5 ms·
British business ‘benefits massively from EU’
- nailer 10y agoThe article URL is the full, non-paywalled text of the letter published in today's Times at: http://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/british-business-benefits-massively-from-eu-n5bhfw9nd http://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/british-business-benefits-...
- gadders 10y agoI'm not sure we'll get much meaningful discussion here. It's like having a debate of Trump vs Hilary vs Bernie.
- adwf 10y agoVery much so. It's turned into the UKs very own replica of the US primaries, with much the same arguments. I guarantee if we had a land border with Europe, someone on the leave campaign would be talking about building a wall :D
- smoyer 10y agoBut at least you've got a moat ;) If Trump is elected, he may have to build a second wall along the Canadian (Canadienne) border - to keep people in the U.S.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- richmarr 10y agoWe do, with the Republic of Ireland... and we have a borderless travel treaty with them called the Common Travel Area which has existed in one form or another for nearly 100 years.
- adwf 10y agoIt's also a condition of the Ireland peace agreement that we keep it open. No EU, no peace. We'd have to renegotiate the deal, amongst all the others... And if we leave it open? All the migrants will just flood through NI. The whole idea that we can control migration by leaving is absurd nonsense.
- smoyer 10y agoNot many people in my circles are excited about the upcoming presidential election - maybe democracy finally dies because the candidates are so uninspired that we simply don't go to the polls.
- redsummer 10y agoNon-EU Norway and Switzerland are at the top of nearly every measure in Europe: standard of living, equality, economy, green issues, credit rating, social progress, democracy, lack of poverty, lack of corruption. Non-EU Iceland and EU Greece both had severe economic problems. Iceland jailed the bankers, and has overcame it's difficulties. Greece has been jailed BY the bankers - and will now be in debt bondage for decades, and has seen a resurgence of Fascism. Children are digging through rubbish for something to eat. This is in the EU.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- smcl 10y agoNon-EU Moldova and Belarus are bottom of nearly every measure in Europe: Standard of living, equality, green issues, credit rating, social progress, democracy, lack of poverty, lack of corruption. etc :) I do think the EU handled Greek crisis pretty poorly, however but I think you're way overblowing the rest of the stuff you said.
- gns24 10y agoNorway and Switzerland have both signed up to free movement of people in order to access the single market. If the UK votes to leave I think that, given the nature of the campaign, that has to be considered a vote against free movement of people, which almost certainly will leave it outside the single market, which is a very different place.
- 98Windows 10y agoFirstly Norway, Switzerland and Iceland are in the EEA so they do have many things associated with EU membership. Greece has the Euro hence its troubles. I totally agree the eurozone is a terrible mess and should be dismantled. So the UK leaving the EU (and the EEA) will cause damage. Your descriptions of the EU are misleading.
- js8 10y ago> Non-EU Norway and Switzerland are at the top of nearly every measure in Europe But what is the causality here? Maybe they didn't want to become a member because they were at the top to begin with. That doesn't say anything about benefits of membership for other countries. It's even possible that membership would be beneficial for Norway and Switzerland, people just don't want to take unnecessary risk.
- jklepatch 10y agoSo basically we have UK businesses selling to europe expressing their interest in keeping 0 tax trade agreements with europe. Their position makes sense from their perspective. How about UK businesses which DO NOT export and have to compete with low cost european countries instead? How about UK employees which also have to compete with low cost labor from low cost european countries? Is this also "great for the UK?"
- eulji 10y agoUh and how other global economies compete ? So you want to protect these employees by "artificial" regulations ? Judging by your surname your ancestors were also fleeing from one of those low cost european countries.
- rlpb 10y agoThe UK is a net importer from the EU[1]. [1] https://www.uktradeinfo.com/Statistics/OverseasTradeStatistics/Pages/OTS.aspx https://www.uktradeinfo.com/Statistics/OverseasTradeStatisti...
- marcospri 10y agoNot sure there are many businesses that compete with "low cost" european countries but not with non-european low cost ones
- muse5000 10y agogetting out is not going to change anything that you mentioned, its like Boris trying to underline that British Steel was EU's fault... I mean what?... Its clearly the case were production has a cut back globally and the need of steel is not there anymore plus China overproducing... how's that EU? For the UK employees that have to compete with low cost labor... I don't think that's the case mate, its an open market, if you are good at what you are doing you are going to get valued. Lets see what you and Boris are going to say to all those people working in Universities that are going to shut down as their main source of income are EU students.
- jklepatch 10y ago
- imaginenore 10y agoThere's zero substance in the article. They use scary words like "massively", phrases like "more trade", "more jobs", but don't say specifically how many and why. I've listened to the arguments from both sides, and the proponents of Brexit tend to give more specific reasons, while the opponent's seem to be stuck in the scare tactics and propaganda, like this article. Take changing the terms of trade, for instance. They make it sound like the end of the world. In reality terms of trade change all the time - new laws, new agreements (TTPP recently, for example).
- nailer 10y agoBrexit folk give just as much vagueness as Remain folk - the trust is, nobody can guarantee anything whether we remain or leave the EU. Some Brexit folk have repeatedly claimed MEPs aren't elected, which is plainly false. Furthermore every EU law must must be ratified by all member states. They've also claimed that Turkey would join, which is unlikely in our lifetimes. OTOH, some Remain folk plainly think that Brexit is some kind of racist plot: as another commenter mentions, businesses that don't trade with the rest of the EU don't benefit as much as those of us that do, and that's a very reasonable viewpoint. I'm Remain - like most of London tech. My reasons are that that London draws the smartest and best people from all over Europe to start businesses here and pay taxes, and that should continue. An Australian style points system is flawed - imagine rating programmers based on their University degrees rather than their actual aptitude. However I can certainly understand the opposing viewpoint.
- awjr 10y agoI think the big value with staying in the EU is passporting and the single common market. Norway and Sweden both pay to be part of this market instrument.
- nutheracc 10y agoThis post is blatant political persuasion, not here for interest/information.
- marak830 10y ago(precursor I'm in Japan so I don't have a chip in this game), but I do worry for my friends in England. My wife works for (edit removed: large vehicle manufacturer ), and she has mentioned that her company is quite nervous about the brexit due to having manufacturing plants there and worrying about the cost of importing raw materials if Britain leaves, due to new import taxes. Take this with a bag of salt, aa i havnt verified any of this, but it's something I hadn't thought of before, and I thought it may spark a decent debate on HN.
- adwf 10y agoYeah I've heard similar things about said Japanese manufacturers. One of the big reasons they are regionally headquartered in the UK is because it is part of the EU. Given that cars make up a sizable fraction (~10% I think) of our economy, it would be a disaster if even 1 major company left for foreign shores over this. Speaking from an IT perspective, I know of quite a few companies that have brought forward datacentre builds in the Frankfurt region, prepping for a Brexit just in case. They have to do with business with the EU and that involves complying with EU data protection regulations which require the data stored in an EU country. There's a lot of business going to disappear overseas if Brexit happens.
- marak830 10y agoIf that's the case+ and I have no reason to believe it isn't), what reasons could they have for leaving? I have been listening to BBC world news, and whenever the subject comes up, the people speaking for an exit don't really seem to put forth a good argument( I hear a lot of 'keep our nationality" and 'we founded parliamentary democracy ' - but they don't seem like a good reason to leave).
- hectorperez 10y agoDatabase of people who agree/disagree on Brexit and why: http://www.agreelist.com/brexit http://www.agreelist.com/brexit
- awjr 10y agoThe one place I was hoping not to see Brexit was on HN. Ah well. For what it's worth, if you are still in two minds after, what feels like, 6 years of campaigning, this video gives, an evidence based argument for staying. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=USTypBKEd8Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=USTypBKEd8Y The lecturer also followed it up https://news.liverpool.ac.uk/2016/06/20/eu-law-expert-responds-industrial-dishonesty-video-goes-viral/ https://news.liverpool.ac.uk/2016/06/20/eu-law-expert-respon... I am genuinely interested in an evidence based argument for leaving and whether the benefits of leaving out strip the benefits of staying. The most sound argument I have found is the democratic deficit created by being within the EU and the delegation of authority to the EU on certain areas of law. The elephant in the room is that we seem to have a house of 800 unelected lords and a government in power event though only 34% of the electorate voted for them. Arguments around "putting the great back into Great Britain" and "taking control" seem to stem, as much from xenophobia and 6 years of government austerity policies. I really wish there was a good, logical, evidence based approach to comparing both positions.
- adwf 10y agoThe problem with the Brexit campaign is that they just don't trust any experts: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/06/16/eu-referendum-leave-supporters-trust-ordinary-common-sense-than/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/06/16/eu-referendum-lea... If people don't listen to evidence, then how can anyone have a proper debate?
- nailer 10y ago> The one place I was hoping not to see Brexit was on HN Not sure if you mean Brexit the argument or the topic. If you mean the topic: a quote from one of the founders of ef, where Magic Pony was created: "leaving the European Union will have sweeping negative effects on British startups' ability to hire, fundraise and access international markets." If you mean the argument, then fair enough.
- awjr 10y agoI was hoping the topic. I hadn't considered the impact on start-ups. Oh joy.
- nailer 10y agodang: the article has been flagged unnecessarily. It's topical, HN worthy, factual and relevant - the discussion just has some very heated opinions against. Can you check it out?
- gonvaled 10y agoAfter so much campaigning, it seems plain clear that the UK is actually leaching in a big way from the EU. The UK is a sore player, only wanting to take part when there is a clear and direct benefit, is not happy to play by the rules, always requesting special treatment, and continuously complaining of how bad we are treating them. Not a team player at all. I am not sure if the UK is better off leaving, but we in the EU will do great getting rid of the grumpy bully.
- pigpaws 10y agoI'll just leave this here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTMxfAkxfQ0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTMxfAkxfQ0