3 ms·
It's not justice when we put the victim on trial (As we do in most rape cases), but we do it anyway.
by vkou 10y ago
It's not justice when we put the victim on trial (As we do in most rape cases), but we do it anyway.
- hueving 10y agoSo you are implying that makes it okay to assume everyone accused is guilty for all intents and purposes?
- tptacek 10y agoI feel like lots of people here are patting each other on the back about a snipey "innocent until proven guilty" argument they've derived by cutting one of this post's sentences in half. No, this post does not say it's "okay to assume everyone accused is guilty for all intents and purposes".
- PavlovsCat 10y agoNo, those two comments are simply asking. Which is fair enough, seeing how the comment doesn't say why that is "not justice", or any different from other witnesses/victims in other trials getting asked questions.
- guitarbill 10y agoThis is flat out wrong. In the US/EU, you can't be put on trial for being a rape victim. What offence would that be? Complete hyperbole.
- vkou 10y agoRead any rape trial transcript, or even an account of someone who took their assault to trial. Read the questions asked the victim. They are invasive and degrading, and they are intended to paint them as scandalous, lying, drunk, promiscuous skank. Your personal and public credibility will be put under intense scrutiny. The accused then takes the stand, and insists that yes, you clearly consented to being assaulted at 2 am behind a dumpster, when you were too drunk to speak. And if, heaven forbid, the case falls apart, you'll likely be sued right back for slander, damaging your attacker's public image, loss of income, etc. That's the defense's job in an adversarial legal system. That doesn't make in any better for victims.