7 ms·
Digitising public domain images creates a new copyright, rules German court
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> The General-Director of the Reiss Engelhorn Museum, Prof. Dr. Alfried Wieczorek, told Ars why the museum had decided to take legal action: "As far as we are concerned this case is not about harming Wikipedia, or of us fundamentally disagreeing with this project. On the contrary: we have great sympathy for the Wikipedia project, and share with Wikipedia the object of spreading knowledge. But in this case, the question for us is who should decide whether and especially how our holdings should be made available. Even if one supports the free public accessibility of cultural items on Wikipedia, it is difficult for us to comprehend that a single Wikipedia author claims the right to decide on their own to release to everybody the results of work created with public funds on Wikipedia for free and thus also for commercial use." So, while it might be ok for wikipedia to publish images of public-domain work, it is unconscionable for wikipedia to publish images of public-domain work that someone else subsequently makes commercial use of. (And it's important that the museum get a veto over whether the public should be allowed to see certain works at all.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cooper12 10y agoThe stupid part about this is that this ruling will only affect stuff hosted on German servers, so only dewiki will be affected. Even then, someone will likely go in and sneak a few pictures that are "good enough" for Wikipedia purposes. All they've accomplished here is further restricting the public domain in Germany while not stopping Wikipedia from using their images. (We call that "cutting off the nose to spite the face") Now Germans will need intimate physical access to a work in the public domain to be able to get their own copyright to share it. Very disappointing for a museum, especially one which takes pride in receiving public funds. (Though of course the court shares more blame for making such a decision)
- incompatible 10y agoI though all the Wikipedia servers were hosted in the US, regardless of language. de.wikipedia.org has address 198.35.26.96, which seems to be in the US. That would make it easy to ignore German court rulings if desired.
- cooper12 10y agoWhoops, you're right. Looks like I misread the relevant passage: > The German court dismissed the case against Wikimedia Deutschland on the grounds that it was not legally responsible for the files in question, which were held by Wikimedia Commons in the US, which in turn are managed by the Wikimedia Foundation.
- acabal 10y agoTragic and nonsensical decision. Just one more avenue for our cultural heritage to be locked away for eternity, when technology is on the cusp of allowing us to share that heritage with everyone worldwide for the first time in history. How would this affect things like gutenberg.spiegel.de? Would a German digital transcriber of a PD work then hold the German copyright for that digital version, until 70 years after the transcriber's death? Ridiculous!
- detaro 10y agoImportant to note: the argument in this case is not "the museum owns the original artwork, thus it can stop people from freely licensing their photos of it", but "the museum owns the rights on the photo, and can decide if it releases it to the public domain or not". It's not about the rights of the owner of the artwork, but about the rights of the owner of the photo. Photographs have a slightly elevated standing in German law, with lower demands on creativity to get protection, and I'll assume that's the way the court got to this decision. We'll see if it survives in front of higher courts. I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't. In your transcriber example (assuming transcriptions and photographs would follow the same rules, which they don't), the transcriber would have the rights to his/her transcription, but couldn't stop anybody else to transcribe the same PD work and release their transcription. I agree with wikipedia that this question shouldn't have come up, because I'd prefer if public museums were required to release such photos under some kind of free license, although I'd be fine with restrictions for commercial use.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoDoes this mean if I create a 3D model of a physical object, I know hold the copyright to that objects digital representation? And if so, does anything prevent me from registering said copyright and providing it to the public domain?
- Bromskloss 10y agoRegistering a copyright? Is that something you can do in Germany? I thought that was something that existed only in the United States, and only a long time ago.
- Doctor_Fegg 10y agoVery curious given that the UK, which has always taken a maximalist view on this, quietly rowed back last year and said that maybe it doesn't create a new copyright after all.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI'm confused. Does this merely mean that if I take a photo of something in the public domain, I hold the copyright on that particular reproduction? Or that if a museum takes a photo of something in the public domain, they can restrict others from offering/using their own photos of that work?
- detaro 10y agoRoughly the first.
- oh_sigh 10y agoThe first one. The Mona Lisa is in the public domain. You can include an image of it in whatever you are creating without asking anyones permission. However, lets say you take a picture of the Mona Lisa. That image is not in the public domain, and it is your image and you can prevent people from using your image without consent.
- parent5446 10y agoTo clarify, because the original article doesn't really mention this: the photos that were uploaded to Wikimedia Commons were taken by a photographer hired by the museum, not Commons users. The museum is claiming that they hold copyright over the photos because even though the original artwork is in the public domain, the photo taken of it has its own copyright, held by the museum's photographer (and thus the museum).
- pavel_lishin 10y agoThat seems completely reasonable to me.
- anonbanker 10y agoSo germans should be running to their local library, in order to digitize everything and claim new copyright? Better the citizenry do it than corporations.
- incompatible 10y agoThey'd only have copyright over their own photo (and it's not clear a scan would count). Anybody else could still make another photo with a separate copyright.
- anonbanker 10y agowhy wouldn't a scan count? Every tax agency I've ever heard of accepts scans in lieu of paper.
- incompatible 10y agoBecause the German ruling applied specifically to photographs, if I understand correctly.
- byuu 10y agoSigh ... as much of a supporter I am of the public domain, I'm really thinking we just need to end the charade that a "public domain" even exists anymore. Because, increasingly, it doesn't. Let's face it ... I'll never see a single work made within my lifetime make it the public domain. And copyrights are just going to keep getting extended and extended. Mickey Mouse is never making it to the public domain. And as if having to go back to pre-World War II to find public domain works wasn't enough, now they're trying to undermine even that! If I thought there were any chance we could change the laws toward our favor, I wouldn't advocate this. But I just don't see any hope at all anymore. So let's just call a spade a spade, and state that the public domain doesn't exist: everyone owns everything, forever. We'll reclassify historians and preservationists as unquestionably being "pirates". Most of us already are. But the few left that are trying to play within the confines of the law, only to continually have the rug pulled out from under them, can get to work with the rest of us on the wrong side of the law. Civil disobedience is the only recourse we have left. It's that, or we give up our very history to corporate interests.
- vacri 10y ago>I'll never see a single work made within my lifetime make it the public domain. Plenty of work makes it to the public domain; it just need to be noted as such by the creator, and creators do do that from time to time. On Mickey Mouse specifically, I don't really have a problem with that one. Mickey Mouse isn't something created by someone who is riding on their past successes and whose descendants are riding on the coattails of. It's an actively developed and organised bit of intellectual property, which is responsible for literally thousands of jobs. They are actively working their IP, rather than merely sitting back and demanding a cut if other people want to work it. As such, I think protection for that is reasonable, as it is a going business concern. I have far more problem with IP not making it to public domain if it's not actively worked. An example from Australia: there was an iconic song "Land Down Under" in the 80s, in which a 12-note melody was in the bridge. That melody was "Kookaburra sits in the old gum tree", a very recognisable Australiana kids/folk tune. The original owners didn't pursue damages, but nearly 20 years after the pop song made it, a business group bought the rights to Kookaburra and sued the creators of the pop song. This business group didn't 'value add' to the IP - they didn't actively work it. The case turned out with a relatively sensible ending - the judge gave some minor royalties to the rights holders because while the melody was clearly in use (it was the point of using that melody, after all), it wasn't the main theme of the song. So I think copyright should be a bit more complex - if you're actually actively working the IP to a reasonable (yes, 'define reasonable...') amount, you should be able to extend it. Otherwise, expiry as it used to be. Some protection would need to be figured out to prevent trivial token 'working', of course.
- azov 10y agoThere's an infinite number of ways to digitize a painting. What if you invented, say, a new algorithm to calculate colors from bayer pattern? Or an entirely new sensor (as, e.g. Foveon, did)? Or, maybe, a new lighting scheme that produces more accurate colors? Should you be denied the copyright on your work because you "sought to reproduce the paintings as exactly as possible"? I don't think so. In this respect the court decision makes sense to me. On the other hand, I agree that preventing sharing of public domain works runs counter to the mission of public museum and, while legally entitled to, they probably shouldn't exercise their copyright in this way.
- tssva 10y agoYour work is the sensor, algorithm or lighting scheme and you should own the relevant patents and/or copyright to those. The exact copy of an image in the public domain that you take using those should not be copyrighted.
- jwatte 10y agoI think there's nothing wrong with mechanical rights for the digitization. Each person shooting their own picture gets their own mechanical copyright. (This is the same as difference between the specific recording, and the written song, in music)
- incompatible 10y agoHow would you even distinguish one from another, once they've been processed a bit in graphics software and copied all over the web?
- germanier 10y agoYou can usually tell the images apart if you have some resolution to play with. Taking such pictures in sufficient quality takes some skill (e.g. with regards to lighting) that two different photographers usually end up with two different picture of the same painting. And even if you can't tell those two images apart you can often trace the image back to its origin.
- jwatte 10y agoI think there's nothing wrong with mechanical rights for the digitization. Each person shooting their own picture gets their own mechanical copyright. (This is the same as difference between the specific recording, and the written song, in music)
- Animats 10y agoIt will be interesting to see how this plays out in German law. US and UK courts have already established that in those countries, copying an image does not establish a new copyright. In the US, this is a Constitutional limitation: "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." The key US rulings are Feist vs. Rural Telephone (telephone directories cannot be copyrighted because they're just collection of facts, not creative works) and Bridgeman vs. Corel (photos of public domain images cannot be copyrighted because they are not creative works.) There's also Meshwerks vs. Toyota, which reaffirms Bridgeman at the circuit court level and extends it to 3D scans. (scans of 3D objects create no new rights.) In the US, databases of facts are not copyrightable. The European Union, though, has a 15 year copyright-like right for databases.
- esbranson 10y agoThis decision only binds these parties with relation to these pictures in these circumstances. No one else. Other courts, even this Berlin trial/appeals court or an inferior Berlin court, need not pay any attention to this legal reasoning in other cases.
- germanier 10y agoThey don't need to but more often than not they do if the legal argument holds any merit at all. And this is not the first time a court has argued that way creating a substantial risk that the next time the decision will be similiar.
- FeatureRush 10y agoThis is kind of similar to how thing are in Poland, so maybe other countries in EU work the same way? In short, digitalising creates new "pole eksploatacji" (~field of exploitation/utilisation) for image, and by the law each such field needs to be explicitly named in agreement with the author. And no, you CAN NOT give rights to all of them, either known or invented in the future. All of them have to be explicitly named, and the law itself does not contain any list of them, just some examples. For example even if tablet, PC and console all are just a computer for the purpose of distributing video they could be counted as something different even if video is streamed from the same source. Other circumstances like if consumers are buying the copy or just renting it, or if it can be viewed at restricted or any time etc. may also be important. By default author is entitled to payment even if agreement doesn't mention it. Finally apart for the above part (called "autorskie prawa majątkowe") there are also "autorskie prawa osobiste" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights ) which can not be licensed away, and at least from my point of view seem to be less popular in US. I've heard this law (mostly explicitly naming fields of utilisation) creates some issues with digitalisation of old archives here in Poland, but I don't remember the details. I'm not a lawyer, it's couple of years after I learned it so there might be mistakes, if someone could correct me I would be grateful. EDIT: better example