4 ms·
> But I think it's improbable that more than a small minority of those assets are legitimate Yes, and only few people that are arrested that aren't guilty and
by mindslight 10y ago
> But I think it's improbable that more than a small minority of those assets are legitimate
Yes, and only few people that are arrested that aren't guilty and only a few people the cops shoot don't deserve it.
However, each of these rare instances constitutes its own crime perpetuated against an innocent victim. If the justice system doesn't actually strive for justice, it's just another gang of thugs.
- rayiner 10y agoThat's my point! Arguing that justice requires more than statistical probability does not require asserting that the presumed probabilities are wrong. I.e. asset forfeiture can be unjust even if the vast majority of seized assets are actually illegitimate.
- mindslight 10y agoI think characterizing it as unfair downplays the problem. It's not "unfair", it's straight up incorrect to reason off probabilities - the design of the justice system is explicitly not utility maximization. But yes I think people concerned about these issues would do well to understand that they're the minority of cases. If they were that common, things would easily change through the democratic process. The job is then convincing the majority, who will likely never have a problem, that such injustice could happen to them.
- harryh 10y ago> it's straight up incorrect to reason off probabilities When a jury decides that someone committed a crime "beyond reasonable doubt" they are reasoning off probabilities.
- mindslight 10y agoSure, everything decomposes to probabilities after all. I really mean statistics, and optimizing for expected value.