3 ms·
Your reply might be inadvertently equivocating on meanings of "request", although I can see an interpretation where you're right. Bear in mind that in many gov
by schoen 10y ago
Your reply might be inadvertently equivocating on meanings of "request", although I can see an interpretation where you're right.
Bear in mind that in many government data requests, the government is really demanding or instructing someone to provide the data, in a manner calculated to make the recipient think that complying is not optional and that refusing to comply would be punished.
In other contexts, the courts have at least created suppression remedies when law enforcement agents order people to do things that aren't really legally required. And if you as a private party make an improper legal demand of someone, there could be a legal remedy against you just because of that (although maybe that falls under "[t]he law is then there to step in when there is a dispute").
I think there are also cases where people have maintained civil rights challenges against law enforcement officers who gave improper orders (for example, improperly ordering someone to stop doing something -- like photography!). I would think the legal system could pay attention in a broader range of situations to the difference between law enforcement requesting people consent to something and making people believe that they have no choice.
- nostrademons 10y agoThere's always an alternative to the government demanding something: lawyer up and take it to the courts. There are very real pragmatic problems regarding the expense and distraction to an organization that may be struggling on the margin of survival anyway, and additional principle-agent problems when this organization is not personally hurt by complying with the FBI's request but is instead acting on a customer's behalf, who will probably never know that the request was made in the first place. But those are the problems that the article is proposing to solve, probably through an organization that serves as a clearinghouse of information and legal assistance to small companies that need to handle customer data but don't necessarily have the resources to fight such a battle themselves.
- voxic11 10y agoEven if you take it to court, the statute that authorizes judicial review of NSLs restricts the authority of the judicial branch to engage in judicial review. Instead of being able to strike down NSLs for any reason that a court may determine is unlawful, under the statute courts may only overturn gag orders if the court finds “that there is no reason to believe that disclosure may endanger national security of the United States, interfere with a criminal counterterrorism, or counterintelligence investigation, interfere with diplomatic relations, or endanger the life or physical safety of any person. So no you cannot always just take it to court. In many cases it may be illegal to do so.
- marcoperaza 10y agoI'm don't think that's an accurate interpretation. Congress can't just add a line to every statute to exempt it from judicial review. Even if they tried, the courts would just ignore it as they have done before.