8 ms·
Here's a Leave fellow who says he just did it as a protest vote thinking it wouldn't actually pass. https://twitter.com/AdamWSweeney/status/746269140915208193 h
by Analemma_ 10y ago
Here's a Leave fellow who says he just did it as a protest vote thinking it wouldn't actually pass. https://twitter.com/AdamWSweeney/status/746269140915208193 https://twitter.com/AdamWSweeney/status/746269140915208193 I don't know whether to laugh or cry. The most important international agreement in the UK's history torn up because people thought this was a Buzzfeed poll.
- mikeash 10y agoThat reminds me of certain American voters saying they support Trump just because they want to tear the system down. I don't think they realize what tearing the system down would actually mean.
- avs733 10y agoI can say with confidence that it might mean the government stays out of their medicare /s
- fomojola 10y agoNot sure if you're being facetious, but Medicare IS the government, you do realize this? Medicare isn't some magical, mythical creature that existed from the dawn of time and has always been there: it is explicitly a creation of the government (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medicare_(United_States))
- mikeash 10y agoThey're mocking people who protested with signs like "Keep government out of my medicare!" during the debate over Obamacare.
- avs733 10y agonote the /s
- mikestew 10y agoNot sure if you're being facetious, but Medicare IS the government And parent even used the sarcasm tag. :-) Parent doesn't need it explained, but some American citizens apparently do: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/prescriptions/2009/08/the_medicareisntgovernment_meme.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/prescription...
- ars 10y agoI get the joke, but after having dealt with them, I would personally love it if the government got out of medicare. Just give everyone a voucher and let them buy their own health insurance using it. The amount of paperwork, and details to keep track of and calculate was absolutely unreal. I have BOXES full of paper from medicare, there was so much I could barely keep up. The worst was the arcane and utterly confusing rules on eligibility: if this, or if that, or you live here, or there, for these dates, and that deadline. I felt like I needed an AI just to figure it all out (and in hindsight my understanding was completely wrong, and I chose the wrong option).
- brewdad 10y agoSounds a lot like private insurance. Handing out "free" money has worked so well for higher education. How will vouchers solve the problem of skyrocketing health care costs?
- njloof 10y agoBy contrast, the paperwork I do (as a client) under Canadian single payer Medicare is nil, and my supplementary insurance (vision/dental) can be filled out online in minutes. Sounds like you need a better system in the US. Maybe not so many different stakeholders in the system?
- ars 10y agoThat's how it works for commercial plans. Very easy, simple paperwork. They have to compete with each other, if they were confusing no one would sign up. > Sounds like you need a better system in the US. It does work for most people, it's the edge cases that fail. > Maybe not so many different stakeholders in the system? Making medicare normal would require much higher taxes (medicare/medicaid hospital payments are below costs and are subsidized by commercial plans). People would then save money on commercial plans. Net dollars would not change, or maybe go down, but the distribution would change, some winners, some losers.
- stephenr 10y agoAmericans always seem to just assume that because their unique way of doing <thing> doesn't work, <thing> is unworkable and should be abandoned, usually in a "let the corporations fix it" kind of way. - Banking regulations - government backed healthcare - gun control - education system
- lgas 10y agoActually as long as you include that "it might" part in there, you can say anything with confidence.
- rayiner 10y agoWhat would it mean?
- eumoria 10y ago...joining the EU?
- mikeash 10y agoDeath, destruction, anarchy, civil war. Not that I think Trump will bring that. The office of President is not that important. But I'm talking about what a certain set of voters says they want, not what will actually happen if they vote that way.
- raisedbyninjas 10y agoAfter dismantling the last superpower, a whole spectrum of things could happen. The assumption is that whatever rises from the ashes just by chance is better than the system that has been refined and mostly thrived for two centuries. Of course there is no assurance that we won't be left with a mix of anarchy and warlords.
- LanceH 10y agoYea, only the other side has idiots voting for them.
- mikeash 10y agoNever said it was only that side. I consider myself an independent and while I view the Democrats more favorably, I'm not positively inclined towards either party nor either voter base. Don't read things that aren't there.
- burkaman 10y ago"Certain american voters", not the whole "other side". I'm sure most Trump voters actually want him to be president, but I've heard a few people say "oh I'm sure he'll get impeached within a year or two, I just want to shake up the establishment".
- mikeash 10y agoI originally posted the comment without "certain" and then immediately went back and added it, because I was afraid someone would think I was referring to all Trump supporters without it. Apparently it didn't work anyway.
- LanceH 10y agoI didn't think you or anyone else thinks it's all. But so much of news coverage (and forum arguments) are about the fringe elements which are basically nothing more than strawmen. Saying that there are some people ignorant of what they are voting for is not news. Stating that one side has ignorant voters carries implications that the other side is correct and right thinking.
- mikeash 10y agoThis whole story is about people who are ignorant of what they are voting for. "Stating that one side has ignorant voters carries implications that the other side is correct and right thinking." No it doesn't. Why would you say that? I can't even.
- maxaf 10y agoThere's no harm in tearing down something that doesn't benefit the majority of voters in this country. I say let 'er burn.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 10y agoYes, perfect illustration of my point. The government benefits the people enormously. Yes, it has a lot of problems, but we're way better off with it than without it. I can totally understand a desire for reform, but simply tearing it down is insane.
- jazzyk 10y agoThe only way to force the government to reform is to vote out the party that screwed up. Unfortunately, in the US, both parties colluded to work for their corporate sponsors, not the people who vote for them, so they both need to be disrupted somehow. Most voters understand it, and that explains the anti-establishment voting in this election (Sanders/Trump)
- mikeash 10y agoThere's a big difference between "reform" and "tear down." I'm specifically referring to people who say they want the second. I can understand, if not agree with, people who want to elect Trump so he can reform the system. I think people who want to elect Trump to tear the system down don't understand what that means.
- jeli 10y agoAhh yes, there's no benefit to being under the American government; we might as well all pack up and move to North Korea, because any change is good change!
- tamana 10y agoEven though one of Trump's most legitimate points in favor was that he mocks how the USG tore down the system in Iraq and Syria, distorting the country.
- chongli 10y agoWhen you're in an abusive relationship it's always harder to pack up and leave than it is to stay. You've gotta do it though, because the long term consequences of living with your abuser are unacceptable.
- simplyluke 10y agoOf course, we're talking about one of the largest/most functional nations in the history of the world not domestic abuse.
- cool_penguins 10y agoMost people in the US don't know how good they have it and what it means to be under a true abusive and police state.
- mikeash 10y agoI think a big chunk of Americans almost want it to be a police state, so they have something to fight against. It makes me think of Sam Altman's recent article about Trump. He said he was taking some risk by writing that, and some commenters here praised his bravery in taking a public stand on this. It's ridiculous. Bravery would be a prominent techie taking a stand for Trump. He's not going to suffer any consequences for publishing that. Nobody's going to knock on his door and haul him off at 3AM, or deny him entrance into any organizations, or even shoot him dirty looks on the street.
- meric 10y agoI got some really bad looks in my office building when some people overheard me telling a colleague I rather Clinton lose than Trump lose, due to her preference for fighting wars. One person looked at me like if they could kill me, he would, like I was some enemy. A lot of anti-Trump people accuse Trump supporters of bigotry and exclusion, but I think that's projection on their part. No, I don't feel comfortable writing this comment. For the record, I don't like Clinton or Trump. But it's better for the rest of the world for Clinton to lose.
- saynsedit 10y agoDo you know anyone personally who has said this?
- 4ad 10y agoI'm not the OP, but I know a few such people.
- mikeash 10y agoI don't even know anyone personally who has expressed any favorable view of Trump. Yet clearly they exist in fairly large numbers, so I don't think that should prevent me from acknowledging them.
- saynsedit 10y agoThe support of Trump has data behind it. Second-hand anecdotes of people claiming they'll vote for Trump just to see the system come down is not data. Without data, it may be such a minority of people that it's not worth significant consideration in a discussion. I'm apt to believe it's an extreme minority given it's an extreme view.
- mikeash 10y agoMaybe so, and maybe people who voted in the EU referendum without understanding the EU are likewise an extreme minority. If you want to stick with easily quantifiable facts then I don't think this is the right discussion for you.
- saynsedit 10y agoFalse equivalence, I wouldn't call uninformed voting (as they are painting it) extreme. I would call malicious voting extreme though. In any case you're probably right. Most people who voted to exit the EU probably weren't uninformed. Google data only represents correlation. General buzz about brexit is a more likely explanation for the search trends. Occam's razor dominates.
- _9MOTHER9HORSE 10y agoOn the contrary, the fact the EU had enormous power over British people, yet barely anyone knew what it was, what it did, or why it was important, was a compelling reason for the UK to leave.
- a-priori 10y agoOr, perhaps, it's a compelling reason why things like this shouldn't be decided by referendum.
- TearsInTheRain 10y agohow should they be decided then?
- a-priori 10y agoWe elect politicians whose full-time jobs it is to understand big and complicated issues, and to decide on our behalf how to deal with them. That includes the right to make and break treaties with other world powers. Why should something like this be any different?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> We elect politicians whose full-time jobs it is to understand big and complicated issues, and to decide on our behalf how to deal with them. But, on Brexit specifically, the British people elected a government that made a campaign promise to hold exactly such a referendum, and to abide by its results.
- makomk 10y agoOne very plausible theory I've seen doing the rounds is that the government never actually expected to have to follow through on that campaign promise. Strategically speaking it was a terrible idea and Cameron was always pretty pro-EU, but he needed the support of the anti-EU faction of his party, so he promised the vote as a sop to them. The theory goes that he didn't expect to get an absolute majority in Parliament and hoped the other parties would "force" him to to not follow through.
- _nalply 10y agoWelcome to direct democracy. The Swiss also had protest votes which actually passed.
- tamana 10y agoA non binding referendum is not direct democracy.
- _nalply 10y agoRight. Formally you are correct. However effectively the Brexit vote is an expression of sovereignty of the populace. It's about power. Why? Because some parliament members are afraid to oppose the outcome. Of course some things are different from the Swiss direct democracy. First the votes aren't ordained by politicians as a gamble but are set in motion by predefined rules in constitution and law. Second, the federal minister (Bundesrat) who has «lost» a vote doesn't retire like Mr. Cameron. Quite the opposite: everybody expects that he obeys the people and takes over to try to find the best way. Like a child who has to obey its parents and can't retire if he disagrees.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pricechild 10y agoI don't think your description is accurate. He says "I'm a bit shocked to be honest.. <Presenter: What about?> I'm shocked about both... I'm shocked that we have actually voted to leave. I didn't think that was going to happen. My vote, I didn't think was going to matter too much because I just thought we were going to remain." Maybe this short clip is missing context... maybe he says later on in the conversation that it was a protest vote... but all this clip shows is that he's surprised they won? It's common to vote for something you believe in, knowing the opposition will win anyway. That doesn't imply it's a protest vote, that you don't really want what you're voting for.
- Dr_tldr 10y agoIt might worth remembering that anecdote !== data. Drawing conclusions about the motivations of a larger group from one member of that group is logically indistinguishable from all the discriminatory -isms.
- nzp 10y agoSo you're characterizing everyone who voted to leave based on a distorted statement of one person the BBC pulled out. He in fact did not say that, quoted no less, sentence at all! Find the clip, the full clip, and watch it. He said he was shocked that they won, AND didn't expect Cameron to resign, and so is worried about that. It's quite understandable to be worried about big changes regardless of wanting them or not. He has neither said it was a protest vote or anything like that, nor that he regrets it.
- delboy88 10y ago>Here's a Leave fellow who says he just did it as a protest vote thinking it wouldn't actually pass. So? >The most important international agreement in the UK's history torn up The Act of Union 1707 was torn up because of this? >because people thought this was a Buzzfeed poll. It's really pathetic that sore losers like yourself are making nonsense claims like this.