4 ms·
http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/12/q-what-does-00-zero-raised-to-the-zeroth-power-equal-why-do-mathematicians-and-high-school-teachers-disagree/ http://ww
by dahart 10y ago
http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/12/q-what-does-00-zero-raised-to-the-zeroth-power-equal-why-do-mathematicians-and-high-school-teachers-disagree/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2010/12/q-what-does-00-zero...
It might be a mistake to try to argue that defining 0^0=1 is the best answer or the most consistent answer. The problem is that there are conflicts. There is no such thing as more consistent, if any rule breaks, they all break. Some math rules lead you to 0^0=0, some to 0^0=1, and some to 0^0=undefined. So math doesn't have an answer for this, and what really happens is we decide that 0^0=1 by convention. There are other examples of this happening in math, and it works reasonably well. But let's not pretend it's "right", let's accept that it's a choice.
We're choosing to say that the rule x^0=1 takes precedence over the rule 0 * x = 0.
Just to play devil's advocate, I like the choice of 0 for intuition consistency, not math consistency. The positive side limit is 0, so if 0^x is defined at x=0, how about we try to make the function more continuous, instead of trying to make it discontinuous?
0^0 is also saying 'start with zero, then multiply it by itself ... Wait, on second thought, don't start'
There's nothing, because you don't multiply zero by anything. The best number we have to represent nothing is zero. Saying that not raising zero to a power is one feels like a random number.
But, I'm wrong. ;)
- etatoby 10y ago> how about we try to make the function more continuous Look at the 3D rendering in my comment. When you look at the z=x^y surface and try to make it continuous, what comes out at 0^0 is a vertical line, aka. undefined.
- dahart 10y agoYou're absolutely right. And you're also wrong in the very the same way I'm wrong. ;) We decided that 0^0=1, and by 'we', I mean the mathematicians. It's easy to show why the choice 0^0=1 is a bad choice, because it breaks some rules. It's also easy to show (as the article's author did) why it's a good choice too. But, regardless, it's still the choice that has been made, and the choice can't be unmade. It's a beautiful example, btw, thank you for contributing the visualization!
- etatoby 10y agoI've updated my example with this frame: https://s31.postimg.org/4kozbjqbf/x_y_lines.png https://s31.postimg.org/4kozbjqbf/x_y_lines.png that highlights 0^y=0 in red and x^0=1 in purple. Now it's even more obvious why any single answer is insufficient: 0^0 is a vertical line, not a single point!
- dahart 10y agoHey, again, I totally agree with you. You are right, no single answer is sufficient. It was obvious before, and it's still obvious. The new lines show the specific conflict between 0^x and x^0, but there is no one answer. Your re-iterating your point makes me wonder if you're actually hearing and understanding the part about choices and definitions trumping logic. If we define 0^0=1, then it doesn't matter what arguments we have, it doesn't matter that there are 3 or more right answers. The right answer can be, and in other parts of math, is what we define it to be, not what makes the most sense. 0^0 is defined as 1 (sometimes) because that has utility and consistency for some other expressions, formulas, operations, etc. It's not because it's right. It's not because it makes sense. It's because we decide to set 0^0=1. It's for convenience. Now, some sources online say that 0^0 is indeterminate, not equal to one. Other sources online say that 0^0 is 1. http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Power.html http://mathworld.wolfram.com/Power.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indeterminate_form https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indeterminate_form https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~alopez-o/math-faq/mathtext/node14.html https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~alopez-o/math-faq/mathtext/node14.h... https://www.google.com/search?q=0%5E0 https://www.google.com/search?q=0%5E0 https://betterexplained.com/articles/understanding-exponents-why-does-00-1/ https://betterexplained.com/articles/understanding-exponents...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lanna 10y ago> 0^0 is also saying 'start with zero, then multiply it by itself ... Wait, on second thought, don't start' The same is true for any other integer: "2^0 is also saying 'start with two, then multiply it by itself ... Wait, on second thought, don't start'" You don't multiply two by anything.
- dahart 10y agoHehe, yep! x^0 isn't intuitive. Depending on how you think about it, anyway... some people feel like it is intuitive. http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/9703/how-do-i-explain-2-to-the-power-of-zero-equals-1-to-a-child http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/9703/how-do-i-explai... The thing is, there is no argument to be had, x^0 is defined to be 1, and x^1 is defined to be x. Those agree with and make consistent lots of other rules and limits, but they are choices we made just like saying 0^0=1.
- lanna 10y agox^0 is intuitive, pretty much so: x^0 = x^(y - y) = x^y * x^-y = x^y * 1/x^y = x^y / x^y = 1 x^0 isn't defined to be 1, x^0 IS 1. x^1 isn't defined to be x, x^1 IS x. The situation is analoguous to multiplication. a X b is defined as a+a+a+... b times. If you see a problem with x^0 and x^1, you should also see a problem with a X 0 and a X 1. x^0 is 1 because 1 is multiplication's identity element, just like a X 0 is zero because zero is addition identity element: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_element https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_element
- Double_Cast 10y agoOne problem with this is that x^y / x^y is restricted to the domain {x | x != 0}. Because e.g. when x = 0 and y = 1, the expression then contains a zero in the denominator. Division by zero is "every number, and therefore no single number" because we can use algebra to "prove" that x / 0 equals "anything we want", almost like the how the principle of explosion works. If you wanted to prove that 0^0 really does equal 1, you would have to prove that the output of the reduction is unique.
- 10y ago