3 ms·
The stupid part about this is that this ruling will only affect stuff hosted on German servers, so only dewiki will be affected. Even then, someone will likely
by cooper12 10y ago
The stupid part about this is that this ruling will only affect stuff hosted on German servers, so only dewiki will be affected. Even then, someone will likely go in and sneak a few pictures that are "good enough" for Wikipedia purposes. All they've accomplished here is further restricting the public domain in Germany while not stopping Wikipedia from using their images. (We call that "cutting off the nose to spite the face") Now Germans will need intimate physical access to a work in the public domain to be able to get their own copyright to share it. Very disappointing for a museum, especially one which takes pride in receiving public funds. (Though of course the court shares more blame for making such a decision)
- incompatible 10y agoI though all the Wikipedia servers were hosted in the US, regardless of language. de.wikipedia.org has address 198.35.26.96, which seems to be in the US. That would make it easy to ignore German court rulings if desired.
- cooper12 10y agoWhoops, you're right. Looks like I misread the relevant passage: > The German court dismissed the case against Wikimedia Deutschland on the grounds that it was not legally responsible for the files in question, which were held by Wikimedia Commons in the US, which in turn are managed by the Wikimedia Foundation.