3 ms·
Grades are both a poor pedagogical tool and a poor measuring stick. They’re too coarse, too removed from the immediate learning feedback loop, too inconsistent
by jacobolus 10y ago
Grades are both a poor pedagogical tool and a poor measuring stick. They’re too coarse, too removed from the immediate learning feedback loop, too inconsistent from course to course, and too ambiguous in meaning (should you get the best grade for working hardest? for understanding the material best? for the best writing or mathematical reasoning skills?). At best, they provide a tremendous distraction for everyone; at worst, they convince some students who are performing well they can slack off, make students at the bottom give up hope and stop trying, cause incredible anxiety for students in the middle, and also create huge headaches and heartbreaks for instructors. Simultaneously, they give parents the misleading impression they know what is happening at school, and thereby discourage parents from getting more directly involved in their children’s education.
The main reason grades were adopted and persist is that they’re relatively easy to apply, aren’t that complicated to reason about heuristically (even if this is often misleading), and they scale across an institution / between institutions.
In my opinion, grades should be entirely abolished for students up through middle school, and replaced with written reports from the instructor. They aren’t really appropriate later, either, but high school grades seem to be one of the only available tools for guiding the college admissions process and I don’t presently have any better equally scalable idea. Colleges should of course do whatever they want, after all, the students are adults at that point.
Then again, I feel rather the same way about institutional schooling in general.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoI went through my higher education basically without grades. Almost all courses were project based, which were done in teams. If the team decided you were a non-perfomer, there would be a discussion with a teacher. This freed up a lot of time for the teachers, so general knowledge was tested by teachers in personal meetings, where you had to explain to him/her what you had learned. If your explanation wasn't good enough, the teacher would explain things again so you would understand. So it's not just a test, but a more personal way for a teacher to feel if you really understood the subject. A system like this only works when everyone loves what he or she is learning. 40% of the students didn't finish the first year. After the first year almost everyone made it.
- rimantas 10y ago> which were done in teams This is fucked up and sucks for introverts. And double sucks for them if they love that they are learning.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoOnly if you think you should leave introverted people alone in the corner of the classroom, forever. Working in teams forces introverted people to learn ways to cope with their natural attitude and it learns the other team members how to deal with their introverted counterparts. If you want your team to deliver the best products you better learn about eachothers strengths and weaknesses. In the first year you learn a lot about team dynamics.
- no_flags 10y agoI actually like the concept of group based work much more in a grade-less environment. When grades are involved it over-burdens the good students because they have to pick up the slack for students who don't care, or risk getting a lower grade.
- simonh 10y ago> and replaced with written reports from the instructor. I find it hard to believe that American middle schools don't produce written reports on their pupils. In the UK we have a system of graded exams at the end of middle school (age 16), but the old 'A' level system used to guide university admissions is losing ground to the International Baccalaureate (IB) qualification. The school my children attend is switching over entirely to IB for high school students from this year. I like it. The IB is a much broader qualification that A levels and includes project assessments and an extended essay as well as examinations. It is of course graded, but looks like it provides a much more complete assessment of a pupil's abilities than e.g. a B+ in Maths. I'm a fan.