5 ms·
And i find it curious how both those engines seems to have more flexiblity in modding than current ones. Maybe because these days you can't get away with a CLI
by digi_owl 10y ago
And i find it curious how both those engines seems to have more flexiblity in modding than current ones.
Maybe because these days you can't get away with a CLI compiler and some freeware to make "total conversions".
- BugsBunnySan 10y agoMaybe it's a bit the complexity of todays game engines, but I suspect that also, If you give people that much freedom, the publishers and other DRM-zealots will freak out, since then people will easily build their own servers and such...
- vvanders 10y agoYup, it's a bit like trying to build a static HTML page with the full AWS stack. There's this incredibly high cost curve for assets. Back about 6 years ago the dev:art ratio was about 1:10 and I'm going to guess it's even higher these days. That's partially also why you see pixel art style thrive in the indie game space. It's the right combination of low production overhead that can still convey a large amount of information/style.
- animal531 10y agoYeah, 3d is also geometrically (excuse the pun) more difficult to pull off than 2d. Nevermind good looking 3d, animation etc.
- pearle 10y agoThe Creation engine by Bethesda is still highly mod friendly. For example, there is a fan-made total conversion mod being created for TES V: Skyrim that is a remake of TES III: Morrowind [1]. Also, the SureAI team is creating Enderal, a total conversion mod in a completely different setting [2]. [1] http://tesrenewal.com/blog/blog-post-march http://tesrenewal.com/blog/blog-post-march [2] http://sureai.net/games/enderal/?lang=en http://sureai.net/games/enderal/?lang=en
- digi_owl 10y agoQuake got crazy mods like Airquake, made initially by one guy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X173LZkEgYc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X173LZkEgYc
- Kristine1975 10y agoI think it's more because nowadays the higher "realism" makes asset and level creation much harder. I remember seeing a presentation about "The Order: 1886" where they described how they created the visuals for a simple fire hydrant. With amount of work that went into it you could have created a Doom level.
- digi_owl 10y agoThat was kinda what i was talking about. Quake 1 had quake-c and a simple compiler (and later decompiler) and some third party freeware to make models and maps. Come Quake 2 you needed visual-C++ and 3D studio to make mods.
- talmand 10y agoI don't recall any freeware to make and animate models for Quake1. Maps, sure; models not so much. Everybody I knew in the mod scene was using 3D Studio. I don't recall what id Software used, but it was something other than 3D Studio. I suppose something came along later on in the lifespan leading up to Quake2?
- cm3 10y agoI would argue that the resources spent on (visual) effects is dumb money trying to improve a game where the creators fail to build a better, more engaging, highly replayable game. To this day, I haven't encountered a better FPS than Quake3. Quake3 isn't the fastest (Painkiller was IIRC), but it hit the sweet spot and today's contenders (including the new Quake) fail to deliver. The new Unreal Tournament looks promising and likely to be a replacement for Unreal Tournament 1. I've tried and failed to play an FPS with a controller on a console and PC. The games are adapted to the imprecise input devices but it's still nothing like the Quake 3 and Unreal Tournament 1 keyboard+mouse experience. I couldn't get a positive experience out of it, and I hope kids getting started will have a chance to play those games as intended in order to have the full picture.
- cousin_it 10y ago> I would argue that the resources spent on (visual) effects is dumb money trying to improve a game where the creators fail to build a better, more engaging, highly replayable game. Graphics make you buy the game, mechanics make you keep playing, and story gives you happy memories afterward. That explains why AAA games have good graphics, average mechanics, and bad stories :-)