5 ms·
Out of the blue comments like this without any context or information are worse than useless. Many, if not most people have no idea about SolarCity's business
by colordrops 10y ago
Out of the blue comments like this without any context or information are worse than useless. Many, if not most people have no idea about SolarCity's business model, so all this does is negatively bias people against them for no reason other than an anonymous stranger's bare opinion. You may be right, but until you give some supporting facts, you are only hurting the discussion.
- jonknee 10y agoPontificating that a name change will really turbo charge SolarCity isn't exactly contributing to the discussion either. SolarCity is an awful business because it loses a huge amount of money. Go look at their financials, it's beyond ugly. https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ASCTY&fstype=ii&ei=p7RpV5GhD6uUigLKj6qQCQ https://www.google.com/finance?q=NASDAQ%3ASCTY&fstype=ii&ei=...
- cryptoz 10y agoLooks like SCTY's revenue is climbing every single quarter. Not sure how that is "beyond ugly" - the vision is a solar-powered world and their revenue is growing. They are losing a lot of money too, yes, but that does not mean the business is "ugly".
- underdown 10y agoTheir quarterly LOSSES are also growing, not typically the sign of a healthy company.
- jusben1369 10y agoI think it's been proven that "losing an awful amount of money" does not equal "an awful business" It might - but that alone is not proof. Many businesses invest (pour more money in during an early phase than they make) and end up doing really well.
- tostitos1979 10y agoSorry .. I disagree and upvoted the parent. If you keep up with the news, you'll see many articles on SolarCity's challenges: http://watchdog.org/225430/solarcity/ http://watchdog.org/225430/solarcity/
- unusximmortalis 10y agook, then please provide links and data to back up your statements
- revelation 10y agoThat's the kind of link that can never support a point but serves only to discredit whoever posts it. It's a fake grassroots news organization funded entirely by a 501(4)(c) with a fixed political agenda.
- Karunamon 10y agoPolitical agendas discredit truth now? In the time it took you to detail the supposed biases of the link (which you didn't back up yourself, mind) and post a throwaway shoot-the-messenger comment, you could have read and understood whether the arguments they put forward are persuasive and correct, something with infinitely more value. The tl;dr: * SolarCity is massively in debt. True. * The solar industry as a whole, including SolarCity, has a tricky future since government subsidies are sunsetting soon. True. * SolarCity acknowledged those risks and others, and disclosed them to the SEC. True. * A promient Wall Street advisor rated their stock a "Sell" based on all this. True. I see nothing in that article that is misleading, non-factual, or even a question of interpretation of unarguable facts. I'm all for pointing out when a source might have a bias, but that absolutely does not invalidate what they have to say or "discredit" its poster.
- revelation 10y agoSee, it's working :) SolarCity is massively in debt .. because that's their whole business. They take money from banks or companies like Google and invest it in solar projects, expecting a reliable return for them and their investor. Debt is the whole point. Government subsidies are sunsetting as solar is getting exponentially cheaper. It comes down to selective reporting. The "risks reported to the SEC" are classic fodder for reporters trying to make a story out of nothing. For purely legal reasons, companies will enumerate in the 10-K even the faintest risks to their business to preempt any claims.