3 ms·
"Biases" are a species of uninformed preference. It is really unlikely that satisfying your biases is going to lead to better decision-making. This goes for jus
by Zigurd 10y ago
"Biases" are a species of uninformed preference. It is really unlikely that satisfying your biases is going to lead to better decision-making. This goes for just about any mismeasure and folk wisdom, as Google has found out.
Multiple dimension of Google's hiring process have been revised as they found they were getting sub-optimal results from the usual kind of "hiring people like me" approach.
For example, it used to be a good bet that men made better orchestra musicians. Until they made auditioners take off their shoes and play behind a screen. You can't detect that bias without trying very hard to wash it out. If men were substantially ALL of the successful orchestral musicians, it would of course look like a completely justified "bias."
- yummyfajitas 10y agoFirst of all, base rates matter. Here's a simplified proof: Suppose you want to know if X is true. You have evidence E which is correlated with X - suppose A = P(E|X) > 0.5 and B = P(!E|!X) > 0.5. Bayes rule shows: P(X|E) = P(E|X) P(X) / P(E) = P(E|X)P(X) / (P(X)A + (1-B)P(!X)) = P(X)A / (P(X)(A+1-B) + 1-B) Differentiating this w.r.t. P(X) shows that it monotonically increases with P(X). QED. Now I'm not disputing - at all - that human biases exist. Far from it! What I'm asking is whether the behaviors discovered in this article are biases (errors that result in worse decisions) or merely accurate use of priors (using correct base rate knowledge to make better decisions). In the case of orchestras the answer is pretty clearly yes. Similarly in the case of baseball. In college admissions and lending the answer is likely to be no [1]. This article completely ignores the question! [1] https://randomcriticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2015/05/16/on-concentrated-poverty-and-its-effects-on-academic-outcomes/ https://randomcriticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2015/05/16/on-c... http://ftp.iza.org/dp8733.pdf http://ftp.iza.org/dp8733.pdf https://randomcriticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2015/11/22/on-the-relationship-between-negative-home-owner-equity-and-racial-demographics/#my_analysis https://randomcriticalanalysis.wordpress.com/2015/11/22/on-t...
- ubernostrum 10y ago1. Argue that yummyfajitas is known to often be wrong, and in fact terribly wrong, thus justifying bias against acceptance of any views advanced by yummyfajitas. 2. Spread this now rationally-supported (on base rate grounds) bias among many people. 3. Find some time later that yummyfajitas' views are overwhelmingly rejected by persons reached in step 2. 4. Declare bias established in step 1 to be retroactively objectively correct after observing how yummyfajitas' posts fare with observers, and note that even yummyfajitas will not be able to argue with it, as the correctness will be demonstrated by yummyfajitas' own argument in comment above.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoThe chain of reasoning you advocate for is circular - the validity of step 1 is dependent on the conclusion in step 4, but step 4 depends on step 1. The same is not true of the chain of reasoning I suggested.
- rhizome 10y agoIt's amusing to read this thread right next to the "The Artist Leaving the Googleplex" one.