3 ms·
Also, isn't there an issue of "gene" being something of an unnatural category? Nature doesn't provide a clean labeling of what part of the sequence is "a" gene,
by SilasX 10y ago
Also, isn't there an issue of "gene" being something of an unnatural category? Nature doesn't provide a clean labeling of what part of the sequence is "a" gene, and the term historically existed (AIUI) to denote regions that the researcher found to have phenotypic relevance. So I'm not sure it's helpful to phrase a minimum in terms of "n genes". See:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene#Functional_definitions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene#Functional_definitions
- grandalf 10y agoThis is an excellent point. It also illustrates how a useful abstraction at one level can hinder reasoning at another.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> the term historically existed (AIUI) to denote regions that the researcher found to have phenotypic relevance That's Mendelian genetics. Geneticists focused on DNA as a physical molecule rather than a conceptual unit of inheritance use the same word to refer to a region of DNA that produces a protein. They're both important concepts, but they're not the same concept.
- dragonwriter 10y agoArguably, the production of a protein is nearly the smallest element of the observable characteristic of an organism produced by the interaction of its genotype with the environment, and thus sort of the fundamental unit of phenotype, so, from that perspective, they are exactly the same thing.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoThey are not the same thing from any useful perspective. You can remove a (protein-coding) gene, or replace it, without altering the phenotype at all. You can make changes outside protein-coding regions and get large phenotypic changes.
- SilasX 10y agoOkay I got the terms wrong but I think the core point stands: a gene is typically defined with respect to some research objective and area of interest, and is highly variable depending on what you're looking at. It doesn't (yet, at least) have a natural boundary. People looking at one phenomenon might see one boundary for a a gene, while others see another. In fact, I think that term is great for comparison: "phenomenon". Asking for the "minimum genes for viable life" seems like asking for the "minimum number of natural phenomena to put a man on the moon". Are those two phenomena really just different manifestations of "gravity" or are they two things in their own right? "It depends."