3 ms·
You say IRR is the rate, but not every project has a unique IRR, e.g. if there are negative cash flow periods interspersed with positive cash flow periods. You
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
You say IRR is the rate, but not every project has a unique IRR, e.g. if there are negative cash flow periods interspersed with positive cash flow periods.
Your assertion about NPV being useful when you have a budget confused me. If you have no budget then NPV is useful. You just do every possible NPV-positive project.
If you do have a budget, as in your example, you could not pick between those two projects without considering some missing information (the length of time). You can't just pick the highest IRR project, or the largest project. The NPV of your larger project with a slightly lower yield could be lower than that of the smaller, higher yielding project. Consider if the larger one had a length of 1 month, and couldn't be repeated, whereas the smaller one would take 5 years. Or you could flip it around. The information you gave is not enough to choose, regardless of whether or not you're budget-constrained.