2 ms·
> That's what happens with sup (or other named operators). And that's what happens when scrubbing subscripts or binomial coefficients. When you want to represe
by pron 10y ago
> That's what happens with sup (or other named operators).
And that's what happens when scrubbing subscripts or binomial coefficients. When you want to represent math as text, you need to change your representation (add multiplication signs, forgo subscripts, use confusing parentheses etc.). This is still true with Unicode. The contribution of the non-BMP special math characters is quite minimal.
> The crux of this is that making changes to a standard to support something new and propagating the changes is super hard; getting new standards to get accepted and implemented is a Herculean effort.
Sure, but the emoji craziness continues, and there's little sign it would ever stop. Instead of saying "this isn't text; if you want, call it 'special text', escape it, and let a different body standardize it", the body entrusted with standardizing text representation worries about how to represent a picture of two people kissing as text. What next? Kids would want to add tunes to their text messages. Would the Unicode Consortium add code points for MIDI? And maybe managers would want to standardize code points for organizational diagrams. Would that be the consortium’s responsibility, too? The BMP contains all the characters for reasonable text-art.
- johncolanduoni 10y agoUnicode has added 1791 emojis[1]. Note that it has used significantly fewer codepoints than this for emojis, because some (e.g. flags) are done via a small number of combining marks (flags use 26 code points for letters in country codes). They've been slowing down the rate of additional emojis since they started doing this. Do you really think they'll accelerate at some point and use up the almost 1 million unassigned code points Unicode has left? Not to mention the fact that many UTF8/UTF16 implementations are already fine with full 32-bit code points, instead of the 21 bits Unicode I'm using above (they have said they'll only ever use 21 bits, but the option is there). Suffice it to say this getting "out of control" and eating up the remaining space in our lifetimes, or our children's lifetimes would be pretty impressive. This means that the worst we have to fear is more boxes, assuming OSes don't keep up with their fallback fonts. Saying adding more symbols-designed-to-be-just-kind-of-placed-in-line-with-other-symbols-like-they-always-have-been is the first step towards MIDI and organization diagrams is like saying you're vegetarian because it's a slippery slope from eating meat to eating people. Also note that unlike every other excess of the Unicode standard, these would require massive changes to the code that handles text. This means that if Unicode decided to do this, you wouldn't have to worry about negative effects because nobody would implement it. [1]: http://unicode.org/emoji/charts/full-emoji-list.html http://unicode.org/emoji/charts/full-emoji-list.html
- pron 10y agoI'm not afraid of running out of codepoints. I just think it is misguided that non-text is standardized as text. It just doesn't make sense. I don't know how people will communicate 50 years from now, but I think it's funny that even then, text strings would still need to support all those vegetables and hand gestures. Written text is pretty much eternal; emojis and pictograms? I doubt it. It doesn't make sense for them to get a similar treatment.
- macintux 10y agoOn a long-enough time scale, emojis and pictograms is what we're relying on[1] for nuclear waste warnings. 1: http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph241/dunn2/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2011/ph241/dunn2/