3 ms·
PM Cameron wanted to keep his word about reducing the number of immigrants to 10,000 per year from 333,000 but he was not allowed to because of EU leadership N
by tremon 10y ago
PM Cameron wanted to keep his word about reducing the number of immigrants to 10,000 per year from 333,000 but he was not allowed to because of EU leadership
No, he blamed the EU to hide his own government's failure. EU immigration accounted for only 50% of the 300,000. So his own government allowed 150,000 non-EU immigrants into the country. The EU had nothing to do with that. You may have had a valid point if the total immigration number was 160,000, of which 150,000 from the EU. But not now.
Readers of HN are in a position to challenge numbers fed to them
Thank you, I can, and I will. First of all, the 3.3 million immigrants are not all from the EU. If the numbers for other years are similar, at most 50% of those are from the EU. I suspect the number is even smaller because EU citizens can also more easily move back home.
Secondly, the EU citizens entering the country are mainly migrant workers, that implies that they are on average younger and more able-bodied than the native population. So your argument that the 1.6 million EU migrants are a similar burden on the NHS than the native (elderly) population is a stretch.
Your £6 billion figure comes completely without backing, so I will reject it because of the above.
- davidf18 10y agoThe people were upset about all immigration independent of whether they were from the EU or not. The BrExit vote was about all immigration, not just that from the EU. The working class hardly cares whether their jobs are taken or wages depressed by EU immigrants or immigrants outside the EU. You present no data about immigration ages (many parents, grandparents presumably come with their adult children to stay in Britain). In addition, immigrants from poorer countries independent of age may have more health problems and unhealthy behaviors (eg, cigarette smoking) that are more expensive to treat. Thus, without additional data about the health characteristics of the immigrant population, it is reasonable to assume that their health problems are consistent with those non-immigrants if not more expensive because of unhealthy environments and lower quality medical care in poorer countries that the immigrants came from. Thus it is reasonable to assume 3.3 million immigrants, about 5% of the population consuming 5% of the NHS budget of £6 billion. Even if this were off by a factor of two, it would still be £3 billion, not £160 million. The £160 million additional increase would suggest that the NHS additional cost for 5% of the population is 0.15% of £115. The "fact source" you cite seems to have some sort of political axe to grind for a 0.15% increase for 5% of the population is simply not credible.