4 ms·
Privatization sounds great when you can afford your own private services. Otherwise, tough luck, pull on those bootstraps harder.
by nkrisc 10y ago
Privatization sounds great when you can afford your own private services. Otherwise, tough luck, pull on those bootstraps harder.
- hackuser 10y agoAlso, privatization often means: Give big government contracts to the campaign donors of the politician pushing privatization.
- digi_owl 10y agoOh so very much this. Also the IPO antics when a formerly public service is made into a private company...
- stevendhansen 10y agoThe only alternatives to privatization I can see are: 1) force the population to collectively pay for these services or 2) force specific individuals to provide these services for free Option 1 is morally questionable and option 2 is a type of slavery, so it seems privatization isnt quite as bad as the alternatives. At least with a privatized service those who wish to opt out, can.
- SolaceQuantum 10y agoWait, why is it morally questionable that a society comes together to, uh, pool resources and do social things? We are a social species. It makes sense that a social species pools resources together for the good of their collective whole.
- arcticbull 10y agoRemind me, how is the collection of taxes to pay for services in the public interest 'morally questionable'? The fire department in particular is such an obvious case because a fire affecting one property can easily spread to the next -- and so on. Is that something you want to happen because the property owner of the first house couldn't afford the fire department? That's morally questionable.
- jschwartzi 10y agoMoreover, given a choice, a lot of people wouldn't pay ahead of time for a private fire service, leading to the kind of bankruptcy situations the article is describing. Some localities solve this problem by levying a property tax and using it to maintain public emergency services, so that anyone who would benefit from their presence in a catastrophe has already paid for the service. This whole article just discusses the consequences of not wanting to pay taxes on anything. It perfectly described a libertarian paradise of private, for-hire, emergency services.
- pravda 10y agoWhether you pay it directly, or thru property tax, how is there a difference? The difference is, if the firemen are government employees, they can vote themselves rich. http://www.publicsectorinc.org/2014/06/firefighter-pay-shows-why-san-bernardino-is-bankrupt/ http://www.publicsectorinc.org/2014/06/firefighter-pay-shows...
- ubernostrum 10y agoMuch better for executives to vote themselves rich, like in a well-run privatized system, right?
- pravda 10y agoThat's the point. Private executives can't vote themselves rich. Well, they could, but how would they collect? Government employees can use violence to steal from you.
- ubernostrum 10y agoYou think executives of a private-sector corporation can't vote to give themselves high salaries or huge bonuses? Most of the time they don't even have to -- it's so ingrained in the culture now that it's just considered a cost of doing business to be robbed blind by the executive team. And if you think a private corporation can't deploy violence, you probably have never in your life read anything about why we had a rise of labor unions in this country; companies used to be able to call on not only the government's army but also their own private armies to put down, via deadly force, anyone perceived as a threat to the company's profits.
- pravda 10y ago>it's just considered a cost of doing business to be robbed blind by the executive team. Who are they robbing? Shareholders! But shareholders choose to be shareholders. You don't like what the executives are up to, you can sell your shares. > private armies to put down, via deadly force, anyone perceived as a threat to the company's profits. Ok, now you are being inconsistent. You think it's wrong for executives to be paid above-market wages, but you think it acceptable for employees to be paid above-market wages. Every dollar paid to an employee above market wage comes from shareholders! But none from taxpayers. All out of corporate profits.