4 ms·
Paypal follows the sane system of having the payer tell them who and how much to pay, instead of CC's process where the seller tells them "it's cool, the buyer
by icebraining 10y ago
Paypal follows the sane system of having the payer tell them who and how much to pay, instead of CC's process where the seller tells them "it's cool, the buyer totally wanted me to have $X" and the payment processor simply complies.
/rant
(Yes, 3-D secure exists, but as a user it's impossible to verify that the site is actually using it before handing over the CC info)
- makomk 10y agoWell, Paypal gives the impression to buyers that they're the ones telling Paypal how much to pay anyway. If I recall correctly the amount displayed on the Paypal payment page is for information only and the API leaves it up to the seller how much to actually charge, and in some cases this may change (for example, because the site can't calculate shipping fees until Paypal gives them the buyer's address).
- JoshTriplett 10y agoAgreed; this and actual cryptographic signatures should be a requirement to process any payment. I'd like that for a bill pay system, too. Right now, I have to choose between systems with direct bank account access that can debit any amount, or systems that require manual entry of amounts. I'd like to see a standard where the source of a bill sends an invoice to my bank, and I then direct the bank to pay it (either via direct authorization, or by setting parameters like "automatically pay if less than $X").
- icebraining 10y agoWhat pains me is that the committee that created the new SEPA Direct Debit standard had the choice (the two processes were used in different EU countries) and they chose the dumb one! We actually had a sane direct debit system here in Portugal, in which the invoice would come with a code that you could input into your bank's site or ATM, therefore authorizing future debits from that company. It was safe, it could be easily revoked, and we lost it to implement SEPA's crappy version.
- ryan-c 10y ago3-D secure trains people to be phished.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoAnd it shifts liability to the customer: given a "3-D Secure" authorization, the credit card company presumes an authorized transaction and makes it much harder to claim fraud.