4 ms·
I'm glad this is the topmost comment. Punishing the 99.5% of good actors to sometimes discover the 0.5% of bad actors seems exactly like forcing people to prov
by pmarreck 10y ago
I'm glad this is the topmost comment.
Punishing the 99.5% of good actors to sometimes discover the 0.5% of bad actors seems exactly like forcing people to prove their innocence as all are presumed guilty.
- rayiner 10y ago"Punishment" and "guilt" and "innocence" are irrelevant concepts here. Banks aren't being "punished" by being required to implement money laundering controls. It's a condition of doing business as a bank, to serve certain government objectives. More generally: no western government recognizes a "fundamental right to commerce" such that restrictions on commerce require the existence of "bad" conduct worthy of punishment.[1] There is nothing "bad" about not implementing money laundering controls, just as there is nothing "bad" about talking a left turn on Constitution Ave between 9-5 on a weekday. But the government doesn't need to show its "bad" to implement the regulation. [1] Though we kind of tried that in the U.S. under the concept of economic due process.
- defen 10y ago> More generally: no western government recognizes a "fundamental right to commerce" such that restrictions on commerce require the existence of "bad" conduct worthy of punishment. That's very interesting. I'm not going to argue with your claim, because I assume you know more about it than I do. But it's a very strange idea, because in many ways commerce is more fundamental than anything in the Constitution or its amendments. Take away everything in the Bill of Rights, all the freedoms defined in the Constitution and our heritage of common law, take it all away and you can still have a society. It would be a terrible, awful society that no one would choose to live in (probably something like the DPRK) but it would still be a society. But without commerce, it is simply not possible to even have a society. I would go even further and say that a vanishingly small percentage of people would even be able to survive without commerce. So in a certain sense it's just as important as air, food, and water.
- rayiner 10y agoI don't think commerce is more fundamental. Humans survived for hundreds of thousands of years without commerce as we know it. Even at the time of the founding, the vast majority of Americans were living on mostly self-sufficient farms. Commerce in the modern sense is enabled by government: protection of property rights, imposition of a common currency, protection against pirates on the high seas. You can argue that government isn't necessary to enable commerce. That you could have a world that has commerce without government. But even if that were true, in the world we do have, commerce is built upon the infrastructure provided by government. Just like the road system. And the government is thus entitled to regulate commerce just like it regulates left-hand turns on roads. Of course, this is just an argument that regulation of monetary transactions is consistent with the assumptions underlying our institutions. I have no opinion on whether money-laundering controls are a good idea or not.
- defen 10y ago> Even at the time of the founding, the vast majority of Americans were living on mostly self-sufficient farms People still bartered, which is recognized and taxed as commerce by the US government. They did not build or repair their own tools, for example - the village blacksmith was usually the most important man in town (or the region). You could argue that once they had a set of tools and land, people could be self-sufficient, but they still engaged in trade. And they would not have been able to be self-sufficient without trading beforehand - how else would you get a horse?
- rayiner 10y agoBut if you ordered some horseshoes made and then refused to take delivery, the blacksmith would still sue you in a government court.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThere are a wide variety of commerce systems that require no government courts. Consider the Silent Trade, the old system used by Africans and Indians to trade. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silent_trade https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silent_trade Realistically, in Colonial America, reputation systems and the like were probably used far more than courts. In fact, even today, extra-legal systems are widely used. My company buys SAAS services primarily from the US and Australia, but we have little ability to use the courts in either of those countries. How do we know Atlassian or Cloudflare won't take our rupees and run?