6 ms·
So there is a great amount of lists, blogposts and information about awful/bad IoT things, but if someone like me want to have a list about IoT things that are
by diggan 10y ago
So there is a great amount of lists, blogposts and information about awful/bad IoT things, but if someone like me want to have a list about IoT things that are actually secure and well-working, where would I find that?
- Klathmon 10y agoI'd love a list like that as well, but sadly I don't think one exists and I don't think there's any money in doing it. Nobody wants to hear about good IoT devices, they want to make fun of bad ones and feel superior, that's what sells clicks. Maybe i'm just being cynical...
- ethbro 10y agoI don't think there's enough profit margin in most IoT devices to allocate to something like this. F.ex. when's the last time you saw a commercial for a door knob?
- Klathmon 10y agoI've seen multiple commercials for thermostats, smart refrigerators, a smart doorbell, and a bunch of IoT lights and light switches.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI've been to a conference literally sponsored by a door knob manufacturer. But they don't target "end users", they target the people you hire to design and renovate your house. Similarly, the home automation solution targeted at those people usually aren't shit cloud-based products.
- wepple 10y agoI think you nailed it: hackers don't want to write blog posts saying "damn, this thing was pretty well made". Perhaps an open-source effort to document & track what work has been done, even if it's just pulling firmware images and taking a look around. Maybe some kind of gamification to motivate researchers to pull things apart and report what they see.
- Klathmon 10y agoIt's not just that people don't want to write about it, it's that people don't want to read it either. You'd never see a post on the front page of HN about how IoT device X was well designed and is generally secure, but you see (and will continue to see) them top out about how awful they are. Just look at this thread. Half the answers to "what are some good IoT devices" is "lol there aren't any"... The HN crowd doesn't want good IoT devices, they want to make fun of bad ones.
- sbierwagen 10y agoPeople don't want to read it, otherwise the front page of HN would be carpeted with astroturfed 5 star reviews of bad products. (See also: most Amazon reviews)
- voltagex_ 10y agoI'll write one when I find something worthy of it. I've got stupidly high standards though. I've bought everything from wireless hard drives to $250 Wifi routers to $20 ethernet/3G bridges and the quality of the firmware is pretty garbage on all of them. I see brand new devices on kernel 2.4 and 2.6 with no upgrade plans in sight, and hacked up kernel trees that have no chance of building except on the developers' Red Hat 9 (!) workstations. http://www.devttys0.com/blog/ http://www.devttys0.com/blog/ is another good place to follow. I guess it's more fun to write a negative article, not to mention it gets a lot more views.
- wepple 10y agoyeah, I love ttys0 blog, it's great. Perhaps a good strategy would be to still offer an interesting read despite a lack of "hey i found epic 0days and hacked everything": - here's my methodology - here are some cool ways they made this thing robust - here is how I tried/successfully defeated the defenses - some tooling I created to break this thing
- pc86 10y agoI think that's your answer.
- manyxcxi 10y agoIt's not that easy. I stick with brands/products that are reviewed by people I trust or have seemed to pick up some momentum. My general rule of thumb is I NEVER buy anything IoT that is WiFi based. Zigbee or Z-Wave based devices will save you a lot of security nightmares (though definitely not all).
- pavel_lishin 10y agoWhy is Z* preferable to Wifi-based?
- gnur 10y agoOne of the reasons would be that it isn't used that often and won't allow access to your network with commodity hardware.
- EarthIsHome 10y agoIsn't this idea hiding the problem though? While using uncommon hardware and protocols may thwart certain users, it's really not solving the problem of security. It's somewhat similar to the idea of using a hidden wireless network and calling that security instead of securing your network with WPA2, etc. As these devices become more popular, we'll start seeing more Zigbees and Z-wave devices become commodity hardware.
- Dayshine 10y agoNot at all, anyone can "join" the network, but nobody can decrypt the traffic without the key. Zigbee has built-in, easy, encryption. You simply set your router to allow unsecured joins temporarily whenever you get a new device, which then learns the key. When the network is set to allow only secure joins only devices pre-configured with the key can see anything other than encrypted frames.
- garduque 10y agoI've installed tens (if not hundreds) of thousands of Zigbee devices over the last handful of years. Zigbee may be uncommon in residential, but it is not uncommon.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> If someone like me want to have a list about IoT things that are actually secure and well-working, where would I find that? Here ya go! ...
- Tobani 10y agoThe comments in the article link to this: https://github.com/HQarroum/awesome-iot https://github.com/HQarroum/awesome-iot
- rubidium 10y agoNone of those are actual finished products (except for the amazon dash... which also isn't really a product). There's hardware and software components and recommendations, but (perhaps tellingly) no "IOT thermostat" or "IOT fridge".
- dimino 10y agoI'm a little worried the answer to this question is []. :(