5 ms·
So much misinformation around fracking; incredubly sad the people that want it banned dont understand impermeable layers, sand injection, and salt water disposa
by exabrial 10y ago
So much misinformation around fracking; incredubly sad the people that want it banned dont understand impermeable layers, sand injection, and salt water disposal.
You will always need crude oil, not for burning, but for the synthetics, plastics, and materials of the future in our electric cars. Fracking in the USA has allowed us to use our own ethically sourced resources, rather than fueling wars in the middle east.
- grillvogel 10y ago>always need crude oil, not for burning, but for the synthetics, plastics, and materials of the future in our electric cars. cheap crude oil just temporarily reduces the demand for renewable energy sources while accelerating the decline of the planet. fracking is just an attempt to delay the inevitable and make oil cheaper than it should be. bioplastics will eventually be able to do the things you mention.
- exabrial 10y agoWow. You literally just proved my point. And where can I buy so much as a christmas tree ornament made from bioplastic?
- grillvogel 10y agoso you are arguing that fracking must continue so that the people's right to buy cheap plastic garbage shall not be infringed? theres already enough oil now for the plastic crap to keep coming for a while, just not as cheaply as before. once the true cost of fossil fuel based plastics reach the consumer, there will be more incentive to pursue better options.
- brucefancher 10y agoOf course, by "true cost" you mean the artificial costs that you want government to impose to make fracking more expensive for no reason other than that it offends your sensibilities that consumers want to buy "plastic crap" that you disapprove of and heat their homes inexpensively. What a humanitarian you are.
- SuddsMcDuff 10y agoThere's 250 million cars in the US. If every single one of them was replaced with an electric car, that would mean at least 1 billion new tires. How much oil is needed to manufacture 1 billion tires? Christmas decorations are the least of our problems.
- makomk 10y agoProbably not very much compared to the amount of oil used to drive those cars - tires are quire thin. I wouldn't be surprised if the oil used in transporting them dominated the equation. Also, 1 billion tires is about the number manufactured annually and it's unlikely everyone would replace their car with an electric one within a year, or eve a few years. Tires are really the least of our problems.
- SuddsMcDuff 10y agoManufacturing a car tire requires 7 gallons of oil. 5 are raw materials to produce the synthetic rubber, while 2 gallons supply the energy required. Lets assume the energy is produced by alternative means, that leaves us with 5 gallons of oil per car tire. That's 5 billion gallons of oil for 1 billion tires. There's around 35 gallons of oil per barrel. That's 142,857,143 barrels of oil. The US produces roughly 9.5 million barrels of crude per day. It would take around 15 days to make 1 billion new tires if 100% of US oil was dedicated to the cause. Now that I've done the maths, it doesn't seem like such a huge problem. So I concede to your point.
- adwn 10y ago> There's 250 million cars in the US. If every single one of them was replaced with an electric car, that would mean at least 1 billion new tires. Huh. I didn't know that gasoline-car-tires are incompatible with electric-car-tires. That's too bad, because if they weren't, you could continue using the tires from your previous car on your new car.
- douche 10y agoGood luck getting the same tires to fit on two different vehicles. Even within the same model line, rim diameters and widths change year to year. Long gone are the days when most vehicles on the road had 15" rims.
- quakeguy 10y agoDon't celebrate x-mas would be a start. /s
- lucaspiller 10y agoWhen I was young ornaments for Christmas trees were usually glass. The move to plastic was only so that they could be made cheaper.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoYou know, I'd much rather drop a plastic ornament on the floor than a glass one. Thinking about the ornaments I'm familiar with, there are a couple glass ones, which need special care. Mostly they're wood / cloth / metal. Plastic is rare, mostly cheap souvenirs of elementary school.
- adrianN 10y agoThe glass ornament likely uses a comparable amount of oil to create. Making glass in pretty energy intensive.
- kbart 10y ago"The glass ornament likely uses a comparable amount of oil to create" The energy might come from renewables, not necessarily oil.
- Kliment 10y agoI'll sell you one freshly printed on my 3d printer from PLA bioplastic, which is the most common material in use in desktop 3d printing (because of material properties, not because of the bio-ness of it)
- frakr 10y agoI don't understand how people can be so confident in the computer models that show that it is safe to inject millions upon millions of gallons of toxic waste water deep underground. They say that it's safe over a timeline of hundreds of years, but we don't even have computer models that can predict the weather above ground for next week.
- nisa 10y agoEven if the models turn out to be correct: There are accidents, things can break and release chemicals in other regions also typical shortcuts for cost saving are likely: Chemicals used are different than mandated to reduce costs, most of these chemicals are also patented and restricted trade secrets that have seen little unbiased research afaik. It's similar to nuclear power. Nice on paper but if you add all real-life risks and costs and let the managers make the decisions that the engineers won't support or have scepticism about, bad things will happen. Germany does not really need the technology and it's highly unpopular here so risking potential environmental harm is probably not worth it. The results from the USA are also rather mixed in regards to being harmless. Here is some data that is rather sceptical: http://www.mweimh.nrw.de/energie/_pdf_container/gutachten_uba_kurz.pdf http://www.mweimh.nrw.de/energie/_pdf_container/gutachten_ub... (german only, sorry)
- piotrjurkiewicz 10y agoI don't understand how people can be so confident in the computer models that show that the Earth will become warmer and warmer. They even say that it's caused by human activity and it can be stopped if we avoid burning fuels, but we don't even have computer models that can predict the weather above ground for next week. So how can they predict exact temperature for next few hundreds years?
- nisa 10y agoI get your point but you are wrong. Climate change is based on a lot of historical data and measurements and theoretical models from various sources. Fracking depends on the geology and certain assumptions about what's going on while fracking and that everything is going according to a plan. Might be harmless in certain regions might be a problem in others. There is little data on fracking as it's recent technology - results on earthquakes are just in and don't look particular harmless.
- maxxxxx 10y ago" impermeable layers" How do we know this is true long-term? We don't even know what fluids get pumped down since they are a trade secret.
- exabrial 10y agoBecause for millions of years, they have remained that way despite having things oders of magnitude more force applied than humans ever could. Arguing what an impermeable layer is, is like saying the LHC is going to kill us from creating black holes.
- crottypeter 10y ago>Fracking in the USA ... ethically sourced resources Surely these two are mutually exclusive? The US oil lobby has even more powerful propaganda than I thought if people really believe fracking is ethical!
- SuddsMcDuff 10y agoIt's all relative. Compared to the Oil fields in say Sirte Libya, a fracking establishment next to an elementary school in California might be considered relatively ethical.
- exabrial 10y agoYeah, the offshore drilling is done by Major corporations that probably have questionable ethics. I don't have the numbers on hand, but I can tell you in the midwest there are a lot of small independent oil and gas firms. Most of the money is exchanged for the other small companies to handle things like, Oilfield Services, transport, testing, OSHA requirements, environmental assurance, abd site cleanup. Local economies are so strong actually that the big players have trouble breaking in because prices are so low and efficiently handled by the small companies competing with each other.
- vbuwivbiu 10y agonope, it's grandpa tech. GMOs will kill all oil products