5 ms·
Does anyone know the argument chain? I'm curious how someone made this outlandish claim sound plausible.
by StavrosK 10y ago
Does anyone know the argument chain? I'm curious how someone made this outlandish claim sound plausible.
- tossaway1 10y agoWas thinking the same thing. That seems like a big omission from the article unless the chain was just some sort of incoherent meandering rant...
- jarman 10y agoMost coherent argument was vague similarity of iconic "Lenin speaks from armored car" image (http://klin-demianovo.ru/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/prizyvvogdja.jpg http://klin-demianovo.ru/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/prizyvvo...) with mycelium (car) and fruit body (Lenin) >some sort of incoherent meandering rant That was the point: total absurdity told with total seriousness.
- gchp 10y ago> I'm curious how someone made this outlandish claim sound plausible. From the article: > Soviet television had, up to that point, been regarded by its audience as conservative in style and content. As a result, a large number of Soviet citizens (one estimate puts the number at 11,250,000 audience members) took the deadpan "interview" at face value, in spite of the absurd claims presented. I guess this had something to do with it? If people were used to TV being a certain way, and this "interview" was presented in the same way, then it would seem reasonable that it would be taken up in the same was as every other. Nothing (aside from content) made it stand out from other shows. Saying that, the claim is crazy, and it does seem strange that it was seemingly accepted as truth. I wonder how a similar stunt could be attempted today, and what the reaction would be...
- icen 10y agoFor a western analogue, try the BBC's spaghetti plantations.
- kalleboo 10y agoIn Sweden we had the Colour TV Stocking http://hoaxes.org/archive/permalink/instant_color_tv http://hoaxes.org/archive/permalink/instant_color_tv
- vermontdevil 10y agoI was going to post that too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghetti-tree_hoax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghetti-tree_hoax Loved this one as well.
- VLM 10y agoor political correctness, as typically indoctrinated in school.
- kodfodrasz 10y agosaying such things to this particular audience will result in massive downvotes.
- boomlinde 10y agoWith less variation it seems to result in someone complaining about their imaginary persecution.
- Rexxar 10y agoThey should have tried with this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghetti_squash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaghetti_squash
- dottedmag 10y agoTV propaganda in contemporary Russia works pretty well, so TV is still seen as an authority. It does not help that there are no large TV stations anymore in Russia that are not state-owned (openly or covertly).
- azeirah 10y agoArgument chain is mostly irrelevant here, people who fall for this simply believe anything who pretends to be an authority. Heck, I know for one that I /could/ believe something like this. A friend of mine once convinced me that both wheels of a bicycle rotate into the opposite direction, just to test my gullibility. I totally fell for it, even though we were on the bike at that very moment. I could've easily checked or reasoned that it didn't make any sense whatsoever.
- alister 10y ago> wheels of a bicycle rotate into the opposite direction Your example reminded me that on a very rare occasion something that sounds stupid and counter-intuitive is true: A train wheel always has some point on it that is traveling backwards when the train is moving forward. It sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? If the train is moving forward, then all points on the train are moving forward. How could it be otherwise? This is very difficult to explain without a diagram: https://books.google.ca/books?id=SiviAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA143&lpg=PA143&dq=train+wheel+travels+backward++prolate+cycloid&source=bl&ots=E5JpPwNEcT&sig=tAzwZA1jY4cLsKv7l8DDre97FbY&hl=en&sa=X&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=train%20wheel%20travels%20backward%20%20prolate%20cycloid&f=false https://books.google.ca/books?id=SiviAgAAQBAJ&pg=PA143&lpg=P...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- OscarCunningham 10y agoI think the thing with the train wheels is sort of obvious once you see that it only works because part of the wheel overhangs the rail. The axle of the wheel is moving forwards, and the bit in contact with the track is stationary, so the bit further out than that is going backwards.
- StavrosK 10y agoI don't think it's that difficult to explain. The part under the track, the "flange" goes backwards. The part exactly on the track is not moving at all, same as a car (or any other) wheel. This is also pretty obvious when you consider that if the wheel was turning in relation to the ground, it would be skidding.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThis was very very early post-Soviet TV. Soviet TV had around 6 channels and everything on them was always very very bland and was supposed to be accepted outright it not believed. Kind of gets you after 30 years of watching. And then boom, and you have "Lenin is a Mushroom". I believe some confusion was genuine.
- anonymfus 10y agoIt was more like a network of connections than a chain.
- 100ideas 10y ago"Every revolution, he argued, is indeed an impressive visual spectacle. Although we usually assume that visual representations of a revolution happen later, after the events have already taken place, Kurekhin argued that revolutions are simply too spectacular to happen on their own. Some- one “first [has] to visualize certain images and later attempt to reproduce them in reality.” During a recent visit to Mexico, he continued, he had seen frescos that depicted the Mexican revolution of the early twentieth century in a style identical to the one used for the Russian Bolshevik revo- lution: “the same exhausted people, armed with primitive tools of labor, overthrowing some rulers.” In order for revolutionary leaders in both places to have imagined these events in a similar manner, their minds must surely have been sub- jected to similar influences. In Mexico, the source of influence is clear. During ritualistic ceremonies, Kurekhin explained, the native peoples routinely used drinks prepared from Lophophora Williamsii or peyote— a Mexican cactus with strong psychotropic properties.2 Although Mexican cacti do not grow in Russia, Kurekhin noted, Russian forests do have an abundance of similar hallucinogens: mushrooms, most prominently the fly agaric mushroom (mukhomor).3 These mushrooms, he claimed, induce the same effects as the Mexican cacti: “people see absolutely incredible pictures very vividly and colorfully” and “enormous scenes of great events and revolutions fly before your eyes.” Building on this premise, Kurekhin began to formulate his famous thesis: “Reading the correspondence between [Vladimir] Lenin and [Iosif] Stalin I came across one phrase: ‘Yesterday I ate too many mush- rooms, but I felt great.’” Bolshevik leaders ate a lot of mushrooms, Kure- khin mused, and some of them surely had hallucinogenic properties. If consumed for many years, these mushrooms can permanently change an individual’s personality. Indeed, Kurekhin continued in an unwaver- ing scholarly tone, “I have absolutely irrefutable proof that the October revolution was carried out by people who had been consuming certain mushrooms for many years. And these mushrooms, in the process of be- ing consumed by these people, had displaced their personalities. These people were turning into mushrooms. In other words, I simply want to say that Lenin was a mushroom.” A Parasite from Outer Space:: How Sergei Kurekhin Proved That Lenin Was a Mushroom Alexei Yurchak Slavic Review Vol. 70, No. 2 (SUMMER 2011), pp. 307-333 http://libgen.io/scimag/get.php?doi=10.5612/slavicreview.70.2.0307 http://libgen.io/scimag/get.php?doi=10.5612/slavicreview.70....
- avdicius 10y agoThere was no valid arguments. Just bogus claims interspersed with irrelevant quotes and a pretence of authority.
- krick 10y agoI am not sure if telling it second-handedly would make any sense. Actually, even watching it translated to english hardly would be the same experience. Basically, to any intelligent person it was an obvious joke, but quite a good one. The most powerful part of it wasn't what he was telling, actually, but how he was doing it: you know, some sane-looking person, a fluent, eloquent speaker, is telling something so ridiculous so seriously, that you might even start to question what is true anyway. He uses some clever words, pseudo-scientific side-notes, mis-interpreted quotes, and all the time he looks deadly serious, repeatedly asking the audience: "You see what's going on here? It's absolutely unbelievable!" To summarize it, it was something like this: he persuades you, that Lenin was heavily abusing psychodelic mushrooms, then, going through some pseudo-scientific gibberish makes a claim, that heavy use of mushrooms led to that a mushroom basically displaced human consciousness, then, by making some random observations "supporting" his claim, makes the statement "Lenin became a mushroom" more and more literal. Anyway, I would argue that it has nothing to do with Soviet propaganda and such: it was a great performance, but not so different in it's nature from a kind of reasoning in the very modern western propaganda or quasi-documental movies about aliens and such. Only it was mockingly exaggerated on purpose.