3 ms·
There is a lot of soul-searching (and poll-searching) going on in the UK right now. And it's worth capturing some of the main points (some reflected in this ar
by lifeisstillgood 10y ago
There is a lot of soul-searching (and poll-searching) going on in the UK right now. And it's worth capturing some of the main points (some reflected in this article some not)
the vote is best seen as a protest vote driven by three emotional issues
1. Fear of immigration
2. Fear of economic dislocation
3. Frustration at being out of political decision making
Comments:
All of the above are common threads in right wing and centre right politics across the western world. From Trump to Greece there is a strong right wing, older, lower educated rump of around 15% who are the economic losers in the past couple of decades amazing debt field growth that has lifted hundreds of millions out of absolute poverty (a Good Thing)
But these three themes (the New Right) are not intellectually driven. They are weirdly fact free zones.
For example, the strongest Leave votes in the UK come from area with minimal immigration. Just as no Mexican ever stole a Pennsylvania Coal Miners job, Immigrants in the UK are not taking jobs from workers in Hull - because there are no bloody jobs in Hull.
2. Economic dislocation is a problem - London is a black hole pulling jobs, finance, young people, from everywhere else in the country to itself. House prices reflect this - houses can be bought for a few tens of thousands just a few hours drive from central Londons million pound pads.
Nothing about this makes sense - our economic future is a concern whatever we do with Europe, and it's just more dislocated in the UK.
The problem is fixing it. Our economy is mostly services now - finance being a ridiculous 10-15 % of GDP. And we are not competing when selling real goods with Germany or others.
Fixing that is a huge industrial policy issue and I don't see people taking it on.
As for the last - well An amazing BBC clip (TBC) shows a voter who voted to leave, seeming genuinely shocked at the result saying "but I thought my vote did not matter".
Turns out people feel disconnected from a political process that actually is working. When it is used. The problem is politicians and electoral rules clouding the direct levers.
So rant slowly ending - we have had a massive protest vote "against the establishment" - which is driven by fears that turn out not to be based on facts, that will result in election of a person who is just as establishment (Boris Johnson was in the same posh school / university class as Cameron. It's not a diversity win here)
My feeling is democracy has stopped being served by five yearly elections - that the real issues are much more local, and we need to find ways of forcing "evidence based politics" and more direct local action.
Sadly that can be the same sound bite as "take back our sovereignty"
- rm445 10y agoOne thing that is odd, is that as far as I can tell during the run-up to the referendum, no-one made the intellectual case for free movement of people to live and work throughout Europe. The 'Remain' camp made occasional and frankly incoherent statements about immigration while staying relentlessly on-message, sticking to the economy as the supposed winning hand. While of course the 'Leave' side played thoroughly on fear of immigration. Don't get me wrong, I'm sure it's economically efficient to have a borderless workforce, and there are also intellectual arguments about fairness. (I voted 'Remain', but that could be seen as self-interest for my own demographic). What isn't clear is why a lower-skilled worker already in a high-income country, who doesn't have any interest in moving abroad, wouldn't consider it in their own interest to pull the ladder up and restrict immigration.
- ProxCoques 10y agoI would not bet on Boris as PM. Most in his own party can't stand him, and grass roots Tories are at best luke warmabout. They will be very hesitant to choose yet another establishment figure now that they've seen what working class votes can do (even if they seemed to do the right thing this time).