3 ms·
Economic globalization, which has indeed brought good to the world overall, is not the same thing as political unification, which has not. We don't need to have
by pdonis 10y ago
Economic globalization, which has indeed brought good to the world overall, is not the same thing as political unification, which has not. We don't need to have everyone in the world belong to a single country in order to reap the benefits of globalized specialization and trade. Political unification just means that people have less and less voice in how they are governed. The EU's rules are written by unaccountable bureaucrats; I'm not at all surprised that Britain voted to exit from that.
- PeCaN 10y agoI agree. To pick a low-hanging fruit, the EU's internet legislation can only have come from bureaucrats completely detached from reality.
- ptaipale 10y agoWhich legislation do you mean? (Genuine question. I can see some examples, such as the completely idiotic requirement that forces web sites to have those exceedingly irritating pop-ups for consent to have cookies. Whoever wrote that law clearly didn't understand how web sites work, socially.)
- PeCaN 10y agoCookie law, “right to be forgotten”, hate speech laws, etc.
- arrrg 10y agoWhich rules are you talking about? In terms of being a political union, the EU doesn’t even do that much. It does do some things, but those things tend to be overall small and also relatively uncontroversial. The bulk of the work the EU does in “creating” rules in unifying regulations. For the common market to exist (i.e. to drive economic unification) you need unified regulation. Otherwise trade barriers would exist. That means you have to write lots and lots of deadly boring regulation. And that’s what the EU did. Yawn. All a very technocratic process. (I’m also not sure why you think people in Brussels are unaccountable. That’s such a cliché propaganda line with no basis in reality at all.)
- pdonis 10y ago> Which rules are you talking about? http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/ALL/?uri=OJ%3AC%3A2004%3A310%3ATOC http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/ALL/?uri=OJ%3AC%3A... http://europa.eu/eu-law/index_en.htm http://europa.eu/eu-law/index_en.htm The Constitution for Europe alone is more than 400 pages. For comparison, the US Constitution is about 10. (Unfortunately the US legal code is probably as lengthy and baroque as the EU's by this point.) > For the common market to exist (i.e. to drive economic unification) you need unified regulation. No, you don't. Global markets existed before the EU and didn't need "unified regulation" (meaning regulation by politicians and bureaucrats, as opposed to regulation by the ordinary process of voluntary trade) in order to work. This idea that the only way to have common markets is by lengthy, boring political regulation is precisely the misconception I am arguing against.
- arrrg 10y agoWhen country a calls for diameter x and country b for a different diameter y then you cannot sell your thing in both countries. The EU would then come and say that the actual rule is diameter z, problem solved. Your view on this is hopelessly naive and really anti-intellectual and dishonest.
- pdonis 10y ago> When country a calls for diameter x and country b for a different diameter y then you cannot sell your thing in both countries. You're still assuming that countries have to set standards. Many standards are not set by countries at all; they are set by markets, by buyers and sellers realizing that a common standard is in both their interests and agreeing on one. (You are also assuming that it is always a good thing for the same product to be sold in both countries--that there can't possibly be good reasons why two different diameters might be used in different places. If standards are left to markets--i.e., to the people who are actually directly affected by what is bought and sold--then those kinds of issues take care of themselves.) Your view on this is hopelessly blinded by your assumptions.
- 10y ago
- bgilroy26 10y agoThis is nonsense. There are many, many regulations are driven by trade. There is no effective way to perfectly separate the economic from the political. People need to get a long and agree on many matters in order to trade. Getting people in line is politics, trade is economics, but they are two sides of the same process.
- pdonis 10y ago> People need to get a long and agree on many matters in order to trade. No, they don't. They only need to agree on what is being traded and at what price.