4 ms·
Supply and Demand. If demand rises -- and it does, the population of LA is increasing by roughly 20,000 annually (from http://www.clrsearch.com/Los-Angeles-Dem
by youngButEager 10y ago
Supply and Demand.
If demand rises -- and it does, the population of LA is increasing by roughly 20,000 annually (from http://www.clrsearch.com/Los-Angeles-Demographics/CA/Population-Growth-and-Population-Statistics http://www.clrsearch.com/Los-Angeles-Demographics/CA/Populat...)
-- if 20,000 per year are added to LA's population, you need more rental units.
Here's a potential SAT question in the 'Logical Reasoning' part:
"A large city experiences 20,000 population growth per year. Because restaurants, doctors, barbers, dentists, and other service providers are not growing fast enough in the city to accommodate this large growth in citizens, should the city:
[A] Provide incentives for new restaurants, doctors, barbers, dentists, etc. to move into the city and start operating to meet the need?
[B] Or should the city impose caps/limits on the fees/charges of those restaurants, doctors, barbers, dentists, etc. who already operate in the city, which will create disincentives for new operators to move to the city to satisfy increasing demand?
Supply and Demand. The demand for EVERYTHING is affected by 20,000 new citizens in LA each year.
In 10 years there 100,000 to 200,000 more citizens in LA.
With the disincentives for new landlords to enter the LA market, there will be an even more severe shortage of units.
"Shortage of willing landlords."
The old adage is this:
"You cannot price-limit, and regulate, and tax your way to an over-supply of housing."
It's really, REALLY awful that city leaders don't understand that.
Guess which cities have the greatest shortage of landlords?
Los Angeles
San Francisco
New York City
San Jose
(those are the U.S. cities with the longest period of landlord-reducing Rent control laws, by the way)
Can we PLEASE INCREASE THE FREAKING SUPPLY of willing landlords.
PLEASE.
$3500+ for a 1 bedroom apartment is just pyscho.
- hueving 10y agoThe number of people even on HN that don't seem to grasp supply and demand is shocking. If HN is a relatively intelligent group, imagine how much of the general population will think just price limiting housing will work?
- st3v3r 10y agoWe grasp it just fine. We also take a dim view of asshole landlords that decide to skirt the law.
- mamon 10y agoIf the law is stupid it is your patriotic duty to ignore it :)
- st3v3r 10y agoNo, it is your duty to work to get it changed. I imagine there are a number of industrial companies that feel workplace safety laws and laws banning the dumping of waste in waterways to be stupid, would you be ok if they ignored those?
- hueving 10y agoSure, you can hate them all you want, but that doesn't change the stupidity of trying to pass laws that prevent people from participating in a market. Look how well the war on drugs is going.
- danieltillett 10y ago"You cannot price-limit, and regulate, and tax your way to an over-supply of housing." Of course you can - you just tax tenants not landlords. If you apply a $10,000 per month tax on every rental property paid by the tenant there would be an oversupply of rental housing even in SF. The real question is should LA be growing by 20,000 people per year.