3 ms·
Explain to me why London's clearly expressed democratic desire to stay is less valid than the overall nation's vote to leave (especially when the margin in Lond
by Analemma_ 10y ago
Explain to me why London's clearly expressed democratic desire to stay is less valid than the overall nation's vote to leave (especially when the margin in London was much larger than for the nation overall). This is the problem with direct referendums, and why this Brexit vote should never have happened: as soon as you say that "we need direct democracy so the people can have a voice", smaller geographic areas which hold the opposite view have equally valid claims.
(EDIT: a lot of my replies seem to be missing the point. I mean why is London's desire less valid philosophically, not legally. Obviously London could not legally depart without a vote in Parliament, but if Londoners clearly express their desire to leave the UK and the UK doesn't let them, well, that seems awfully antithetical to the direct democracy that the Brexiters say they want)
- mac01021 10y agoI'm not sure this has any impact on the validity of the desire, but it sounds like a border-control nightmare.
- robotresearcher 10y agoBecause London isn't a sovereign nation.
- lmm 10y agoNor is Scotland or Northern Ireland, but they're talking about independence.
- robotresearcher 10y agoThese are completely different cases. Scotland has been its own traditional country for a very long time, and the union with England was formed when the King of Scotland became also King of England and not the other way around. Northern Ireland is the vestige of a brutal occupation of Ireland by England. The Catholic population traditionally loyal to Ireland now outnumbers the UK-supporting Protestants. London has never been a country. This is obviously a protest demonstration and not a serious proposition.
- deadfish 10y agoNot strictly true. The 'City of London' (not to be confused with London) is and has always been its own country. Whilst the argument is for all of London to be independent. It would surely be possible for the 'City of London' to remain in the EU. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/City_of_London
- robotresearcher 10y agoThe City of London, as shown in that link, is a city and COUNTY in England, and not a country. That 'r' makes a difference.
- Anderkent 10y agoThus the sentiment of seceding; if the desires of people in London are so different to rural UK, why force them to follow the same policy? Obviously this isn't going to happen, there's no reasonable mechanism by which London could gain independence. But if there was, I'm pretty sure London would go for it
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Because London isn't a sovereign nation. What is or is not a sovereign nation is not an immutable fact of nature, and the Brexit vote may change that. Though Scotland is more likely than London to get away.
- sp332 10y agoBecause they're just one voting area among many. It's not as if laws and services only apply to the individuals who vote for them.
- TallGuyShort 10y agoIs the UK just one area in the EU? Their decision affected the US economy. Should the US get to vote about whether they stay? That's GP's point.
- sp332 10y agoJust because the vote was counted at the level of voting districts doesn't mean those districts are having different referendums. It was a single referendum across the whole country.
- spriggan3 10y ago> Explain to me why London's clearly expressed democratic desire to stay is less valid than the overall nation's vote to leave Since when London is a sovereign country ?
- lmm 10y agoWell that's exactly what the petition is about changing.
- clentaminator 10y agoLondon's desire to stay is not less valid than the overall nation's, but neither is it more valid, which is roughly the sentiment expressed by this petition. It comes across as a sense of misplaced entitlement for someone to believe that because they live in a specific region of the UK that their vote is somehow more valid. Some of the comments in the petition page (https://www.change.org/p/sadiq-khan-declare-london-independent-from-the-uk-and-apply-to-join-the-eu https://www.change.org/p/sadiq-khan-declare-london-independe...) are interesting: "Even though the Houses of Parliament are situated in London, Londoners are only able to elect around 11% of MPs in the commons; Londoners have no say in how the vast majority of MPs are elected, yet they are still subject to their laws." Yes, as they are subject to the laws of the entire country. The location of the Houses of Parliament has nothing at all to do with this. Plus, are we talking about the City of London or Greater London? The "11%" number essentially comes down to area boundaries and what is and isn't considered "London". "London has no control over its borders while it remains a member of the UK." What borders? London is a single city in a country. By definition the type of borders they are referring to don't exist, as it's not a country boundary.
- Analemma_ 10y agoI think you're missing the sarcasm in those comments. Just like this petition as a whole, they are deliberate ironic echoes of the Leave camp's claims in order to raise the question of "Why is your vote valid but not ours"