4 ms·
Depends on how quickly the climate changed. Lets say one year winter came and spring never did. It simply went from less cold to more cold all year long and dec
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Depends on how quickly the climate changed. Lets say one year winter came and spring never did. It simply went from less cold to more cold all year long and deciduous plants stopped growing north of say Dallas Texas.
All sorts of food stocks simply die. No corn, no wheat, no cows, chickens, or pigs (in year 2) and no vegetables. Fruits from the tropics perhaps but another huge die off in that vegetation as well as temperatures drop into the 40's at night. There is no "other place" to go, so generally you see (depending on your model) 70 - 85% of the population outside the middle lattitudes die from starvation and general unrest. If you are lucky, you get someone smart enough to create a defensible space in the mid lattitudes that can support the population inside of it. The fisheries will crash in year 3 as the remaining survivors use what is left of the world wide fishing fleet to haul in ever more valuable food (aka fish). Then the people in the defensible spaces need to hold off the people outside those spaces until those outer people die and are no longer a threat. That can take a while and since the outside people will be scavenging weapons from the whole frozen world they will have a lot more ammo and war fighting resources than the people in the defensible spaces.
If it changes fast enough, the people trying to survive kill off everyone. It has happened in colonies before and it can presumably happen on a more global scale.
Would bands of indigenous jungle tribes survive? Good question, anything that moved would be hunted as food, jungle would clear cut to make farmland as quickly as possible.
If it happened slowly? Like over a couple of decades? Sure that would probably allow people to survive relatively intact save for their ability to actually make any new things of any level of technological sophistication.
Look at maps of the late Pleistocene where the glaciers were and plot those out on a modern globe. Now look at what is under those glaciers and try to figure out how long it would take to relocate that capability south. More importantly how long it would take to relocate it south. That sets the parameters for the maximum rate at which the species could tolerate the onset of a new ice age.
- jessaustin 10y agoI thought we were talking about global warming?
- ChuckMcM 10y agoWe are, but that is sort of the "trade name" for anthropocentric climate change. Which, if you read a lot of papers track the rising temperatures but have a variety of opinions of how exactly that will affect the climate. One such change can be triggering a sudden glaciation event.
- jessaustin 10y agoA sort of Mpemba effect on a global scale? That's got to be the goofiest global warming thing I've heard yet, and I've been following the movement since 1992.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoNot really, Mpemba is about water freezing. There was a recent Nature paper discussion which looked at the non-linear effects of various climate modifiers[1]. I pointed out that some models have warming causing the onset of a glaciation event, the mechanics are warmer air carries more water vapor (itself a powerful greenhouse influence) which sets up a positive feedback loop making the air warmer and then sucking up more water from evaporation, which retains more heat which makes the air warmer. You cross the dewpoint in the stratosphere and that gets 100% solid cloud cover above the tropsphere. At which point the albedo of the planet goes way up (its a uniform white reflector at that point) and the water in the troposphere precipitates out as the mother of all snow storms and the greenhouse gas equivalent of nuclear winter. Do I actually think this is going to happen? Not really. Are we recording unprecedented levels of greenhouse gases? Yes. Is the climate we're experiencing similar to the climate that was in effect when those levels occurred in the past? Not really, the early Pleistocene was much warmer than it is now. Moore's paper from 1980 was probably pretty influential here. He, like others, is/was really interested in why we had ice ages in the first place. The point though is that we talk about "global warming" which implies to a lot of people who don't read the papers that our inputs into the climate will only cause increased heat, but it is more accurate to say "climate change" since we don't have good non-linear models for how the planet responds to all the forcing functions we are throwing at it. We casually throw around terms like "hottest temperatures ever recorded" or "lowest ice levels on record" but some times lose sight of the fact that the "record" we've been keeping in terms of climate change is, according to ice cores, and other geologic carbon dating of glaciation events, perhaps 2% of a cycle. (assuming 100kyr cycle and 2kr of nominal human recordings). Remember that 2% of a year is one week. We can't take a week's worth of measurements and even imagine all of the variations we'll see that year, so we have to be careful about extrapolating with the amount of data we have. Pretty much everyone (except some really hard liners) can agree that climate can and will change, its understanding that change which we can only develop as we go along. And the latest contribution to our understand was the Nature paper that said, in essence, don't try to model this stuff with linear models. [1] http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v5/n5/full/nclimate2568.html http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v5/n5/full/nclimate25... [2] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ted_Moore/publication/222200712_The_evolution_of_Pleistocene_climate_A_time_series_approach/links/546b4b310cf2397f7831ba2b.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ted_Moore/publication/2...