7 ms·
> The scaremongering goes on even after the vote has been called... The terms are simple: You can't have free movement of goods without the equally free moveme
by paganel 10y ago
> The scaremongering goes on even after the vote has been called...
The terms are simple: You can't have free movement of goods without the equally free movement of people. As long as people in the UK are ok with the free movement of people (even though the fight against it was a big part of the "Leave" campaign) then I would see no reason why us, the rest of the EU people, should impede the UK products' access to the European market. You can't have your lunch and eat it too, meaning you can't be against free movement of people (against "immigration") and then expect us to accept your economic products. It's not "scaremongering", this are the true, hard facts.
- sverige 10y agoBut most of the immigrants are coming from outside the EU. There's the rub.
- evgen 10y agoFrom what I recall of the most recent stats, which were unfortunately released just a short while ago and may have pushed some votes to Leave, there has been more net migration into the UK over the past few years from EU nationals than from those coming from outside the EU.
- dharma1 10y agoRoughly just over a half is immigration from within the EU
- throwaway049 10y ago'Most' but not by much margin. Which means, if you are looking to curb immigration, that there are two parallel but independent issues to resolve. The UK has in recent years tightened restrictions on many visas for non-EU nationals including those for foreign spouses (minimum income rules, capacity to speak english), post-study work and shortage occupation work (many occupations taken off the list as they were being filled by EU nationals).
- zghst 10y agoChina ships tons of products to the US, however the freedom of movement between the two nations are comparatively low compared to the EU.
- ptaipale 10y agoAnd on the other hand countries outside the EU but inside the EEA still have very low barriers to trade - Norway, Switzerland or Iceland are not exactly going down the drain. The rest of Europe still buys crude oil, high-tech cuckoo clocks and fish fingers.
- paganel 10y agoDon't know about Iceland, but Norway and Switzerland have had to actually adopt the EU norms without having any say in how those norms get adopted or decided. That's the reason they didn't go "down the drain", I think you forgot to mention that.
- ptaipale 10y agoTrade norms are not a bad thing, even if some in Britain wanted to continue to sell bananas by the lb. Most everyone is happy with having trade norms, and in particular, having the same norms everywhere (not just in EU but world-wide, starting with things like the metric system). Unfortunately, even within EU the influence of small countries on trade norms is rather negligible. We also get lost of proposals for regulation of things we don't want and could avoid outside the EU. Note that I'm actually for the continued EU membership of my country. I just find it abysmal that the pro-EU camp is often in denial about things and too enthusiastic for deeper integration towards USE.
- bayesian_horse 10y agoOh, there are barriers to trade with Norway and Switzerland. I faintly remember a butter shortage in Norway because they are trying to protect their extremely uncompetitive dairy industry.
- 99_00 10y ago>You can't have free movement of goods without the equally free movement of people. Why not? Other countries have free trade without the free movement of people.
- nicky0 10y agoI think they are confusing free trade with the single market. Free movement is a condition of membership of the single market. Single market means not just lack of tariffs but also harmonisation of regulations.
- oldmanjay 10y agoI feel like you have to be a lot more explicit about the connection between your statements. You word things as though one implies the other but they seem independent to my eye, and the independence belies your point
- ptaipale 10y ago>The terms are simple: You can't have free movement of goods without the equally free movement of people. Why not? No movement is absolutely "free" of course, but we get lots of goods from (e.g.) China, while it is not that easy to immigrate into China. There are many big trading nations that are not at all that free about moving into them (for instance, Singapore). The people in UK seems to think that their island is rather full. Those of us in the remaining EU need to reassess the idea to push deeper and deeper political integration towards a federal wannabe-superpower.
- paganel 10y ago> while it is not that easy to immigrate into China. Care to mention why? In my quite limited circle of acquaintances I have 3 people who now work in China, and they seem to have had no problems with getting work permits in there. One of them is even a guy in his late 20s who's now working with kids under 7, which would have been an issue in other, more "liberal" countries, but I digress. I'm from Eastern Europe, if it matters. > Why not? Because if you make superior products to out internal, home-made ones, and then flood our market with those products then that means our domestic producers go out of business and we lose our jobs (while we happily buy your better products). We want to have the chance to share in your country's superior economic power (which, let's not forget, also depends on our cash, it depends in our buying your products) by working for your country's companies, if need be in your country. It's as simple as that, any other outcome is economic colonialism.
- ptaipale 10y ago>I have 3 people who now work in China, and they seem to have had no problems with getting work permits in there. I have myself worked in China thus I know the process (well, the process 16 years ago). Yes, it is easy for a professional who goes there to be a well-paid expat. Income differences are huge in China. But the forms really look like the Chinese are concerned about immigration of people who come there to exploit the welfare state (even if it is actually rather non-existent).
- 10y ago
- vsl 10y agoErr, there isn't free movement between UK and the Schengen area. Yet it apparently doesn't impede trade.
- 314 10y agoYes there is - it does not mean that you can on holiday without a passport. It means that you had the right to live and work there.
- bkor 10y agoYou're shifting goal posts. The statement was free movement of people. You cannot freely move to UK, it is outside of Schengen. Stating that free movement is not free movement is illogical.
- paganel 10y agoAs the original poster, my intention was to talk about the free movement of people which implied the freedom of employment. Sorry for the misunderstanding, as I'm not a native English speaker.
- bkor 10y agoMe neither (Dutch), I do not think it makes sense to apologize for not being native speaker. You meant something else, ok, let's move on. You only meant freedom of employment? I'm annoyed that UK asks questions while in loads of non-EU countries you just wave an EU passport and it is like an open border (no questions, nothing).
- memsom 10y ago"...without a passport". There, I fixed it for you. You don't need a VISA, you don't need a permit. I know plenty of Europeans that moved from the UK to mainland Europe and vice versa. (That's right - we are all Europeans...)
- mcv 10y ago