK, and the EU to accept them. I understand but not approve the reason for Spain not liking the idea, but they'll be frowned at quite a lot. 5) There are territories around the world, some virtually independent from the country that claims rights on them. There are some of the especially in Asia, maybe for face saving reasons. Could Scotland be the next one? Even London is possible, but much more difficult to implement IHMO. That said, we are human beings and we are used to bend the written words to our wills. If we agree on the result any act or constitutional chart can be interpreted to match it or changed.
- kuschku 10y ago> No need to be punitive. Except, to prevent other EU nations from leaving, brexit should be as painful as possible. Ideally with the UK falling apart.
- pmontra 10y agoIf it falls apart it will be because of its internal divisions, not because of external punishment. Actually, punishment often strengthens the bonds among the punished especially if it's deemed to be unjust. And a feeling of injustice could drive other countries to dislike the Union even more. It's a double edged sword that I wouldn't wield.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sambeau 10y agoHidden in the same discussion paper is the fact that the Northern Ireland (and Welsh) parliaments would also have to ratify the new laws required to remove EU law from their legal systems. The Northern Ireland parliament would be incompetent if they voted for it. Removing the EU from Northern Ireland would break the Good Friday agreement and has the real potential to throw them back into war.