3 ms·
This doesn't deserve the label "fallacy"; the only thing I got is that the author disagrees about the implications of restarting a mind somewhere else. Well, g
by SilasX 10y ago
This doesn't deserve the label "fallacy"; the only thing I got is that the author disagrees about the implications of restarting a mind somewhere else. Well, great, but you need to explain substantively why you think that is, not simply disagree with it.
But even then, you should only label the flawed premise -- the one you're refuting to make this point -- as the fallacy, not the conclusion.
What's worse, the author's disagreement has to deal with the (almost) established "consciousness branching" that happens all the time. If you accept the universality of the Schrödinger equation, then your body is branching into different parts of the wavefunction, yet (each of) you obviously internally perceive it as the same consciousness.