5 ms·
Slavery has been illegal in the US for about a century and a half. The answer is, of course, "yes." If an employer doesn't like that, then they should make sure
by mikeash 10y ago
Slavery has been illegal in the US for about a century and a half. The answer is, of course, "yes." If an employer doesn't like that, then they should make sure their people are motivated to stay. Warning: this may involve paying them more.
Certainly you shouldn't unless you have a really good reason. If you just can't agree about the new product name, you should definitely give notice. If they handed you a gun and ordered you to kill a customer, quit on the spot.
A lot of employees are loyal to companies, not so much the other way around. They're both quite similar: when a loyal employee thinks about quitting, they worry about the impact it'll have on the company. When the company sees someone quit (or fires them), they too worry about the impact it'll have on the company.
- kafkaesq 10y agoWarning: this may involve paying them more. Though much of the time it should suffice to simply not treat them horribly. Difficult though that may seem for the management circles of certain organizations.
- mikeash 10y agoYes, at some places the idea of treating employees decently may inspire even more horror than the idea of paying them more.
- p4wnc6 10y agoThis has been my experience in every job that I have had (4 in total). I've suffered severe career burnout basically wholly because my working experience leads me to believe there is no such thing as a company that treats employees with even a minimal level of acceptable decency, at least in the U.S. (I have no experience working elsewhere). In my early career I was foolish enough to believe this was just a symptom of earning your stripes or paying your dues. In the first professional job in which I gave two weeks' notice, I worked my tail off during those two weeks to clean up several lagging code repos, write a bunch of badly needed tests, polish off a deliverable for an important system, and write copious documentation detailing step-by-step how to handle any of the little ad hoc things that I had to do on a weekly or monthly basis. On my final day, I even worked an hour late (until 6 pm) furiously giving a tutorial on some of that last-minute work. I was literally sweating in my shirt when I collected my last items and walked to the elevator for the final time. Months later I came to find out that a former colleague at that firm had given a negative review about me (a very petty action related to being upset about my choice to leave) to another employer when I was interviewing. Now I feel it is completely unsafe to ask them for any kind of reference or recommendation. So much for really pouring myself into the role and trying, even literally to the final minute, to be an exceptional employee for them...
- billmalarky 10y agoThere's always a good chance you could work with some of your old peers at a new company. They aren't necessarily going to forget the way you acted when you left. Honestly two weeks notice isn't about the company at all, it's about the people you work alongside (including your boss). The company will do just fine regardless, but your co-workers have to pick up the extra slack.
- p4wnc6 10y agoYes, but if the company is treating you badly, you don't owe it to your coworkers to continue enduring that for their sake. If they really value their professional relationship with you and if they respect you, they will certainly understand that you can't be expected to subject yourself to two additional weeks of poor treatment just for their sake -- and neither should you expect that from them if they determine that the company is treating them badly and they need to quit. It is not you who has made the coworkers pick up extra slack via your choice to quit without notice. It is the company that has given them that extra burden by placing you in a situation where the only healthy option was to quit without notice. Thoughtful colleagues will understand that the company is to blame for this kind of thing, not the worker who did not give notice. In cases when someone was treated well and simply did not give notice for some extrinsic, selfish reason (like being offered a sign-on bonus to start immediately at a new firm or something), it will be pretty obvious to everyone that actually the company had treated them well.
- joe563323 10y agoRight point.
- a3n 10y agoThe higher skill a job requires, the less impact quitting without notice should have on colleagues, with respect to "pick up the extra slack." As far as I can tell from reading around, it's going to be a long time after even a two week notice before a replacement is in place (if at all). You should probably send emails to people about what's where, etc. Or try not to have loose ends. And I can understand colleagues feeling snubbed without a goodbye, much less a happy hour. I'm not advocating without notice, but when it happens, around "here," I just don't see much of an impact.
- joe563323 10y agoStill pay matters. If the office looks nice, food is free, the project is cutting edge but for-profit, but salary mediocre then quit. Pay matters
- alva 10y ago'A lot of employees are loyal to companies, not so much the other way around.' Recognising and then losing this mindset is so important. Many of my younger friends who have only been employed a few years appear to have fierce loyalty to their employers. So many have sacrificed salary for essentially worthless options. They appear less likely to ask for a raise, assert their rights to reasonable work hours, dissent to a bad work environment. The best way I have found for avoiding this is reducing the idea of your job into a very simple transaction, taking the view of a consultant. You have problems that need solving and will pay. I will solve those problems for pay. When seen as purely transactional, I believe the individual feels more empowered and avoids the loyalty trap.
- dpc59 10y agoI lost jobs as a teenager because I had that "transaction" mentality.
- yardie 10y agoMost of the jobs I've lost as a teenager were because of normal teenage things like SAT/ACT/AP exams. Like they really wanted me to value the job more than my future. Another thing they liked to do was change the schedule after publishing it. But it's my fault for not checking the schedule everyday.
- draw_down 10y agoYes, I agree. Loyalty to your employer is a mug's game.