5 ms·
A Dagger to the CIA
- hga 17y agoI haven't more than skimmed the first and last page, but if you want to really understand this issue you have to go back at least to the '70s, particularly: The Church Commission. The purge of James Jesus Angleton, and more importantly the effective end of the agency's counterintelligence function, which is very much a part of this particular screwup; it's never a popular thing, no one likes being told their informant is a double, but ignoring the possibility is lethally expensive. (See also Aldrich Ames, who's lifestyle should have been caught by counterintelligence as another example of a failure in this area.) Jimmy Carter's DCI, Stansfield Turner, and e.g. how he riffed 800+ HUMINT operators in just one purge.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThe more I learn about the history of intelligence services post WWII in America, the more as a taxpayer it ticks me off. Not the agency trying to do loopy things like poison Castro's underwear, but the wholesale ripping apart of decades of work just because the politics change one way or another. Want to fund overthrows? I don't like it, but fine, if it's done according to process. Want to abolish funding overthrows? Fine, if it's done according to process. But tearing down entire structures? Effectively destroying all HUMINT in the 1970s? It's insanity. Completely crazy. The intelligence agencies never managed to stay above politics, which is a shame.
- smallblacksun 17y agoThe problem is not that the intelligence agencies can't stay above politics, but that the politicians meddle with the intelligence agencies for political reasons. Despite what some conspiracy theorists believe, the US intelligence agencies are run by the elected officials, not the other way around. This is good for a lot of reasons, but does leave them subject to the whims of politicians.
- barrkel 17y agoAn intelligence agency not run by politicians, on the other hand, would be an enemy to be feared.
- hga 17y agoYes to what both of you are saying. But it's not quite just "politics", I would say. Perhaps look at this as an evolution of the post-WWI principle that "Gentlemen don't read each other's mail"? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Strategic_Services#Origins_and_activities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Strategic_Services#Or...) (Me, after the WSJ recommended it I just got a copy of The Deceivers by Thaddeus Holt, 1148 pages (!!!) on "Allied Military Deception in the Second World War". Very interesting.)
- Luc 17y agoThanks for the recommendation, that book sounds great. I've ordered it, at a price of less than one pence per page!
- dkimball 17y agoI think there's another problem. Arab intelligence services tend to be brutal, so I'm not surprised that _they_ thought that their course of action was a good idea, but was "let's torture this Islamic-fundamentalist blogger into infiltrating al-Qaida for us" really a course of action that raised _no_ moral or common-sense alarm bells at the CIA? And where do I go to get my money back? I would rather be killed by a suicide bomber than defended by torturers. (I say this as a conservative -- and as someone who believes in objective right and wrong.)
- kingkongreveng_ 17y agoWhy are you "fine" with US covert/clandestine operations as long as they're done "according to process"? I contend our foolish interference overseas lead directly to the blowback of 9/11 and current tensions with Iran, for starters. Nothing good has come to US citizens from the nonsense the intelligence community gets up to. It should be cut down to a twentieth the size ($25 billion or whatever it is these days is ridiculous).
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoBecause I am fine with the government doing things I do not agree with -- this is why we have elections. The point isn't to get into some kind of spitting match over who did what when. Let's stipulate that duly elected officials acting within the constitution instructed the CIA to do things we do not like. To respond to the fact we don't like it, we elect new officials. We do not terminate the entire national intelligence program. After all, the next bunch of guys in Washington may need a CIA due to no fault of our own, and it take decades to spin one up. Trashing it in a moment of political anger takes away options we might need 20 years from now.
- kingkongreveng_ 17y ago> Washington may need a CIA For what? What have they EVER gotten right? This utterly failed 60 year experiment needs to be shut down. The actual intelligence functions should be absorbed into the pentagon with a much smaller budget.
- hga 17y agoMilitary intelligence is inevitably oriented towards the needs of the military and in the US the needs of the particular branches who are calling the shots at any one point in time. Our national political leadership needs higher level political intelligence, like "what's this foreign leadership likely to do?" and so on, in addition to what they can do (based on e.g. their military resources). There's also a selection bias in your comment "What have they EVER gotten right?" We hear all about many of their mistakes, but by definition we don't hear about most successes until they're declassified many decades later.
- balding_n_tired 17y agoMy impression is that Angleton was on the whole a destructive force.
- hga 17y agoMy first question is where you do decide to strike the balance: in counterintelligence, do you prefer false positives or false negatives? I haven't tried to get a full measure of him and his actions (for one thing, I suspect that's going to be impossible until everything from the relevant periods are declassified), but my major point is that the counterintelligence function is essential and we pretty much just don't do it.