3 ms·

The US is not the world though.

• gcatalfamo 10y ago
  Thank you. US people just don't get it.
• hnal943 10y ago
  Yes, but the original claim was that the French Revolution codified the idea of the separation of powers, which is clearly false. The evidence of that is that America already existed with this structure and was obviously known to the west.
  • david927 10y ago
    Democracy was also known in Greece a couple thousands of years prior. As others have stated, the ideas were the ideas of the enlightenment and while America was a wonderful project, it wasn't the real example to show that these ideas could work -- the French Revolution did that.
    • gkya 10y ago
      The ideas worked only about 10 years though, until Napoleon.
      • david927 10y ago
        Not at all. Napoleon was definitely seen as a force in that direction and that was a large part of his appeal to the masses.
        • gkya 10y ago
          Some interesting fact-bending here.
          • umanwizard 10y ago
            He's right. In a dichotomy of revolutionaries vs. monarchists, Napoleon is definitely seen as the former. It's not really as simple as democracy vs. lack thereof. Many of the most radical revolutionaries were extremely undemocratic. At times during the Revolutinary period even suggesting democratic measures (like implementing the Constitution) could get you killed.
    • tnecniv 10y ago
      Except it didn't work. After overthrowing the monarchy, France went through a number of highly unstable governments until Napoleon ascended to the throne in 1805. That period was called the Reign of Terror for a reason. If you were suspected of being a counter-revolutionary, you could be executed without trial. After Napoleon's defeat at Waterloo, the French monarchy was restored. When the Second Republic was established after the revolution of 1848, Napoleon III quickly abused his uncle's popularity to establish another dictatorship within five years. This lasted until 1870.