3 ms·
Your point doesn't contradict mine even if made-up 51% number was true. Selective as usual focusing on its start and fact there's USG funding. Yet, a person loo
by nickpsecurity 10y ago
Your point doesn't contradict mine even if made-up 51% number was true. Selective as usual focusing on its start and fact there's USG funding. Yet, a person looking on site at "About Tor," "Core team," and "Sponsors" doesn't get a clear indicator that the vast majority of funds so far as come from groups CIA created to wage propaganda wars and act for U.S. foreign policy. That fronts allegedly separated from despite them doing basically the same jobs today funded by U.S. government doesn't reduce that concern. Readers might think instead it's a mostly for-the-people organization whose funding is spread out among many groups instead of the kind its libertarian proponents would seem to fight rather than work for. Then, we have chat logs from a group funded by CIA & affiliates worried about their image if one CIA person is in the project.
Hence, "sort of." I'll change my statement to their source of support being clear when they state such things clearly on their web site and stop the kind of smears I saw in response to the Pando article. I mean, here's people taking money from CIA and/or affiliates openly speculating that someone saying so or implying it means something must be... working for CIA, a fascist, or something in a smear job. Repeat, people paid by vicious, authoritarian regimes they claim to fight accusing someone of evil or connections to such regimes for reporting their source of funding. Unreal...
I'll be interested to see how long popular support for Tor lasts if it's marketed as a former Navy tool currently supported by CIA and State department groups. The reality probably will change the perception of it and when/where to use it a lot. I still support the project as realists like me know it's a double-edge sword they need to work but might try to compromise in limited ways. Hence, me pushing strong security engineering to be applied to it.
- 89284923482 10y agoThe 51% was a joke, and a good one at that.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoI got it. Stepped on it in my counter. The response to Pando piece and these logs don't fit that joke or its implication at all. Plus a strawman given Tor is meant for laypeople mostly. Let's restate the Tor sponsor page differently to show what they're doing: "A US project about helping people enable anonymity plus fight oppression of authoritive regimes, from China to US, that's mostly paid for by CIA and other US propaganda organizations along with small contributions from these other organizations." Juxtapose that against the IRC logs for the real joke. They fear what will happen if seen as affiliated with even one CIA person. Only imagine what their image would be like if lay users, not just security experts, saw their funding spread and sourcing. Probably why they present the sponsor page and other parts they way they do. Obscuring source to maximize uptake. Truth is that they're a tool that can be wielded for good or bad. That it's mostly US govt villians funding it is acceptable to me for greater good so long as legit software. It is so Im fine. That's realistic. This hide the CIA guy crap doesnt fit with reality if they push a genuine one.