6 ms·
I may be wrong here, but a surface detonation is unlikely to damage a submarine that is deep underwater. That is the reason why a fleet of nuclear submarines ar
by pm90 10y ago
I may be wrong here, but a surface detonation is unlikely to damage a submarine that is deep underwater. That is the reason why a fleet of nuclear submarines are the best nuclear deterrent: hard to take out since they can be anywhere undersea, mobile and ready to counterattack at a moments notice.
- narag 10y agoCan a submarine that is deep underwater launch torpedoes? I didn't think so. OTOH, a nuke doesn't need to yield several megatons. First devices were about 20 kilotons and it's possible to create smaller ones. I'm sure I've seen some video of 1 kiloton bomb. Also, intuitively, it doesn't seem that it would destroy a sub a few miles away looking at Baker test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nWFx-zmI0k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5nWFx-zmI0k Around 1:25 there's a brief fragment showing the explosion underwater with the usual expansion-contraction cycle.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> Can a submarine that is deep underwater launch torpedoes? I didn't think so. The maximum depth for a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_48_torpedo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_48_torpedo is estimated at 800 meters.
- vonmoltke 10y ago> Can a submarine that is deep underwater launch torpedoes? I didn't think so. Where did you get this idea from? Submarines can launch torpedoes at whatever depth the torpedo itself can operate at.
- narag 10y agoWhere did you get this idea from? Movies. On second thought, there was some submarine against submarine battle in Red October... most other submarine wartime movies were from WWII, always shooting at boats and at periscope level to aim. Oh, and speaking about wars, relevant nick :-)
- reactor4 10y agoRanger Able was 1kt.
- elorant 10y agoRussians tested a 4.8 Kiloton T-5 nuclear torpedo in 1957. They used three decommissioned submarines as targets. The weapon was detonated at 20 meters below surface and sank two of the three submarines at a distance of 6.5 miles. As previously mentioned nuclear torpedoes of the era relied on blast damage rather than precision. The shock wave could easily break the hull of any vessel, be it underwater or on the surface.
- graycat 10y ago> hard to take out since they can be anywhere undersea, mobile and ready to counterattack at a moments notice. When I was working in that stuff, the usual point about the SSBNs (the US long range missile firing submarines) was that they were darned difficult to find. Also, it was standard to assume that they moved in some variation on Brownian motion so that, even if did get some data on their location, it was not very useful for extrapolation. So, a major point about the design and operation of the SSBNs was that they be darned difficult to find -- via passive sonar, magnetic anomaly detection, active sonar, or anything else. Also, a big deployment of search resources that might be more able to find an SSBN would be regarded as provocative. Then there was the point: If the Soviets did find a US SSBN, now what? If they track it for very long, then that is provocative. If they don't track it, then they will soon lose it again. If they sink it, then there are all the other US SSBNs ready to fire back. So, the Soviets would have to find AND sink ALL the US SSBNs at the same time. Finding all of the SSBNs at the same time without being provocative was regarded as essentially impossible. So, maybe somehow there could be a nuke war but limited to sea. Then could pick off each SSBN as it was found one at a time. Then how long would the SSBNs last? Once I was asked to answer that! So, I derived some math, wrote some software, submitted my results, and the next day my wife and I went for a vacation in Shenandoah! Later my work was sold to a leading US intel group. I could tell you which one, but then I'd have to ...! Ah, the math wasn't either artificial intelligence or machine learning!
- tr1ck5t3r 10y agoThis was around https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SOSUS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SOSUS and better stuff is around today. Nothing like a big bang to scare the population into projectfear.
- vonmoltke 10y ago> If they track it for very long, then that is provocative. Both sides spent the entire Cold War shadowing each other constantly. There was nothing provocative about it.
- graycat 10y ago